News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by austinkhale on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @09:56PM (#32588474)
I really enjoy my 3D printer but the number of real use cases is fairly low in terms of day-to-day utility. This is exactly the kind of thing that makes me excited about the future of the hobby.
Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by RowanH on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @10:26PM (#32588678)
Use cases may be low, but when you find "the one" it's just nothing short of epic. For me it was my Sim Rig... needed a 3d printer to make the carrier blocks for the actuators, which then triggered a whole rabbit hole of designing & building a (slightly over the top) simulator*

The amount of stuff I've printed with it, km's and km's of filament and the little beast still keeps squirting out molten plastic. Last time I looked at the stats, 91 days print time, 6355m of filament.

One of the best tool purchases in the shed ever. Really stoked with it.

* https://www.rowanhick.com/motion-simulator

Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by t0mas88 on Thursday August 25, 2022 @05:30AM (#32591480)
Nice! I have a few 3D printed components for my sim racing setup, but it's only a few brackets and a custom face part for my VR headset. I've always done the 3D printing by uploading the design and having it delivered. That uses to be easily in the $ 10 per part kind of price range but recently there are higher minimum order prices (50 or 75 or so) everywhere.

What kind of printer do you have and what did it cost?

Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by ge96 on Thursday August 25, 2022 @12:36AM (#32589528)
It's great for robotics. Designing/printing parts of various shapes.
Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by dekhn on Thursday August 25, 2022 @12:09PM (#32595781)
I've had a lot of fun with my printer. Some days it runs almost 24/7 and then I don't use it for a while. Recently, I wanted to make a sliding barn door. Spent some time looking at the products online, then designed the same thing in Fusion 360, and after a few test prints, I had all the parts to make the door.

Similarly, all my shelf brackets are 3d printed now. THe thing that holds up my custom LED light is 3d printed. Some of the art I have around the house is printed...

Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by jnovek on Thursday August 25, 2022 @07:37AM (#32592325)
After 3D printing for years I started teaching myself how to use FreeCAD. It’s not the most newbie-friendly software but being able to design your own parts is incredibly powerful. I design and print parts for the most mundane tasks.

These days I find designing a part relaxing, similar to the feeling of writing code for a personal project.

Apparently Fusion 360 is also free for hobbyists, I’m guessing that it’s a bit easier to learn than FreeCAD.

(I realize that designing your own parts isn’t practical for most folks but I think HN is a good audience for this.)

Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by dceddia on Thursday August 25, 2022 @09:16AM (#32593290)
Came here to say the same, except so far I’ve been using Blender with the CAD Transforms plugin (mainly for the Sketch-like snapping abilities). I watched a few videos on Blender for Precision Modeling (search youtube) and started playing around.

I’ve been meaning to learn FreeCAD or one of the others because the parametric modeling seems useful, but Blender has been good enough for my purposes so far - mostly adapters for tool vacuum ports, and other little things around the house and workshop.

Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by dekhn on Thursday August 25, 2022 @12:11PM (#32595805)
I moved from FreeCAD to Fusion360 (I pay for a pro license) and the difference was astounding. Once I grokked the fusion360 model (which is both easier and more complex than FreeCAD) I was able to make forward progress very quickly. There are a lot of subtle little touches in the Fusion360 UI that make design easy.
Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by spoonjim on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @11:26PM (#32589104)
Really? This camera lens is essentially a POS. I find tons of real world use cases of my 3D printer and this isn't even the ballpark.
Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by 2muchcoffeeman on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @11:55PM (#32589292)
It's all relative. If you have a 3D printer and are just a hobby photographer, this is great. Super cheap. Mixes your hobbies.

But I agree that the real world uses of 3D printers are endless. Although often you need to know how to use CAD.

Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by spoonjim on Thursday August 25, 2022 @12:02AM (#32589341)
Owning a 3D printer without knowing basic CAD seems pointless beyond description.
Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by LASR on Thursday August 25, 2022 @12:39AM (#32589555)
Hard disagree. You’re forgetting the long tail of consumer-only usecases.

That’s like saying owning a computer without basic programming knowledge seems pointless.

Obviously 3D printers are useful even if you never create or modify 3D models.

Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by MezzoDelCammin on Thursday August 25, 2022 @02:36AM (#32590349)
Well, someone has to create the models. If You're lucky and there's plenty of good modellers in Your use case / hobby, good for You. Have fun printing.

What the OP however refers to is the "rapid prototyping" that 3D printers unlocked for masses. If You learn even some basic modelling (e.g. few primitives in OpenSCAD for programmers), it's trivial to do test fits and whatever gigs You need.

I haven't realized it myself until some months ago I needed a small funnel for a bottle. After some thinking I realized it's much easier/faster to throw together a difference of two cones and two cylinders in OpenSCAD in about 10min and print it in maybe another 20 than spend the time looking around stores to find some close compromise.

Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by jjk166 on Thursday August 25, 2022 @08:43AM (#32592946)
I think it's more like owning a computer without being able to use a text editor or a spreadsheet program. You can open files you get from other people but you can't make changes or generate anything original. Programming in this analogy would be modifying your printer itself.

Obviously there have been some successful computers where users don't modify their files, like mp3 players, but those are much cheaper and more user friendly than general purpose computers.

Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by johnandrews911 on Thursday August 25, 2022 @12:41AM (#32589572)
You can still download and print designs, so its certainly not pointless
Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by spoonjim on Thursday August 25, 2022 @01:33AM (#32589893)
I suppose, I just don't use it that way. Have never printed something that I downloaded except for testing purposes. I use the printer to make stuff that I need around the house, like a bracket to hold my electric toothbrush charger to the towel bar, etc...
Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by OJFord on Thursday August 25, 2022 @05:45AM (#32591551)
I check for well-designed looking ones first though, if it's not extremely custom (like the razor holder I designed to fit my specific razor over the side of my specific mug-like bathroom holder thing).

I found a nice looking bracket shaped specifically for my Bamix stick blender that someone else had designed, saved me some trial and error and time and filament.

I found someone else's design for a Makita LXT battery fitting that I used as the base to prototype the inverse: I wanted a dummy battery shape that I could mount to the wall in order to hang my vacuum cleaner from it.

I'm glad I can do some basic CAD / am willing to learn, but I've definitely got some use out of it with only a slicer. And then there are the people who only want trinkets anyway.

Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by dekhn on Thursday August 25, 2022 @12:14PM (#32595866)
Everybody should print digital sundial (https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:1068443) and watch escapement (https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:3364860) and finish the escapement assembly.

Those two projects made me realize that 3d printing can be a full time fun hobby for exploring all those things it would be too hard to machine in a garage.

Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by bilsbie on Thursday August 25, 2022 @07:31AM (#32592283)
90% of your ideas will already be on thingiverse. So still pretty useful.
Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by AYBABTME on Thursday August 25, 2022 @02:22AM (#32590255)
I've been enjoying using OpenSCAD whenever I can (instead of Fusion 360). The language is a bit janky but it's great for hacking something up in a purely procedural manner, and using Git.
Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by fho on Thursday August 25, 2022 @03:53AM (#32590859)
I would so love to use a free CAD software ...

OpenSCAD is fine for what it does and I do use it a lot for very simple stuff. ImplicitCAD is another interesting project in that space that has fillet unions.

FreeCAD would be great if the Interface wouldn't be so janky. I give it a try every now and then, but never really get over the re-learning aspect.

So, I am still stuck with Fusion360 running in a VM on my otherwise FLOSS-only system :-/

Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by VBprogrammer on Thursday August 25, 2022 @05:48AM (#32591569)
It will be interesting to see how constraint based modelling in Blender comes along. Seems like the most promising route at the moment.
Re:3D print and build a 164mm f/2.5 lens for less than $15 by andybak on Thursday August 25, 2022 @06:23AM (#32591790)
Isn't this intended to be a creative lens? "POS" is a bit harsh - I can imagine some gorgeous uses of this thing.