News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by w1ntermute on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @09:59PM (#3268547)
> A truly open facet of Android — the open-source codebase, minus Google’s apps — has enabled one company with a strong market position to step in, effectively close it, and make themselves the gatekeeper. And as gatekeepers go, Apple looks quite benevolent by comparison.

Wow, he's almost as bad as Gruber. Why is someone who admittedly has little to no experience with Android (because he despises it so much) making predictions about its future?

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by benatkin on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @01:56AM (#3269114)
> Why is someone who admittedly has little to no experience with Android (because he despises it so much) making predictions about its future?

I'm pretty sure that the average technically-inclined Android user knows more about the Android than the average technically-inclined iPhone user. But Marco's experience building and successfully marketing mobile apps skews it quite a bit.

Also it's quite common to be familiar with something you despise, for instance in war people become familiar with the enemy.

Finally, to answer your question, he made the prediction because he thinks a lot. He shared it because he didn't see anyone else saying it. If numerous Android experts were already saying it, I don't think he would have bothered.

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by fpgeek on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @10:07PM (#3268567)
Indeed. He casually dismisses side-loading before claiming Apple is a relatively benevolent dictator, completely forgetting (or not realizing) that (among other things) side-loading is how the Amazon Appstore got started in the first place.
Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by ianstormtaylor on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @12:14AM (#3268857)
Are you really trying to suggest that the majority (or even a decently sized minority for that matter) of Kindle Fire owners will know how to and actually go to the trouble of side-loading apps onto their device? Just like a majority of iPhone users don't install their apps through the App Store... oh wait.
Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by bookwormAT on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @06:55AM (#3269738)
I remember all these people who told me that no web browser will ever gain market share on Internet Explorer, because "Dude, it's preinstalled on their computers" and "people don't even know what a browser is".

I sometimes wonder how the world would look like today if Steve Ballmer had the power back then to simply reject Firefox. Or if Apple had to ask Sony for permission to release a new smartphone.

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by fpgeek on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @02:02AM (#3269129)
Side-loading on the Kindle Fire is no harder than it is on your typical Android phone. A significant portion of Kindle Fire owners will side-load apps if someone gives them an incentive to.

Given that, I expect that side-loading on the Kindle Fire will be as insignificant as side-loading has been on Android phones. After all, it isn't like phone side-loading helped a company build an app store that they later married to their other content services to make a rich ecosystem for a new tablet, now is it?

Oh, wait...

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by andrewfelix on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @01:39AM (#3269072)
Also a very US-centric take. Apple and Android Market apps are available outside of the States. As of today I still can't get legitimate access to much of what Amazon has to offer (I'm in Australia)
Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by airlocksoftware on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @12:17AM (#3268869)
Seriously. This is a completely ridiculous prediction. I'm not saying it's actually likely, but I see a greater chance that things will go the other way: i.e., Amazon will open up the Fire (or future devices) to work with the Android Market.
Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by rbarooah on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @05:17AM (#3269515)
What's your reasoning for it being 'ridiculous'?

It seems reasonably that the fire could outsell all the other Android tablets combined by 2x, possibly even in its first quarter of existence. Amazon has a great brand and distribution channel, and the Fire is very good value for money.

It also seems quite reasonable to suggest that Fire owners may well purchase apps at a significantly higher rater than other Android tablet owners or even Android phone owners. Why? Because the Fire is all about buying content, and the apps are presented in the same context. Also, Amazon's store may work better than the Google's one.

These aren't foregone conclusions, but they seem quite reasonable.

If these two things work out, then Amazon's app store could easily end up being the channel for most Android app revenue.

Then, it would be an easy decision for app developers to target the Amazon store first.

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by phaus on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @07:20AM (#3269792)
Yours is an even more ridiculous prediction. In October the total estimated number of Android tablets sold was 6 million. I'm not sure if this figure includes the Nook color but if it doesn't then that would take it over 9 million. I don't think it is at all reasonable to suggest that the Kindle Fire might sell 12-18 million units in it's first quarter.

Due to the rumors that Amazon has two more Kindle Tablets coming out in 2012, I'd say there's a better chance that the Kindle Fire will never sell 12-18 million before people lose interest in the original model.

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by rbarooah on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @08:30AM (#3269936)
I didn't make a prediction so save the insults.

Where do you get that 6 million figure from?

The nook doesn't include the Google app store, so if 6 million includes it then the relevant figure is much smaller, and if it doesn't then you're 9 million number is irrelevant.

And you're supporting Marco's argument by suggesting that Amazon will soon produce some even more compelling tablets.

The only point here is whether Marco's prediction that Amazon may end up in control of Android App distribuition is 'ridiculous'. It clearly isn't, and you haven't shown otherwise.

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by phaus on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @09:08AM (#3270035)
"It seems reasonably that the fire could outsell all the other Android tablets combined by 2x, possibly even in its first quarter of existence. Amazon has a great brand and distribution channel, and the Fire is very good value for money."

I was referring to this statement. I rather like Amazon and the Kindle Fire, I just don't see them selling 2x the total amount of Android tablets that have been sold thus far.

If you weren't including all other android tablets when you made your comment, then you shouldn't have used the phrase "all the other android tablets combined."

The 6 million tablet figure is an estimate from Andy Rubin.

http://www.androidauthority.com/there-are-over-6-million-and...

As far as Amazon taking over app distribution, I don't think that it will happen. As stated elsewhere, there are many more phones than tablets, and that isn't going to change. While Amazon's alleged Kindle Phone may be as big of a success as their tablet, it still won't represent a large enough market to matter to Google.

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by rbarooah on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @09:25AM (#3270080)
Fair enough, neither of us were particularly precise. The rubin figure will undoubtedly count anything that can possible be called an Android tablet, including the nook.

That said, what matters is not how many devices are sold. It's how many app buying customers adhere to each store, and how much they spend. The vast majority of android phone owners are not buying apps.

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by phaus on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @09:47AM (#3270154)
"That said, what matters is not how many devices are sold. It's how many app buying customers adhere to each store, and how much they spend. The vast majority of android phone owners are not buying apps."

This is true. I have been using android since the G1 launched, yet I have probably only spent about 50 dollars total on apps. When I see an app that I want or need, I purchase it. I've purchased 4 different PDF readers in order to find the best one. (not including the PDF reader that came with docs to go) Unfortunately there just isn't much that I would need even on Google's own market.I would probably buy a lot of games, but there's only a couple on the market that are worth playing.

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by EwanToo on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @06:19AM (#3269656)
The Kindle Fire could outsell other Android tablets combined by 10x, and it'd still be outsold 10x by Android phones, and that's what makes it fairly ridiculous.

It's not that the Kindle Fire isn't a great product, it's that it's not relevant to the primary Android market - cheaper smart phones for the 99% of people around the world who can't afford an iPhone.

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by rbarooah on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @07:16AM (#3269785)
It would be interesting to see what proportion of apps are bought by people who buy the low end Android phones that are actually cheaper than iPhones. I suspect the answer is not many.
Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by EwanToo on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @08:16AM (#3269898)
True, and that's where the "missing leg" of Amazon's current Android strategy comes in - they don't have an ad network to support free apps, unlike Google.

There's definitely going to be people who don't buy apps, and who don't install many in the first place, but for those who don't want to buy them (or don't have a credit card, quite common in most of the world), free ad-supported apps need to be in place.

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by rbarooah on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @08:39AM (#3269957)
I'm a bit uncertain about this.

If people can't afford to buy apps, can they afford a data plan, or to buy the advertised products?

I certainly think there's a necessity for free apps. I'm just not sure that there's any necessity for ad-supported apps.

Don't get me wrong - I'm certain that there are a lot of people who like to choose advertising supported products. I'm just skeptical that it's out of economic necessity.

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by EwanToo on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @09:04AM (#3270021)
It's not necessarily that they can't afford to buy apps, but that they live in an economy where credit/debit cards (and even bank accounts) aren't that common.

Most of Africa's like this, same with a lot of Asia - Visa and Mastercard have very little footprint there. Instead people use cash to buy pre-paid access from their mobile carrier.

You're right there's a question around what kind of adverts you'd display to them though.

Re:Prediction: Amazon will take over Android app distribution by dlikhten on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @10:33AM (#3270313)
TBH I can't stand the amazon app store. The only reason it's still installed is because I have like 2 free apps that I use daily (SwiftKey X and sometimes QuickOffice Pro) the free apps mostly suck anyways, and the annoyance generated is extreme. Google market's superiority is pretty big. Problem is that its not Amazon.