News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by sudden_dystopia on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:50PM (#32567633)
Big mushroom fan. But isn’t all the sodium and crap they add to it to make it taste like bacon, mostly what makes bacon unhealthy to begin with? The saturated fat aspect is debatable or at least not completely settled.

I don’t eat bacon much anyway so I definitely wouldn’t eat this on a consistent basis due to all the sodium but I’d try it for the novelty.

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by KMnO4 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:54PM (#32567703)
I think their target demographic is vegetarians/vegans who are trying to reduce their footprint or use of animal products.

> consumers will likely be willing to give it a shot—especially knowing that it’s easier on animals and on the planet.

The ultra-health-conscious will still probably avoid it. Oreos are also vegan and not very healthy.

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by novantadue on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:19PM (#32568058)
Seems a lot cheaper to grow mushrooms than raise pigs.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by horsawlarway on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:27PM (#32568178)
Possibly - but pigs are fairly hardy, and have very few dietary limitations, so you can often buy very cheap feed, or just let them forage.

Basically - outside of the cost of the land, pork is really cheap to raise, even for small farmers. As low as $0.64/lb for commercial production, and around $2.50/lb for small farmers and families.

Current mushroom production methods are FAR more expensive (just the spore cost can be $0.50 to $1.00 per lb).

This might scale to make it cheaper, but I'd be pretty surprised. Mushrooms require much more intensive care and handling.

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by idiotsecant on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:53PM (#32569491)
Depending on the species used mushrooms can be cultivated very, very, very cheaply. You only have to look at the average cost of agaricus mushroom per lb ($1.5 - $2) wholesale vs processed whole pork per lb ($6- $7) wholesale to see that. Mushrooms also have a much shorter supply chain in terms of inputs and much less water input.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by serverlessmom on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:34PM (#32569157)
Creating more spores from mushrooms is incredibly easy and cost effective, so is creating liquid culture which is a process that allows you to create huge amounts of mycelial growing base you can then introduce to more growth medium(corn syrup and water that's been sterilized).
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by brainzap on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:24PM (#32568123)
not sure man, mushrooms need food too. Pigs can eat waste, can mushroom eat waste?
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by ksaj on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:29PM (#32568199)
Pretty much by definition, that is what mushrooms and other fungi do.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by uoaei on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:27PM (#32568166)
The entire reason the kingdom funga exists is to eat waste. You may have heard that dead trees piled up for millions of years before fungi came along, whereafter they carved a new niche for themselves in the ecosystem and consumed the detritus. Life finds a way ;)
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by kamma4434 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @04:46PM (#32571244)
Fungi, not funga - it’s masculine not neuter.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by uoaei on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:23PM (#32571728)
funga is the name of the kingdom, a recent change to align with the now-accepted designations flora and fauna (and of course bacteria and protista). Fungi is the plural when referring to organisms (i.e., instances), I am rather referring to the kingdom (i.e., the category).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Funga

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by jbboehr on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:01PM (#32572162)
Seems like it has no historical usage[0] and is not a valid form of fungus[1], from what I can tell. Kind of a weird choice.

[0]: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/funga [1]: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/fungus#Declension

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by kamma4434 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:33PM (#32630201)
Thanks for the clarification. It’s still sounding ugly, like if someone decided that the kingdom of mugroomz would include multiple mushrooms, but I guess it’s too late to complain
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by binbashthefash on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:54PM (#32574801)
Oyster mushrooms grow on wood chips and old coffee grounds. Not exactly expensive.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by helsinkiandrew on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:09PM (#32567911)
> I think their target demographic is vegetarians/vegans who are trying to reduce their footprint or use of animal products.

Presumably that was a typo and you meant non vegetarians/vegans?

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by HeyImAlex on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:18PM (#32568044)
I think it was more describing the rationale of the specific vegetarians/vegans; some do it more for health reasons, some for environmental/ethical reasons.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by sirmike_ on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:27PM (#32568170)
I agree with your two points. It does seem to be targeted at a subset of folks and not the normies.

https://myforestfoods.com/myblog

They rebranded from Atlast Food Inc in that blog section. They also mention going after the "alt-meat market".

Nothing wrong with more choices. However, nothing will ever really replace bacon.

Begs another question of how well a food start up does vs tech ones.

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by presidentender on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:52PM (#32567679)
Whether it's any healthier doesn't really matter to me. I'm excited to be able to enjoy bacon without paying for the inefficiency of raising animals.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by horsawlarway on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:38PM (#32568330)
Don't really think that's going to happen. Pork is one of the cheapest meats you can raise.

Just the spore costs to produce a lb of mushrooms can rival the total cost to raise a lb of pork (commercial pork can be as cheap as $64/CWT carcass weight - so $0.64/lb. Mushroom spore can be as high as $1.00 in spore costs to generate 1lb of mushroom). Processing the meat will raise costs, but it's hardly like mushrooms have low care/processing costs (If you don't know, they often require clean room levels of care to ensure proper spores without contamination).

There's a reason white mushrooms (unsliced) goes for $4.49/lb at my local Kroger, and the boneless pork goes for $1.99/lb.

I don't see this ever being cheaper.

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by sibane on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:47PM (#32569388)
What do you mean by spore costs? Wouldn't most large scale farming operations work with liquid cultures based on live mycelium? Liquid cultures are easy to multiply and inject into pasteurized substrate with needles. Once the mycelium has taken over the growing medium, it also no longer needs to be kept in a fully sterile environment.

I'm not at all convinced a pound of mushrooms is worth that much more than pork. Are you sure it's not the meat industry subsidies that are keeping the price down?

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by VLM on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:57PM (#32570610)
There don't seem to be subsidies for Pork. There was a "Small Hog Operation Payment" last century that paid $10 per hog for the first 500 hogs sold by a farm, according to wikipedia, but they got rid of that a long time ago. That is well under 10% the sale price of a hog.

The problem mushrooms have is scale, much like spices. We can grow 20K acres of mechanized corn, but mushrooms are a little less mechanized. So its to be expected for mushrooms to cost as much as basil or cilantro per pound.

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by binbashthefash on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:58PM (#32574818)
It's the exact opposite where I'm at in the EU. I picked up 400 grams of king oysters from the market for 2 euros yesterday.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by c16 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:19PM (#32568062)
Sadly fake meat is just as expensive if not more expensive than meat.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by oblak on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:37PM (#32569213)
All fake meat products that I can find here in Bulgaria are considerably more expensive than meat. I an not saying impossible burger is more expensive than kobe stakes, though.

It's mostly speculation, imho, as people are willing to spend more on these products. Some of these things are just as bad, if not worse, than cheap real meat. Back in the before going full veggies, I've tasted some horrible things that should be illegal. I am baffled people are willing to eat factory chicken, pork, etc. Shit is disgusting even if you don't care about the horrible lives of all the animals

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by pvaldes on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @04:54PM (#32571357)
Fortunately, in fact. This protects the rights of the majority that want bacon and not fakesomething silently replacing their food overnight.

If the product is not meat, shouldn't be tagged as meat.

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by gillytech on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:32PM (#32568238)
Fungus != meat
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by boringg on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:35PM (#32570233)
The sodium isn't a problem. It's the saturated fat + the nitrates.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by boomchinolo78 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:01PM (#32567808)
Bacon is pretty unsaturated fat and thus quite unhealthy.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by VLM on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:16PM (#32569890)
lipid hypothesis was disproven a long time ago.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by hombre_fatal on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:48PM (#32570439)
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by nradov on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:39PM (#32570301)
Stop spreading misinformation with that old myth.

https://peterattiamd.com/how-did-we-come-to-believe-saturate...

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by hombre_fatal on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:58PM (#32570613)
Funnily enough the HN comment actually demonized unsaturated fat, not saturated fat.

But that link doesn't seem to contain any information.

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by nradov on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:45PM (#32568440)
Even the sodium in bacon isn't necessarily unhealthy. The issues with sodium causing hypertension and metabolic disorders are due to complex interactions involving genetics as well as intake of water, fructose, and other nutrients. So we can't say that "sodium = bad", or even that people should limit themselves to a particular maximum level of sodium intake (within reason).

https://peterattiamd.com/rickjohnson2/

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by VLM on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:22PM (#32570002)
With healthy kidneys the half life of salt in the body is about half a day, maybe less. Even with destroyed kidneys, excess will be emitted in sweat, assuming the patient exercises enough to sweat... The chronic high blood pressure problem comes from destroyed kidneys being unable to excrete the salt fast enough. Bacon being a rather low carb food (as long as you don't maple glaze it or whatever, which admittedly is delicious...) the problem kind of takes care of itself in that lower carb foods tend to be higher sodium but the lower carb levels result in less damage to the kidneys, and healthy kidneys are not bothered by sodium ...

The worst case scenario would be "foods" that are both salty and high carb, which is mostly junk food and fast food.

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by kuprel on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:43PM (#32568397)
I don’t understand why vegans try to mimic things. I have no problem eating vegetables and mushrooms but I would never eat bacon made of mushrooms. The devil deals in deception.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by Klonoar on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:10PM (#32568808)
Food is more than just nutrition; it’s culture and art and probably more. Substitutes are important for these reasons as they allow people to enjoy without violating their diet/ethics concerns/whatever.

They’re not harming anyone by existing so I frankly don’t see why this complaint comes up in every thread on the internet. Just don’t eat it if you don’t want it, meat isn’t going away.

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by coffee_beqn on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:04PM (#32571485)
It’s also really hard for most people to think of what to cook at the end of a long day. Meatballs and potatoes is the first thing that pops to my head and turning that into brussel sprouts and potatoes sounds unappetizing but impossible meatballs and potatoes is quite close especially if I add a sauce. I guess that’s the cultural imprint.

I do also care about the animals and the environmental impact and it’s just extremely naive to think that a large part of humanity would switch from meat-based diets to tofu and steamed veggies. People are lazy and like tasty easy things.

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by bee_rider on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:12PM (#32568826)
Me either. I'm not a vegan or vegetarian or anything. I do know some vegetarians who are also pretty confused about the imitation meat stuff. It is these companies coming up with these products, not the potential customers -- clearly the companies have customers, but their products aren't necessarily universally beloved, right? Maybe they just assume that creating a good replica of a popular meat product will result in a popular vegan product?

I wonder to what extent the customer base of these products is mostly curious people who are just dipping their toes in, not quite ready to take the plunge into veganism/vegetarianism. Or well-intentioned parents/friends who want to include vegans in things like cookouts?

I dunno. I'll observe that people who've successfully been vegan for a long time (the kind of recurring customers you'd presumably want) have been following their dietary restrictions that whole time, I guess they don't have an overwhelming hankering for bacon or whatever. But then I guess they are hard to address, if they are already happy!

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by serverlessmom on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:35PM (#32569185)
A lot of my vegan friends really enjoy the meat substitutes- I am a meat eater and the meat substitutes tend to make me pretty nauseous.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by bee_rider on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:21PM (#32569985)
My observations are based on pretty limited anecdotes, I certainly don't have enough info to make a robust argument.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by coding123 on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @08:23PM (#32587729)
These companies are marketing to the largest segment of vegetarians: the temporary ones.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by Tagbert on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @04:40PM (#32571182)
Meat substitutes are not really targetting vegans. The are aimed at meat eaters who what something healthier and / or reducing meat consumption. I am very much a meat eater but often have days where I eat vegan or days when I eat meat substitutes. The aim is to reduce climate impact and reduce dependence on animals while I am not will to completely eliminate meat.

We have completely eliminated ground beef from our diet and choose Beyond Beef instead as it tastes better. I have tried lots of bacon alternatives and most of them are disgusting.

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by hombre_fatal on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:08PM (#32569748)
It seems straightforward that someone who enjoys the taste of bacon but does not eat it (for ethical or health reasons) may still want to partake in the experience.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by Qem on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:01PM (#32568667)
Probably most vegans are converts, raised by meat-eating families, that later decided to adhere to a meat-free diet. The problem is, once your taste-sense and food preferences are conditioned in childhood, it's hard to change them as a adult. So people seek alternatives compatible with what they are used to.
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by brnt on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:53PM (#32572068)
Actually, I have found this difficulty is exaggerated. I moved country twice and maried from another still: all involved significant changes to my diet. Yes, there is a mental hurdle, but like learning languages, by doing it repeatedly, it gets easier. Also, the rewards are exploring tasty new food universes!
Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by boringg on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:37PM (#32570255)
It's not vegans who are the ones building this - I'm pretty sure its corporations who are looking to make money on veganism and the changing dietary habits of the populations.

Most vegetarians/vegans don't try and mimic food like this. Just want you to target your statement to the right people --> companies trying to make money on niche/high margin items.

Re:A new vertical farm will grow 3M pounds of mycelium a yea... by hombre_fatal on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @04:07PM (#32570733)
Well, you could say the same about all of the foods at the supermarket from Red Baron experimenting with new frozen pizza toppings to Big Apple coming up with new apple specimens to HEB trying out a new flavor of fizzy water.

With the growth of veganism in the west, it's not surprising that we will see more companies targeting them with novel food products.

It doesn't seem like there's any more conspiracy when it comes to alt-meat products than what underlies all of the products in the supermarket, especially all of the packaged goods.