News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hacker News Official API by metadat on Sunday August 21, 2022 @11:45AM (#32541280)
What difference would exposing counts make? Why should this data be mineable?

We're already helping to create a training set of slightly above average English speaker discourse for free.

Re:Hacker News Official API by O__________O on Sunday August 21, 2022 @11:52AM (#32541362)
If it was up to me, all data would be publicly available aside from emergency recovery email and password.

This would include mod commutations and mod logs; unless it was security related, which would have a formal process with deadlines for release.

—-

To address you specific question as why the comment voting data would be of use, among other reasons, it would allow users to have custom filters. For example, posts and comments with high up/down votes tend to be flamewars. Mods also random boost/ding posts/comments too.

Re:Hacker News Official API by tptacek on Sunday August 21, 2022 @02:52PM (#32543244)
It's not going to happen. Showing comments led to constantly flamewars about unfair commenting. Even without the comment scores, the mods are still constantly having to remind people to stop arguing about scores. The decision not to display or make available other people's scores was litigated intensely; it is now part of the premise of the community.
Re:Hacker News Official API by O__________O on Sunday August 21, 2022 @03:19PM (#32543481)
By “showing comments led” do you mean showing comment points/votes? Also, if comment viewable comment points are gone forever, then the “popularity” filter should be removed from HN’s search and the old voting data removed from the public API.

To me, if users have concerns about “unfair voting” to me the solution is not to hide them. Also, if comment points aren’t important, why even allow them? They are obviously important and if a users is not available to respect guidelines not to complain about them, what’s difference between that an guidelines related to comments about being downvoted?

Re:Hacker News Official API by tptacek on Sunday August 21, 2022 @03:34PM (#32543608)
Like I said, this has been heavily litigated. So much so that I think you'd have difficulty coming up with an argument that hadn't been made already about it. Not making other people's comment scores available is, as I said, a part of the premise of the community. There are other communities that work differently. There isn't a single optimal set of policies.
Re:Hacker News Official API by O__________O on Sunday August 21, 2022 @04:18PM (#32543987)
You’re right, obviously the best way to secure the community was to obscure the votes of people that were upvoting toxic content instead of the mods/community just publicly tagging and flagging the related undesirable content and penalizing the voting weights of anyone upvoting that content.

If votes being public impacts voting patterns, listing top users, having usernames publicly associated with comments, being able to follow given user’s comments, etc — for sure does too. What’s the difference?

Re:Hacker News Official API by tptacek on Sunday August 21, 2022 @04:21PM (#32544002)
You're arguing here as if there is an argument to be had. I'm trying to help you understand that there is no such argument. Your claims have been considered and rejected hundreds of times over the last 10 years. It'd behoove you to consult the search bar below and read some of those old discussions. This isn't a case where the community made a rash decision and just doesn't realize how problematic it is; you're talking about what is probably the single most deliberate community management decision HN has ever made. It's not going to change.

A moment later

Maybe it'll help if you get your head around the goal of HN. There are a bunch of things you personally seem to want to accomplish with HN. But HN itself has just one goal: to nurture curious conversation. Other sites have other, equally valid goals: propagating the news as quickly as possible, or relentless focus on a particular topic, or getting the best Q&A pairs to the top of Google's search results. HN, though: curious conversation. That's the whole ballgame.

Anything that drags on curious conversation is a non-starter on HN, even if it might make a bunch of things better for you.

We don't have to guess about whether making comment scores available is a drag on curious conversations; it manifestly was, for years. People have an innate, visceral reaction to comment scores they feel are unjust, and they talk about them, and those conversations choke the landscape like kudzu.

A lot of things about HN make more sense when you accept the premise of the site, and understand that HN will make most sacrifices it can come up with to optimize for that premise.

Re:Hacker News Official API by O__________O on Sunday August 21, 2022 @05:46PM (#32544787)
Just to be clear, intentionally not responding, since you repeatedly in my opinion ignored my points and contrary to your claims, did not engage me out of intellectual curiosity.
Re:Hacker News Official API by threatofrain on Sunday August 21, 2022 @08:51PM (#32546043)
I think tptacek is saying something meaningful in suggesting that there's already a long history to this discussion. Personally I disagree that the soul of HN is about curiosity. If you removed all the explicit comments about curiosity and showed the site to new tech people, I don't think there would be consensus on curiosity. If you showed a bunch of people the Rust subreddit, there would be consensus that it's soul is Rust.

Personally I see this site as the Reddit of tech with 20% of its flavor coming from YC companies. That is how it behaves, as opposed what moderators say the site is about.

Re:Hacker News Official API by pvg on Sunday August 21, 2022 @09:30PM (#32546297)
'curious conversation' is a much loftier, woolier and syntheticier goal than 'Rust' and HN strives towards it imperfectly. The measure, though, is 'does this or that change bring us closer to it' not 'can people unfamiliar with the site achieve mindmeld with dang by staring at the front page'.
Re:Hacker News Official API by metadat on Sunday August 21, 2022 @11:56AM (#32541387)
I hear you, but what is the endgame with this? Does it lead to a better HN?

Lobste.rs actually exposes even less and doesn't provide an API because the users haven't consented to such intrusions.

Personally, I don't want to be able to review every vote for or against my HN account. It wouldn't be productive and would likely lead to me not wanting to be here at all. It'd be like having a super strong mirror and then looking at your skin and being confronted with too much information about the reality of how nasty looking and imperfect being human is. Basically not a healthy pastime.

FWIW, if you're truly passionate about this, it's not difficult to setup your own site with the lobste.rs open-source code. Maybe there is a whole subset of like-minded folks.

The lobste.rs origin story may also be of interest to you. The TL;DR is jcs was being singled out and abused by pg on HN. Thankfully there is no evidence dang has (or would ever) do this, it was certainly toxic behavior on Paul's part. Being a moderator isn't for everyone, it's a Certain Thing, and net-positive mods who avoid power tripping are truly rare gems on the Internet. Open information would guarantee such abuses couldn't happen in the dark, but at what cost to the best aspects enabled by the HN ecosystem?

References:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4452568

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32112665

Re:Hacker News Official API by O__________O on Sunday August 21, 2022 @11:59AM (#32541423)
Again, just expressing my opinion, but another example would be it would allow custom ranking algorithms like PageRank, TrustRank, etc.

And yes, aware of Lobste.rs mod logs, but Lobste.rs is basically dead compared to HN — largely because it’s an HN clone.

Re:Hacker News Official API by ElCheapo on Sunday August 21, 2022 @12:07PM (#32541501)
This is a website where people post links and other people comment below them. Most front page discussions don't surpass 50 replies. I don't really think we should care so much about this place to the point that we're willing to employ state of the art data analysis tools just to read a blog post and see if someone has critiqued it in the comments
Re:Hacker News Official API by hombre_fatal on Sunday August 21, 2022 @01:55PM (#32542647)
This kind of stuff would probably just seed the sort of neuroticism that makes forums worse.
Re:Hacker News Official API by dinkledunk on Sunday August 21, 2022 @02:16PM (#32542867)
Yes, it is. And if you feel that way, that's fine. Why gatekeep?
Re:Hacker News Official API by ElCheapo on Sunday August 21, 2022 @02:21PM (#32542905)
What am I gatekeeping, exactly?
Re:Hacker News Official API by O__________O on Sunday August 21, 2022 @02:44PM (#32543173)
For starters, that you only want HN to be used the way you want to use it; which for sure it not the way I want to use it and more than likely significant number of other users too. If that’s not gatekeeping, then what is?
Re:Hacker News Official API by mdaniel on Sunday August 21, 2022 @01:25PM (#32542329)
> Lobste.rs is basically dead compared to HN — largely because it’s an HN clone.

My outsider opinion is that lobsters is dead because the sign up process is designed to keep people out. I appreciate there's also the network effect of people coming here because people come here, but I for sure would visit lobsters too if I could participate without having to know a friend to get past the velvet rope

Re:Hacker News Official API by bambax on Sunday August 21, 2022 @12:29PM (#32541737)
> This would include mod commutations

In 2019 I set up a bot to store titles for HN stories as soon as they appear on the "new" page, so that I could then compare them to the current version.

I had also made a browser extension for FF and Chrome that compared the current version of any HN story to the stored one, and displayed a warning if they differed.

There was zero downloads of the extensions, so they fell into disrepair and don't work anymore, but the cron job for storing the titles is still active.

If there is any interest I could resuscitate the extensions, or some other system to make that information useful.