The balance of the penalty was punitive damages, which are intrinsically expressive; you can disagree with them, but they have nothing to do with how much the business was worth.
$36m is rational from an economic perspective. It's a giant slap on the wrist to a) stop them doing it again and b) stop others doing it again.
If you don't have punitive, a wealthy person(/business/organization) can do something awful to a poor person which causes them great harm (e.g. $50k) but the rich person can easily afford.
That's because it's not just from an economic perspective. It's for damages but also punishment. The original award was $11 mil in damages, plus $33 mil punitive, and then also $6.5 mil legal reimbursement. The punitive got reduced on appeal to $25 mil.
Punishment is necessary because if suits were limited to damages, then people would break the law much more often, since suits aren't always brought and don't always succeed.
A punitive amount that's a little over double the economic damages is very reasonable. That's the whole point of the punitive part.
> something else is going on here... Conservative news outlets...
The idea that this is political or biased seems totally unsupported. This is just how the law works.
The revenue of Oberlin does seem much more relevant than the revenue of the bakery here to me.
It's really tricky and I personally feel that number is appropriate to fine a university considering they have no issue taking loans with zero conscience. Gladly accept 50-200,000 from 18 year olds with limited life experience. The judgement is fair
> The Gibsons note that the jury initially awarded them $11,074,500 in compensatory damages and $33,223,500 in punitive damages. They assert that the jury’s punitive damages award represents less than three percent of Oberlin’s total assets. Noting that the purpose of punitive damages is to appropriately punish and deter defendants, the Gibsons argue that a purely mathematical application of the caps thwarts those purposes. They also argue that applying the cap in their case bears no rational connection to the public welfare or a rational connection to Oberlin’s wrongful conduct. They further argue that the punitive damages cap violates their right to a trial by jury.
That makes sense to me. If Oberlin just had to pay <$1m then what's stopping them from continuing this behavior in the future.
[1] https://via.hypothes.is/https://oberlinreview.org/wp-content...
[2] https://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/9/2022/2022-O...
Gibson's is a small business targeting the lower end, with revenue likely in the low/mid six figures per year. It's like a convenience store which sells some groceries and baked goods. Coffee was near $1.00 in the mid 2000's. If someone were to sell Gibson's on a reasonable market, it would sell for less than 1M, I would guess more like 100k if you were to discount physical assets (which could be sold even after boycott).
36MM is completely absurd from an economic perspective. Instead, something else is going on here.
Conservative news outlets have made Oberlin a punching bag, and that must've percolated to this jury's award. It was meant as a political signal from biased citizens to punish Oberlin for being liberal in a now red-leaning state.