News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by Aeolun on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:43AM (#32560547)
Seems like small drones are the best weapon against big drones. Kind of curious that they seem to assume that the drone needs an operator. If I were defending against a drone swarm I’d want my drones to be piloted by AI.
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by adrianN on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:26AM (#32561132)
Perfect micro matters a lot when you zergrush your enemies: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IKVFZ28ybQs
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by mgdlbp on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:29PM (#32571803)
AlphaStar's blink stalker micro, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUTMhmVh1qs&t=5888s

with capped actions-per-minute and reaction time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18992698

Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by MaxikCZ on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @12:22AM (#32574948)
This is what I dont like about Starcraft. The strategy is, in many instances, second to microing the units. The fact that 1hp unit have the same effectivenes as a full hp one is just weird.
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by ajuc on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:20PM (#32571677)
Piloting isn't the main bottleneck. It's easier to automate the piloting than the maintenance, and unless we're talking one-use drones (so, guided missiles really) - there's a lot of maintenance. Somebody needs to transport the drones to the front, program the goals, recharge the batteries (which takes hours often), rearm them after the mission, download the gathered data, change the encryption keys, etc.

And if you manage to automate some of that - automation make your drone swarm vulnerable to disruption. Enemies can wait near automatic refueling/recharging station and capture the drones one-by-one for example. They can put a gps tracker on the automatic drone transport system and shell the enemy base once it gets there. Or they can put a grenade on a captured drone, release it, and detonate it when the drone is recharging destroying the whole swarm cheaply.

Ultimately there's a trade-off between automation and resilience that should be familiar to web developers.

Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by antihero on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:33PM (#32571849)
What if you launch the drone swarms from a large plane circling out of danger, like an AWACS or gunship?
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by squeaky-clean on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:46PM (#32571991)
Anything far enough away to not be targeted by a ground to air missile would also probably be too far away for a drone to make a round trip. A quick Google search says even SAMs from the 1950s can hit targets over 30km away.
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by antihero on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @07:01AM (#32577702)
Why do you need a round trip? Cruise a cruise missile is 100k-1.1m+, imagine the sort of drone you could build for that price
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by squeaky-clean on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @03:03PM (#32584189)
Because that was the point of the comment thread

> and unless we're talking one-use drones (so, guided missiles really) - there's a lot of maintenance. Somebody needs to transport the drones to the front, program the goals, recharge the batteries (which takes hours often), rearm them after the mission, download the gathered data, change the encryption keys, etc.

If we're talking single use drones you can launch them like rockets, or from an unmanned vehicle. There's also no real reason for them to be propeller drones. A modern Tomahawk missile can "loiter" in the air for 2 hours before being directed at its real target.

The concern is with multiple use drones, the biggest vulnerability will be your maintenance / base station so you'll want humans defending that. But also anything that puts them within a reasonable drone range puts them in artillery or SAM range.

Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by dinkledunk on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:56PM (#32572088)
Put your drones inside a missile and launch them at their target.
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by mattlondon on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:21PM (#32572360)
I saw a slide somewhere recently - there are already plans for this as an artillery shell or missile. I think it was combined with ordinary ordnance- drone is ejected before main weapon payload towards end of "flight". Drone helps pick highest value target then is used after for damage assessment. Presumably then it self destructs or/or kamikazees
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by nradov on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:23PM (#32574275)
Cruise missiles with submunition dispensers are not exactly a new concept. It's certainly possible in theory to stick some smart loitering munitions in a Tomahawk but that's going to be extremely expensive and not reusable.
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by Gaishan on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:20PM (#32572351)
I like this idea if it could be a cheap form of Smart Chaff.
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by 323 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:42PM (#32570353)
Small drones have limited range, so you need to deploy them everywhere. The front line in Ukraine is 1000 km.

Maybe you can have a big "carrier" drone transport them to where they are required, like in StarCraft.

Or maybe you can make the small drones recharge directly from the grid, by landing on top of power lines and deploy the necessary connections.

Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by jonathankoren on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @04:19PM (#32570924)
Small attritable drone swarms deployed by strike aircraft.

https://youtu.be/ndFKUKHfuM0

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perdix_(drone)

Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by usrusr on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:14PM (#32571615)
If you want a defensive screen: minimalistic gliders, deployed to high altitudes, that dive down onto a target when needed. They'd simply use altitude as energy storage, and when that's nearly used up they take the rest to make it to some designated landing field, ready to get collected for the next launch. Multiple "shifts" at different points in the altitude cycle at any given time.
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by nradov on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:24PM (#32574278)
And what kind of sensors do those gliders have, and how much power do those sensors draw?
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by usrusr on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:27AM (#32575584)
Sensors fly separately from the consumables, hitching the same ride up. The consumable ones only need their own for final approach which might even be assisted by "painting".

A bigger problem would be sensor overload from all the friendlies, you'd probably want those loitering to follow a course determined by a PRNG predictable to everyone who knows that day's key. But that's just very basic crypto put to novel use.

Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by nradov on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:03PM (#32571475)
That depends on the flight regime. If the big drones are at high altitude and/or moving fast then a small drone will never have the performance or sensors to achieve an intercept. So we need fast missiles or directed energy weapons fired from large, expensive platforms (which could be manned or unmanned, operating on land, sea, or air).

AI piloting technology remains very primitive. We don't have anything yet that can cope well with a dynamic air combat environment involving multiple unpredictable threats, EW, countermeasures, and complex ROE. That's just total science fiction today so we can expect to have humans in the loop at some level for many years to come.

Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by Aeolun on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:31PM (#32574679)
I think you can generally build a smaller drone than the attack drone, regardless of environment, if your goal is simply to trade them 1 for 1 (e.g. suicide drones).
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by nradov on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @01:49AM (#32575377)
What do you mean by drones exactly? If you're referring to small multi-rotor UAVs, those are so slow as to be almost completely useless as interceptors. Need something faster, with rocket or turbine propulsion. Probability of kill is never going to be 1.0, so the defender will usually fire multiple interceptors per target.
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by bilsbie on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:38PM (#32572516)
Actually it’s ordinary table yarn or fishing line. Fly it around the drones and trip up the props.
Re:Military drone swarms and how to combat them by picsao on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:55AM (#32562958)
Carrier drones are the ideal, swallowing cost of transport while not sacrificing amount and speed