Re:TMTP a Internet protocol combining elements of email and ...
by cestith on Monday August 22, 2022 @11:01AM
(#32552429)
Most Internet application protocols run on top of UDP or TCP. They mean a new application protocol, like SMTP, HTTP, HTTPS, L2TP, POP3, IMAP4, SNMP, LDAP, SSH, FTP, RDP, LPD, XMPP, Kerberos, remote syslog, etc etc etc. If you're on any flavor of Unix, take a look at /etc/services and you'll see there are lots of protocols in the world.
Re:TMTP a Internet protocol combining elements of email and ...
by icedchai on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:51PM
(#32558826)
The protocols you list are decades old. There hasn't been a new mainstream protocol in a very long time. "Innovation" kind of stopped when we started tunneling everything over HTTP(S).
Re:TMTP a Internet protocol combining elements of email and ...
by cestith on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:11AM
(#32564401)
HTTP2 and HTTP3 themselves are relatively recent and widely used. They also happen to work on top of TCP and UDP rather than supplanting them.
ACME protocol is fairly recent and widely used.
WebSocket protocol is barely over one decade old.
DNSSEC is a little over a decade and a half old.
NVMe over Ethernet is barely half a decade old and still gaining support.
400GBASE-LR4-6 is from last year. People are still working on terabit/second Ethernet.
There are loads of protocols on top of the HTTP family. DNS over HTTP is a protocol. SOAP, JSON-RPC, and REST are protocols. IPFS is a protocol.
To say there's no innovation in protocols when it's literally happening all the way up and down the stack is just silly and shortsighted.
Re:TMTP a Internet protocol combining elements of email and ...
by icedchai on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:45AM
(#32564837)
Ok, you have a point. There is innovation in the "infrastructure" space for protocols. Almost none of the stuff you describe is directly visible to end users. I should've said there's no new application protocols, like SMTP, POP, XMPP, SSH, etc. Example: I had hopes there would be some sort of federated "instant messaging" standard so we wouldn't all need to use separate apps.
Re:TMTP a Internet protocol combining elements of email and ...
by eis on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:13AM
(#32565225)
Isn't Matrix trying to be that?
Building a new protocol today is kinda like inventing a new engine that doesn’t require gas, it’s gonna need a giant motivator to be adopted and trillions of dollars.
The days of grassroots bootstrapping are over, no one has any reason to adopt your thing because what we have now is Good Enough(tm). Your new thing needs to be revolutionary AND have government backing across multiple governments and administrations. There is no other way, consider the electric car vs hydrogen.