N=1, but I have an autoimmune disease that has reacted extremely well to lifestyle (stress & diet) changes after years of expensive drugs failing. Or regression to the mean happened. Or a recent solar flare fixed what was wrong with me. Nobody knows.
Doctors are great but they’re overworked and the amount of time required to truly help patients isn’t feasible. When science doesn’t have any easy solution to your problem self care (or tons of money) is the only option - which makes it awesome to see products like those in the OP! Hopefully it’ll be a step up from a lot of the snake oil self care out there.
You can't turn N=1 into N=100 just like that ...
I do hope someone will keep an independent scientific record of how this approach actually helps people (if at all).
There's a lot of money being made in the space of nutritional supplements at the moment, and yet there is very little evidence that any of them work at all. We shouldn't let the same happen here.
You're right - I probably shouldn't have used the language I did. In retrospect I see how it was confusing. I just meant to express how happy I was that healthy lifestyle changes were helping someone. :)
> I do hope someone will keep an independent scientific record of how this approach actually helps people (if at all).
Yes! We want to contribute to the scientific literature (e.g., by identifying new lifestyle interventions that help reduce inflammation levels) and do so in a validated way!
In the meantime, we base our service on existing scientific literature regarding which lifestyle interventions are associated with decreased inflammation levels: https://www.begolden.online/post/lifestyle-interventions-ass...
Changed my life in such a significant way. Doesn't hurt to try it.
You are correct that there are sources of inflammation that are not lifestyle related, but many of the drivers of inflammation are indeed lifestyle related.
I really like this article on the drivers of inflammation: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-019-0675-0
I particularly like Figure 1
https://www.begolden.online/post/lifestyle-interventions-ass...
There has been a surge in, for example, IBD in India recently [1], but by and large India did not have many of the inflammatory disease issue we had for decades. They had plenty of other diseases, but I wouldn’t be surprised if all the curcumin helped stave off certain inflammatory conditions.
I'm excited by your company, and will certainly be checking it out. Are there options for more regular testing? I'd like to establish baselines on my week to week or even day-to-day. I just dont want to figure out a lab to do my own testing.
Best of luck!
Eventually many people get the point that they realize diet alone can either dramatically reduce or eliminate symptoms.
Will it work 100% of the time, no.
Something like the autoimmune protocol diet is amazing at calming down inflammation.
There have been tons of companies doing things far more similar to Theranos' claims especially in the liquid biopsy space, without any negative association, partly because they bill themselves as biotech companies, and partly because their tech actually works.
The main reason Theranos was able to get away with what they claimed, was people in the industry knew what they claimed was approximately possible, just hadn't yet been done with the tech of the day.
11 years later, that tech has continuously improved. Biotech companies with interesting ideas about how to approach liquid biopsy and personalized medicine don't get extra scrutiny because of Theranos. The exception is if they are going for funding to people more familiar with Theranos than with biotech. Which is itself as much of a red flag as one needs.
Everyone I know in the industry has always said that what they claimed was physically impossible, tech be damned.
For some reason parts of the tech community always fall for this bullshit.
That said (you just knew there was going to be criticism :)
> Overall, we recommend healthy lifestyle habits versus drugs to manage inflammation levels.
Such a blanket recommendation strikes me as problematic: Which "lifestyle habits" handle the case where CRP is high due to things like (say) cancer? Or mold-toxicity? Or auto-immune issues?
In constructing the company, I assume there is a general counsel talented in medical liability, which strikes me as a minefield. I also assume the very public history of Theranos is also going to invite interesting scrutiny, even though you're running a legitimate operation.
Good luck to you in any case. Self-managed care should be an interesting space over the next decade imho.