News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Most Texans pay more in taxes than Californians, data sug... by whatever1 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:21PM (#32571701)
That’s bs. In Texas you pay just 1-3% property tax. That’s it.

Car registration is dirt cheap (<$100/year), housing is dirt cheap (200k get you a house with a swimming pool), electricity is super cheap (when it is not snowing) and gasoline is almost half price compared to California.

Re:Most Texans pay more in taxes than Californians, data sug... by dd36 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:25PM (#32571762)
There’s no such thing as a free lunch. It all comes from somewhere. Texas does a better job of obfuscating and shifts more of the burden to lower incomes.
Re:Most Texans pay more in taxes than Californians, data sug... by mbesto on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:30PM (#32571814)
You need to read the detail. If your home's value outpaces your wage increases (on an absolute basis, not for a like-for-like percentage), then you could pay more as a % of your income in TX than CA.

Let's say you bought a house for $100k 10 years in a small town in Texas. People start moving in, but you still only make $50k/year. Now your house is worth $500k. That 1-3% property tax still hits your income.

Re:Most Texans pay more in taxes than Californians, data sug... by jjk166 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:22PM (#32572368)
Yeah but in addition to your $50k/yr salary, you're gaining $40k/yr in home equity. You can sell your house and move to a cheaper area and pocket the difference. Of course if you're struggling with day to day expenses you probably can't wait for 10 years for a big pay day, but even this can be dealt with by financing.

Further, the big problem here is ridiculous growth in property prices. While obviously some areas do occasionally experience a few years of exceptional growth, it would be dumb to assume that any given area is going to 5x in property value in 10 years. Even if it did in the past, such growth should not be expected to continue in perpetuity. Over the long term, property appreciation rates average around 4% annually, over 10 years you ought to expect a 100k house to go up in value to 148k. By comparison, assuming a 3% raise every year on average and no job changes, someone starting at 50k/yr should be making 67k/yr after a decade. Under such normal circumstances, a 2% property tax with no income tax would have a tax to income ratio of 4% versus 12% for a 10% income tax and 1% property tax. The rate of change in tax to income ratio is better with the income tax, a 2% increase in 10 years versus a 10% increase, but still it takes 166 years for for the high property tax option to overtake the income tax option. While some people may get unlucky (if you can call your net worth skyrocketing unlucky), going with the high property tax option is objectively the better strategy.

Re:Most Texans pay more in taxes than Californians, data sug... by mbesto on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @07:53PM (#32573209)
Over 50 years, the difference is even more striking. After accounting for inflation, home prices have jumped 118% since 1965, while income has only increased by 15%, according to a separate report by online brokerage Clever Real Estate, based on Census data.

https://www.cnbc.com/2021/11/10/home-prices-are-now-rising-m...

Re:Most Texans pay more in taxes than Californians, data sug... by jjk166 on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:38PM (#32583858)
A 118% increase over 57 years is an average yearly growthrate of 3.8%.

Wages for equivalent jobs have been pretty stagnant for the past 50 years, but people personally tend to make more money year over year as they gain experience. Or in otherwords, a 25 year old right now is not much better off than a 25 year old 20 years ago, but a 45 year old right now is likely much better off than a 25 year old 20 years ago.

Re:Most Texans pay more in taxes than Californians, data sug... by reddog on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:06PM (#32572213)
That’s true. But you’re also $400,000 wealthier. So you got that going for you. Which is nice.
Re:Most Texans pay more in taxes than Californians, data sug... by briandrupieski on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:27PM (#32571784)
1-3% property tax seems to line up with their breakdown for property tax: https://itep.org/whopays/texas/

Looks like most of it comes from sales and excise taxes.

Re:Most Texans pay more in taxes than Californians, data sug... by hindsightbias on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:30PM (#32571815)
You aren't getting a $200K house with pool anywhere anyone on HN wants to live. The median house valuation in Frisco TX will reach $1M in a year or two.

And that's just a random suburb nobody outside of TX has ever heard of.

Re:Most Texans pay more in taxes than Californians, data sug... by dhd415 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:09PM (#32572251)
You're right that $200K won't buy a house with a pool in most desirable parts of Texas, but your quip about $1M houses in Frisco is misleading. Frisco is not just a "random suburb nobody outside of Texas has heard of." It's a very desirable suburb on the fast-growing north side of the DFW Metroplex.
Re:Most Texans pay more in taxes than Californians, data sug... by hindsightbias on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:53PM (#32572645)
There are dozens of burbs just like Frisco, and that’s just DFW alone.
Re:Most Texans pay more in taxes than Californians, data sug... by xienze on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:27PM (#32571773)
Yeah I’m really curious about the methodology here. Property tax is surely higher, but then again property values are a good bit lower. Income tax is certainly lower in TX (hard not to be). Sales tax I’d wager is lower in TX as well, at least on average. Not sure about utilities, but it’s not hard to have cheaper electricity than CA. Gas is no contest.

So what’s the angle here? Things that make you go hmmm…

Re:Most Texans pay more in taxes than Californians, data sug... by hindsightbias on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:37PM (#32571899)
It all rolls down the counties who have to pay for everything.

So they raise your valuation 20% a year (if you're in an avg market). For the last 10 years. And then the rate goes from 1.2% to 1.9% over the same time. And that doesn't even cover highway use, as they've all got tolls now.

With no Prop 13, anyone who picked the right hood as poor or middle class can no longer afford to stay.