IMO, anyone who deprecates themselves from an important role within a team has successfully scaled themselves in a very interesting way (same output, but person is free to do other things). Such a person would seem very valuable and destined to scale in even more interesting ways.
If someone came into a highly-demanded (by the team itself) role and turned the responsibilities around into work the team can take care of on its own, that's valuable work for sure. But if this was just a role created by an executive as a result of, "We've always needed one of these", then maybe not so much.
You can create organizational chaos by skipping that last step, you may even achieve job security. But it's blatantly obvious to both your managers and coworkers if you fight to keep them off your turf. Don't expect respect or admiration.
Absolutely not. The jobs that are the most respectable are the ones where your job is to put yourself out of a job. Management can be a noble profession because of this.
I 100% agree they have scaled / transcended their “job” at that point.
Don't manage your work from a place of fear. If you really don't want to be promoted, that's fine. I respect people that have that opinion. But don't try to ensure job security by slowing the organization down to reassure yourself you're too essential to replace.
This is a strange comment, considering the person asking the question IS the mom.
Secondly, I feel like your entire argument around the extra work the team will face (and the idea that the team being fine with them gone means they provide no value) has an unstated premise; that the amount of work the team has is constant and can't be changed.
When a team member is gone, we expect the team to be less productive. The team and company should plan for this, and commit to less work during the period. The idea is that the team should GRACEFULLY reduce their workload, and not grind to a halt completely.
Good luck making that work at a lean startup or for a team that is already understaffed.
if you're indispensable, you're unpromotable
I can see your point in the case where the person does nothing already, leaves, and it has no impact. But in the top-comment where this happens specifically _because_ the person deprecated themselves then that person has definitely shown how valuable they are.
If they can do that well you know they'll fit in anywhere. You should definitely fight to find a place for them when they come back.
First off, yes, I agree with the notion that you should take the leave, and that being with your children at this time is much more important than work. That said, here is how I've seen other folks handle it:
1. If possible, especially for paternity leave, I think it's a good idea for both your team and your family if you can break up some of your time, e.g. take a month or two now, then come back to work for a month or two, then go back off for a month or two. Many folks have family that will help with the kids in the early days, so it was helpful to always have a extra pair of hands at home for the mom during the first half year or so.
2. Your team will feel the burden of extra work when you're on leave, but I think it's good just to recognize that and set things up as best as possible beforehand. Sometimes people get sick, or people leave for other reasons. Mat/pat leave is just one more thing people and businesses need to learn to handle, and (and I say this as someone without kids), even a small team will have to learn to deal with these "curve balls" at one point or another. You shouldn't feel guilty for taking your leave, just like one shouldn't feel guilty for getting sick.