Don't buy into the contrapositive of the American Dream; the Dream isn't true, and so neither is its contrapositive.
I disagree with this, and in fact, it's my point.
I did study philosophy -- at uni. But I didn't learn about contrapositives in that class, I learned about it in a dedicated Critical Thinking course -- also at uni. I also took a couple of formal logic courses and a few psychology courses there, all electives, and none related to my career (except maybe tangentially in the formal logic of computation). I learned so much in these courses about not only how to think, but common ways people incorrectly think and how to notice and avoid that. I even learned theories of the neurology behind why some of those common mistakes happen, and the importance of each step in the scientific method regarding which of these fallacies each attempts to counteract.
Public K-12 education may fail to teach people how to think, but high-quality universities do not. Which is my point: higher education is so important and should be as accessible to as many people as possible if we're to create the best society we can for ourselves and others.
The world is a very hard place to live in and we do very little to prepare 18 year olds for adulthood. Can't get a job or afford a place to live on their own. God forbid they make a mistake. It's cruel and predatory to give them loans they'll be stuck with for the rest of their lives unlike any other type of loan.
Financially coddling those 22+ is doubling down on failing to prepare them for the future.
Thanks.
> It's a start in preventing predatory lenders
Doesn't loan forgiveness just encourage MORE lending? Does a rational person base their lending decisions on a chance of politically precarious one-off presidential forgiveness?
>trapping 18 year olds in loans they'll never get rid of.
Should we cancel child support debts for any 18 year old who knocked up a girl after she begged for it? Just trying to figure out when 18 year olds are allowed to be held responsible for their debts. A child is also a big gift and investment worthy of society investing in, so if education is worth society paying for without 'trapping' the 18 year old, then we can also excuse 18 year olds of 'predatory' child support.
----------
RE (below):
I can't help comment on the drop-dead-laughing hilariousness of suggesting these federal loans are 'predatory' while simultaneously you denied my suggestion that we eliminate this 'predatory' loan program. You want to perpetuate a program you find 'predatory' and possibly 'malicious' while encouraging EVEN MORE lending. Your refusal to consider cancel the debt of a guy who gets 'trapped' by a voluntary decision with a baby mama shows this has nothing to do with cancelling the poorly counseled debt of 18 year olds and everything to do with pandering to your favored group at the cost of the blue collar worker and his family.
The average person has more loans than were forgiven and the plan included more than just forgiveness. Again, it's a start.
> Should we cancel child support debts for any 18 year old who knocked up a girl after she begged for it? Just trying to figure out when 18 year olds are allowed to be held responsible for their debts. A child is also a big gift and investment worthy of society investing in, so if education is worth society paying for without 'trapping' the 18 year old, then we can also excuse 18 year olds of 'predatory' child support.
You're taking this to the extreme position that I want us to hold 18 year olds responsible for nothing ever. Also you seem to not understand that malicious contracts exist or that they can be invalidated even when signed. Maybe you just don't believe it's predatory in this case. IDK. Anyway, I refuse to entertain that student loans are comparable to child support so I'm done here.