1. Unions are great and everyone should be part of one. Anyone who points out the bad parts of unions is an evil conservative and hates the middle/lower class.
2. Unions are evil and cause nothing but problems. Anyone who supports unions is a fool who doesn't see the horrors they cause.
Any discussion that includes the viewpoint that unions have both good points and bad points (as you allude to above) has a high likelihood of being attacked by _both_ sides.
It also doesn't help that it appears to very hard to actually set things up so that you get the good sides of a union without also getting the bad sides.
the works council (aka 'company codetermination') involves employee elected colleagues in company leadership decisions like during, hiring, reorgs, raise distribution, working hours, shift planning guidelines, ... while the unions focus on salary and compensation negotiations
Frankly, anyone who raids PCA funds the way they do is evil, plain and simple.
That being said, there will always be some need for collective bargaining. I only wish it were possible to limit these extreme union grabs for power.
https://www.cato.org/commentary/americas-ports-problem-decad...
This is exactly why Milton Friedman was against unions. Unions would eventually evolve into this amalgamation that only protects the union and its contributors while disallowing other qualified workers from getting jobs at the respective companies.
This is why we need more PPP (private-public-partnerships) here.
Just look at the MTO. It use to be an absolute cesspool or inefficiency which would make the old USSR envious.
Drivers license expired? Time to go stand in line where there are two tellers and 6 people "on break" in the back. The lineup is out the door, but who cares? Certainly not the union slugs who work there.
They finally introduced kiosks, which charged a "convenience fee" (probably at the request of the unions).
Fast forward, there is now a PPP in place for the MTO. Automation all over the place, you can renew your license online (FINALLY).
if not for the ability to step away from their union staff, none of this would have taken place. The union fights changes which leads to efficiency as this often means job losses.
Any "tech" the government builds looks like it was done by high school students and it is a shame they pay for this garbage.
Again, imagine you went to your bank site, and it looked like it was built 10 years ago and never been updated?
Just saying it doesn't have to work that way.
I worked for ~2 years as a contractor for a government entity in Canada. ~3500 headcount of employees. What I observed there was sickening. This was a place that had white-collar unions for all non-management employees. This union had completely hijacked the mission of this institution. It was no longer about serving the people that this entity was created to serve, but rather to protect the union and its contributors.
The software we were in charge of writing had direct, material impact on the physical and mental well beings of people in the province. Life and death. And at times I saw things like a deployment of features being delayed by weeks/months because a union member who was responsible for _manually_ deploying the changes was on vacation. To automate that deployment meant automating a union employees job and was impossible. These features directly served the needs of people that were in critical need of them.
On the other hand, I have family friends who work for UPS and other delivery services and see the brutal toll it takes on their body and mind. Pushed to absolute limits and exploited because they don't have a union.
But to me, it seems unions can and often do exploit people. After witnessing all of this I've developed a very dim view of humanity. We all just want to exploit someone.