News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by anon291 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @09:56AM (#32619066)
The supreme court applies the law.

I don't understand where this idea has come from that the court ought to be the provider of novel 'fair' legislation (as opposed to the mean legislation proposed by Congress) or the decider of punishments.

This law is set by elected members of Congress. It is their duty to provide proper punishments for it or to scrap it altogether.

It is up to the president to show mercy when someone faces a trial like this through his power of clemency.

Contrary to this article placing the blame solely with the judiciary, a case like this starts with the federal government starting a case. They don't have to.

The executive is the real one punishing us expats.

Stop making the court out to be some dictator.

Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by lumost on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:33AM (#32620110)
So if we have two broken branches of government, break the third?

In practice the relative power and authority of different branches of government changes over time. The US constitution is now the oldest still operable founding document, and was constructed at a time when the king held extensive influence over British governance.

If we say that no branch of government is allowed to be rational, then we’ll need a constitutional convention sooner rather than later.

Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by rayiner on Saturday August 27, 2022 @12:03PM (#32620423)
Applying the rules created by the other two branches is the Supreme Court’s mandate. What you’re advocating is breaking the third branch of government on the theory that the other two branches are broken and need to be worked around.

A “results” oriented society is a regression from a “rules” oriented society. We have that in Bangladesh—courts that do what they think is “right” instead of following the rules. It’s better than courts where judges take bribes or act in their personal self interest, but not as good as courts that rationally apply the rules. It doesn’t promote respect for the rule of law because people disagree on what’s just and right. But mostly they can agree on the rules and reconcile themselves to the results if they feel the rules were followed.

What a shamefully misleading article title! I’m shocked to see so many well educated Americans, who should know better, embrace such thinking. What I admire most about Americans is that they’ll jump off a bridge if a court tells them to and the paperwork is in order. That’s how you build a marvelous civilization.

Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by skissane on Saturday August 27, 2022 @06:58PM (#32624083)
> A “results” oriented society is a regression from a “rules” oriented society. We have that in Bangladesh—courts that do what they think is “right” instead of following the rules. It’s better than courts where judges take bribes or act in their personal self interest, but not as good as courts that rationally apply the rules.

Applying the rules is great when the rules seem mostly fair and reasonable.

When the rules, applied to a situation, produce a seemingly very harsh outcome – especially when there is no evidence their original authors would have actually wanted that outcome in this particular case – judges often look for ways to "bend" them.

Rather than something limited to countries such as Bangladesh – it is something which has happened time and time again in the history of common law tradition. If a judge feels that mechanical application of the law produces an unconscionable outcome, they will find a way to reinterpret the law, so it doesn't actually mean what it says on its face.

This especially happens when the judge views the aggrieved party sympathetically – far more likely for a well-respected businessperson who has received a seemingly disproportionate penalty for unintentional violations of the law, than a career criminal on death row.

Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by anon291 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:35AM (#32625801)
> When the rules, applied to a situation, produce a seemingly very harsh outcome – especially when there is no evidence their original authors would have actually wanted that outcome in this particular case – judges often look for ways to "bend" them.

The original authors of what? The original authors of the bills to tax expats actually did want these outcomes.

I actually disagree with the law, but the claim that the writers didn't intend for this is quite the stretch, as the law is extremely clear in the punishments, and if you read into the history, it's quite clear they wanted to punish people.

What may be a remedy by the court is if they believe the punishment is cruel or unusual or the fine excess. They may find that and strike down the entire law, but the law is certainly intended to do exactly this.

Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by selimthegrim on Sunday August 28, 2022 @11:21AM (#32629063)
Where did they get this suo motu idea from if not the British?
Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by rayiner on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:00PM (#32629385)
I don’t know if there is some precedent in the Mughal tradition or whatever, but maybe it’s British. It has a very “dispensing the King’s Justice” feel to it. But that’s always kind of been the equity side of the courts. The common law courts were famous for rigid decision making. And I’d argue that it’s even more important in a pluralistic society like America where we don’t have a State Church or monarchy to serve as an agreed upon count of wisdom and justice.
Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by anon291 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:30AM (#32625781)
I'm unsure what you're arguing for. The supreme court has no authority to be 'rational', if congress dictates otherwise. That's not its place.

American government gets its power from the people. If the people, via their representatives, act irrationally, then the government is irrational. no government is going to be perfectly rational. That's kind of the entire point of our constitution. I would highly recommend reading the commentary written by its writers.

Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by patrick451 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @12:07PM (#32620464)
Allowing the courts to legislate makes them broken. That is job of of congress.

Appealing to the age of the constitution to defend the courts arrogating power which that constitution did not grant is complete nonsense. If you want the courts to have that power, pass an amendment. If you don't want to do that but still want the courts to be able to create law, then bringing up the constitution is pointless. You have already tossed it in the waste bin.

Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by someguydave on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:40AM (#32620190)
>"If we say that no branch of government is allowed to be rational"

"rational" in this case meaning "unilaterally countermand the decisions of the other branches"

Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by patmorgan23 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:56AM (#32620349)
The constitution is not the founding document of the United States, that would be the articles of confederation. But the US constitution is one of the oldest operating constitutions In the world. Most either get rewritten after 50-100 years or get overturned in a revolution.
Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by anon291 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:36AM (#32625805)
No, the declaration of independence is the founding document of the United States, since before that no United States existed by anyone's reckoning, and after, someone certainly thought so. The articles were written way after, and formed the second federal government of the United States. The first was the continental congress.
Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by throw_m239339 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:08AM (#32619848)
> I don't understand where this idea has come from that the court ought to be the provider of novel 'fair' legislation (as opposed to the mean legislation proposed by Congress) or the decider of punishments.

Cause the legislative branch in US is in shambles, "can't" get anything done, at least that's the perception, as the country is divided to a point that both camps consider the other "the enemy", so everybody now relies on either the judiciary or the executive branch to makes laws. This is essentially a constitutional and political crisis, that has been going for the last 20 years in USA.

Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by patrick451 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @12:09PM (#32620491)
Gridlock in Washington is a feature, not a bug. The more gridlock, the fewer laws get passed. Unfortunately, there never seems to be much gridlock around spending money.
Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by anon291 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:37AM (#32625808)
Completele agree.
Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by aidenn0 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:03AM (#32619132)
Indeed, if the recent decisions by the supreme court have taught me anything, it's that Congress has been incredibly ineffective at passing legislation over the past 40 years.
Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by kurupt213 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:39AM (#32620170)
It took the recent decisions? Congress has almost completely abdicated its responsibility for decades
Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by someguydave on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:42AM (#32620219)
One reason for this is because the Supreme Court has deferred to allowing a great deal of legislating in the Executive. Congress passes "blank check" laws that require unelected career bureaucrats to make law ("regulation") with minimal oversight.

If the Supreme Court slowly disallows this, then Congress will eventually be forced to vote on controversial issues again.

Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by aidenn0 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @03:30PM (#32622282)
I don't think there's anything in the constitution that prevents Congress from delegating their power. I don't think the authors anticipated that elected officials would want to give away their power.
Re:Next, the Supreme Court Decides How to Punish US Expats by someguydave on Monday August 29, 2022 @08:56AM (#32637588)