Of course it doesn't help that the elected MPs have almost exclusively belonged to the same class of robber barons, Imran Khan being one notable exception.
Pakistan actually has a pretty vibrant and critical media, in contrast to (other) military dictatorships. They have a lot of great political satire (that, again, stops short of criticizing the military).
Pretty damning.
• 2008-13 PPP-led coalition government, which transferred power to the
• 2013-18 PML(N) government, which transferred power to the
• 2018-22 PTI (Khan's party) government, which was ousted in its penultimate year by a vote of no-confidence in the National Assembly.
1. PPP-led coalition government ousted in scandal of zardari's corruption. "mister ten percent", etc
2. nawaz sharif government ousted in scandal of nawaz sharif corruption (maybe that choice of microsoft word fonts in the faked documents for luxury UK real estate was not the best idea ever).
3. people finally "elected" khan
4. khan loses power in parliamentary no confidence vote
none of those are exactly what an outsider would consider to be the normal and orderly transfer of power in an electoral system
My own opinion: democracy is hardly a boolean value -- these transfers, faulty and flawed as they may be, did legitimize civilian rule in the public eye.
For your first bullet, the prime minister was kicked out after just over 4 years.
For your second bullet, the prime minister was kicked out after just over 4 years.
For the third bullet, Imran Khan didn't even last 4 years.
Khan has a large populist support base but it's not exactly accurate to say he's wildly popular, a huge amount of people from Lahore and Punjab and the power base of elites supporting Nawaz Sharif and his friends are deeply opposed to him. They've spent lots of money on political opposition.
And then there's all the Sindhi Bhutto and PPP supporters who don't like him either. He has maybe 45-50% support.
Add to this religion, every few years there is some popular majoritarian religious trend, often loaded with settling scores with the minorities for some imagined victimhood, some battle some king who belonged to your religion lost 800 years back, these are 'pride' related emotional issues on which masses vote. No one cares about education, or improving general standard of living.
Add to this caste, regional and linguistic reasons.
Democracy is mostly a sham even without fixing, because masses don't vote for their own good. To think of democracy in the sub continent, people vote to hurt others than to help themselves. A vote is mostly a downvote in many ways.
But I do agree with you, having the pleasure to know some upper class Pakistanis, that the military is the basis of the government.
sounds like Turkia but like 40 years ago
The Army and the military forces in general are the people who really control the country.
Pakistan makes a public show of having a parliamentary democracy with elected MPs and such but it's all a farce.
Doesn't particularly matter whether Bhutto, Zardari, Nawaz Sharif, Imran Khan or anyone else.