I'm not trying to say you're wrong or that I even disagree, I'm just trying to point out that people should have different expectations with ebooks and physical books (like I mentioned in my other post which was downvoted). ebooks are awesome in some ways physical books are not (and they're lousy in some ways that they really oughtn't be).
The point I most strongly agree on is where you say this is in its infancy (like the browsers wars). The first ebook I read was on a Windows PocketPC in about 2000 and it sucked. The whole technology has gotten dramatically better and I expect it will continue to, but it's not more than about 10 years old, really, and only really started gathering steam within about the past 5 years. And I'm not saying "therefore we should all have low expectations" but I, personally, am willing to look at all the things that have been done well and focus more on those than focusing on typography or whether editing is immediately correct.
I buy ebooks because they're easier to see... The lousy formatting makes them less enjoyable to read in some cases, but seeing is a prerequisite to reading. I need the inverted screen and the ability to enlarge the text and view the book on a back-lit display.
I've also noticed that my daughter, age 9, has an easier time reading ebooks with the text size bumped up than she does printed books. In her case, it's not about eyesight, but the fact that larger text and fewer words on the page makes it easier for her to focus - she retains what she's read better. There may be a slight tendency toward dyslexia or something there. It's not sever enough to get a diagnosis, but there is some sort of little "glitch" there that both we and her teachers have noticed it.
Instant delivery is another nice feature. If I decide at 10pm that I want to start a new novel, I can have it in my possession by 10:02.
So ebooks offer many advantages in the realm of accessibility, and there are certainly many more books available in ebook format than there are large print editions, but the poor typography and high price are certainly annoying.
Why are books even OCRed to create ebooks? Do they not have the original digital copy of them to work from?
You would think the same people who design, manufacture, and market a product can have their shit together long enough to take some great beauty shots for e-tailers. But nope. The vast majority of vendors are so poorly organized, so bureaucratically frozen, that getting them to do anything that isn't already part of the process is like pulling teeth.
So, "please send us digital copies of this manuscript" is pretty much out of the question. The easiest way is to take a copy of the book, OCR it yourself, and then get the license to distribute it.
The customers would then be able to customize the font sizes/stylings, etc., and use those settings for all the ebooks they read.
So they're not willing to provide the original source files, or what?
> edits late in the process are made to the typeset InDesign files, after the structure has been lost.
Wow, they do this so haphazardly that they don't even bother to go back to the original Word file and add the same edits?
Is InDesign used for all books? I don't see why you would need it for something without any figures/graphs/tables. You could just use Word, and things would work out fine.
As for why OCR is used, just look at the range of books that are now available electronically. There are a lot of books from the 1980s and earlier that are now available as EPUBs. Do you really think that it would have been easier to use the source files off floppies? (Keep in mind that the floppies are, for the most part, long gone.)
How are reprints of such books achieved?
How about effectively dealing with ligatures?
I know that people like to harp on and on about how great LaTeX or InDesign are, and when it comes to complex layouts (particularly LaTeX if there are lots of referenced figures and InDesign for text wrapping, etc.), I agree. If you were writing a scientific article, I'd tell you to use LaTeX. If you were creating a magazine, I'd tell you to use InDesign.
But for your typical, text-only, fiction novel, the kind you're most likely to read on a Kindle? I don't think it really makes a difference.
I guess they could generate PDFs from Word files with Acrobat and shoehorn them into the process, but any publisher that is actually satisfied with doing that is bonkers.
(And even if they weren't, I would appreciate such examples.)
People make a big deal about how using Word will lock you into a certain format when they're storing their data on floppies or, even worse, rasterizing it and keeping just the PS. Seems like the latter is a lot worse than the former.
Typography is more art than science.
What is the incentive for better typography? Most books are like mini-monopolies (over the short term). If the typography of a book sucks and it sucks on all platforms, what is a consumer to do if they want to read the book? Fallback to print? Publishers probably don't mind that. It's true that all things being equal, typography could be a deciding factor for the consumer, but my gut says that in most cases the content is weighted much higher.
I think the platform could benefit from typography. A consumer may choose an iPad over a Kindle if the iPad had a better reputation for typography. But since there is _art_ involved it might not be economical for the platform to pursue it. Which is a better selling point: Our platform has 100 really nice books or our platform has 100,000 books?
As far as your final hypothetical goes I honestly do not know what answer you were expecting, but maybe that's the point?
I believe this is true in general. A few savvy people catch on that a product is better and it becomes a meme that others rely upon for their decisions.
I do not think that there are enogh savvy-typography-valuing-people to induce some market driving meme. If this was the case Word would have died many years ago...
I dont know - and neither does reddit/selfpublish . How does an author go from writing to generating books without encountering specialized (and expensive) typesetters?
The first piece of advice that self-published Kindle authors will give you is to have a beautiful cover - how do you design one and integrate it into your ebook generation workflow to get one nice little package ? Can I say that the publishers are fleecing us, when probably they are having to pay extra to make sure their ebooks look good on Kindle, Nook, Sony, etc. ?
The toolchain doesnt exist - and it is time for disruption.
Two printed paperback books, with their horrible sand-paper pages, pixelated fonts, and crease-forming covers... surely you can live with an out-of-place hyphen if you can live with a paperback.
It's not always the publisher's fault--I've developed a few ebooks for different platforms, and ebook readers today are where Mozilla and IE were around the IE5 browser wars. Developing a book that looks good across all platforms is difficult, if not impossible in some cases.
It wouldn't suck so much if we weren't paying almost the same price as a print book. Why would I pay ~$13 for a brand-new, often terrible-quality ebook (and a DRM'd one at that), when I could buy two print books for the same price, and get Amazon to ship them free to my door?