News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by oifjsidjf on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:12AM (#32507884)
You are conflating highly processed seed oils (canola, corn oil,..) with legit cold pressed ones that have been consumed for a long while (hemp oil, olive oil,...)
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by grapeskin on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:16AM (#32507911)
Olive oil actually isn’t a seed oil. It comes from the flesh of the olive.

I was surprised to learn that myself recently.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by samatman on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:34AM (#32508070)
While this is true, an oil like high-oleic sunflower oil is (obviously) a seed oil, but one which is mostly oleic acid, like olive oil.

Furthermore, coconuts are a seed, and coconut oil is often explicitly cited as an alternative to seed oils.

"Seed oil" is a reasonably proxy for the sort of high polyunsaturated oils we should probably avoid eating, but it's a heuristic for identifying products with bad lipid profiles, not a law.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by leephillips on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:54AM (#32509612)
No: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Relevant-Fatty-Acid-Comp...

Sunflower oil is mostly linoleic acid; its profile is unhealthy according to current thinking (and my shaky understanding). You’re right about olive oil, which is supposedly good for your heart.

EDIT: unless by “high-oleic sunflower oil” you’re referring to some special variety?

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by samatman on Thursday August 18, 2022 @10:05AM (#32509770)
Indeed, it's, wait for it, high in oleic acid.

I'm only teasing a little. It's a specific sort of sunflower (safflower is also available in high-oleic) and sunflower oil will either say "high oleic" or it will have a ton of linoleic acid in it.

I use high-oleic sunflower to make mayonnaise because it has a neutral flavor. If I ever deep fry again, which eh, that might happen, I'll use a blend of it and tallow.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by leephillips on Thursday August 18, 2022 @10:11AM (#32509849)
I deserve it; I should have searched before commenting:

https://www.sunflowernsa.com/oil/High-Oleic-Sunflower-Oil/

It’s interesting!

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by marvin on Thursday August 18, 2022 @08:30AM (#32508674)
I am once again super confused. During my whole primary education, highly poly-unsaturated fats were considered beneficial with regards to cardiovascular health. Saturated fats and trans fats were considered the culprit.

What changed, and when?

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by samatman on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:02AM (#32509017)
During my whole primary education, trans fats were considered a healthy alternative to saturated fat, this was universally promoted by the same authorities, and tens of millions of people suffered poor health, obesity, and premature death.

Unlike tobacco, none of the researchers responsible for this calamity have been censured, sued, or otherwise suffered negative consequences. They are, for the most part, still in power, and research is conducted under their auspices.

Does this mean they're wrong about linoleic acid being healthy as well? No, not inherently, but it does mean that it's worth looking elsewhere and drawing your own conclusions.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by adrian_b on Thursday August 18, 2022 @11:12AM (#32510790)
Linoleic acid is an essential nutrient for humans, who must obtain it from their food.

However, all nutrients, including all essential nutrients, have a range of daily intakes within which they are healthy, and when eaten in much greater quantities than the upper limit of that range they become unhealthy, or even dangerous.

For example a too low selenium daily intake can cause illnesses, but eating selenium only a few times more than the maximum recommended intake can cause a severe poisoning.

That is true also for linoleic acid, in moderate quantities it is very healthy, in too large quantities it is unhealthy.

Until the last few centuries, it was extremely unlikely for anyone to be able to eat too much linoleic acid. It was possible to do that if one would have eaten huge quantities of, for example, pine nuts, poppy seed paste or walnuts, but all those were quite expensive so most people would not have been able to buy enough of them, much less eat enough of them, to suffer from that.

That changed especially since the 19th century, when the industrial production of edible oils began to provide large quantities of cheap vegetable oils, like sunflower oil and many others, which have a very high content of linoleic acid.

These cheaper oils have replaced the traditional olive oil and also the animal fats in most applications, which resulted in a greatly increased consumption of linoleic acid.

So for most people, now it is more likely that they might eat too much linoleic acid, than it is that they might eat too little linoleic acid.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by Jensson on Thursday August 18, 2022 @08:58AM (#32508980)
Poly unsaturated fats easily becomes trans-fats when heated. This is very common in factory produced food since trans fats melt at higher temperatures making their shape easier to keep if you turn the poly unsaturated fats to trans fats.

But I don't think there are any dangers to poly unsaturated fats other than them easily turning into trans fats, so as long as factories are banned from making them into trans fats it should be fine. Or really the opposite, poly unsaturated fats are the healthiest fats, omega 3 and omega 6 and so on belongs to this group, just be sure to treat it carefully and don't let it turn to trans fats.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by bluGill on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:30AM (#32509307)
There is one other problem with poly-unsaturated fats: they spoil fast - a few months at best at room temperatures. Since the crops are often harvested yearly and it takes time to get from field to market to your cupboard this is a real problem.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by feet on Thursday August 18, 2022 @11:15AM (#32510837)
Sounds to me like if you avoid heating them it's fine, which means there should be no issue with dietary PUFAs.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by Jensson on Thursday August 18, 2022 @12:32PM (#32511812)
Yeah, canola oil should be fine to use if you add it to food yourself. But as ingredients in fastfood or bread or chips it is likely they heated it enough to create trans fats.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by feet on Friday August 19, 2022 @01:50PM (#32524071)
So the heating thing appears to be false. I wasn't able to locate literature in my brief search on the subject so perhaps someone can post a link
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by ZeroGravitas on Thursday August 18, 2022 @10:10AM (#32509840)
Nothing changed:

Here's the British Heart Foundation:

> Contrary to some of the reporting on this issue, cutting saturated fat doesn’t necessarily mean lowering all fat. We all need some fats in our diet and, over time, the very low fat diets recommended in the past have been put to one side as our understanding of the effect of this nutrient has developed. So, current guidance tells us to switch from saturated to unsaturated fats rather than cutting the fat completely.

> However, it is still important to talk about processed foods and what is in them. A lot of the food we eat is pre-prepared, and while sometimes the processing is as simple as canning tomatoes, processed foods also include foods like ready meals, sweet treats or processed meats where food manufacturers can alter the amounts of different fats, salt or sugar.

> As with our diets, when one thing goes out, something else will take its place. The concern is what saturated fat is replaced with when it is removed. Replacing saturated fat with refined carbohydrates, like sugary foods, or trans fats won’t improve our health, but replacing them with unsaturated fats seems to have a positive benefit.

> We also know that we are already eating too much salt and sugar on average so, while we welcome changes to reduce saturated fat in our everyday products, we also want manufacturers to be mindful of what they replace it with. As consumers, we still need to keep an eye on food labels to understand what is in the foods we are buying and make the best choices for ourselves, too.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by bluGill on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:28AM (#32509276)
In my youth it was assumed that the problem with fats is when they were solid at room temperature. Thus saturated fat was assumed to have the same effect as much cheaper trans fat, so they studied trans fat and called saturated fat bad. Then someone else recommended margarine (transfat) over butter because the headline said saturated fat (and the article may not have even mentioned they actually tested trans fat because there was thought to be no difference)

Some of this was science not knowing they needed to check things, but a lot of it was media and industry groups trying to sell a product and running a with half truths that fit their narrative. there are a lot of old studies that we cannot/should not reference today at all because things we now know are important were not something science took care to control for.

Problem is good science takes years. Health authorities need to make recommendations today, and often for political reasons don't get the option to say I don't know.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by atwood22 on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:18AM (#32507934)
Same with avocado oil, which is a good alternative if you need an oil with a higher smoke point.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by m000 on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:57AM (#32508291)
There's also olive pomace oil [1], which doesn't come from the flesh of the olive. It is technically olive oil, but is not allowed to be labeled as such.

The packaging of olive pomace oil can be deceiving though. If it seems suspiciously cheap, make sure that the label indeed reads "olive oil".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olive_pomace_oil

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by elevaet on Thursday August 18, 2022 @12:49PM (#32512051)
It does come from the flesh tho (read the link) it's chemically extracted from the pulp after the mechanical pressing is finished.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by UncleOxidant on Thursday August 18, 2022 @12:27PM (#32511733)
Similar for avacado oil. I had thought they were pressing that out of the seeds, but no it's from the flesh of the avacado.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by feet on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:30AM (#32508025)
What's wrong with canola oil? The fatty acid profile seems pretty healthy to me
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by samatman on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:44AM (#32508172)
It's important to remember that if this were the 80s, a well-informed consumer would say the same thing about margarine vs. butter.

Turns out we were tragically wrong about that, causing tens, perhaps hundreds, of millions to suffer in old age and die prematurely.

So if I saw some mild evidence, like most nutrition scientists retiring, that the industry has reformed, that would be one thing.

As it is? I think they're lying, from Doing My Own Research™, but your mileage may vary. The important part is that you'd be a fool to trust the industry consensus with your own health.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by feet on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:50AM (#32508217)
Okay but I specifically asked what is wrong with it, can you cite any sources?
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by wil421 on Thursday August 18, 2022 @11:06AM (#32510689)
The only sources they will site are a few doctors with popular books. I’ve read a few of them and they can help you lose some weight.

After reading the books based on some internet persons suggestion I realized there’s controversy. Some say it’s junk science pushed by snake oil doctors others says it’s the next scientific revolution.

One fact remains, heart disease has gone way down and obesity has gone way up.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by hombre_fatal on Thursday August 18, 2022 @04:07PM (#32514250)
The whole seed oils thing just seems like a twitter fad/meme. Can anyone share some promising literature?

When I search for it, I just see studies about PUFA (polyunsaturated fats) benefits where they seem to always use canola oil (like swapping saturated fats for canola oil) to show benefits.

Yet overnight it seems like popular twitter accounts and podcasters have echoed seed oils = bad.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by kritiko on Thursday August 18, 2022 @01:28PM (#32512518)
Hasn't life expectancy gone up and cardiovascular events gone down since the 80s?
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by dilap on Thursday August 18, 2022 @08:51AM (#32508905)
Just looking at macro fat breakdowns (per cronometer.com) it's definitely one of the better vegetable oils, but still not awesome -- 28% PUFA, 2/1 n6/n3. Which isn't terrible, but like 2.5x the PUFA content of olive oil, and way more than a cooking fat like tallow or butter.

(I'm assuming in the above your goal is to keep PUFA low and n6/n3 balanced.)

There's also some animal studies w/ canola oil specifically that showed adverse effects, though I don't have them at hand.

Just looking at the characterization of fatty acids by unsaturatedness is omitting details which can matter -- the particular makeup of the fats (chain length -- a fatty acid w/ the same unsaturatedness can have varying effects on metabolism at different chain lengths; cis vs trans) as well as all the other chemicals that are in the oil, whether beneficial or harmful.

As one example, canola oil used to contain high levels of erucic acid, which is a 9-chain monounsaturated fat generally considered toxic. Over time the levels have gotten lower.

You might enjoy this video showing how canola oil is made:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cfk2IXlZdbI

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by landemva on Thursday August 18, 2022 @11:36AM (#32511100)
> vegetable oils

Canola (Canadian Oil) or rape seed was used as an industrial lubricant oil. The first human lifecycle testing is now showing results. I avoid consuming it.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/rapeseed

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by hombre_fatal on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:24PM (#32515093)
Industrial application doesn't mean something is unfit for consumption: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olive_oil#Other
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by gamblor956 on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:01PM (#32514838)
Coconut oil and olive oil are also used as lubricant oils.

On a similar note, note, water is used as a lubricant, an industrial cleaner, an industrial solvent, and has strong corrosive properties. Too much water consumption can cause death.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by landemva on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:48PM (#32516162)
I agree humans are well adapted to water consumption. The water from my well is delicious.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by feet on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:42PM (#32516838)
Humans are well adapted to consuming fatty acids, in fact there are some that are essential to our diets because we don't have the enzymes to produce double bonds at specific locations
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by dilap on Friday August 19, 2022 @03:50PM (#32525301)
Ray Peat has an interesting essay questioning if they are really essential.

https://raypeat.com/articles/articles/unsaturatedfats.shtml

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by feet on Friday August 19, 2022 @08:05PM (#32527588)
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by dilap on Saturday August 20, 2022 @08:27AM (#32531529)
I don't know if he's right or not, but he's talking about specific, concrete studies -- real data.

The page you link to say says:

> A deficiency of essential fatty acids—either omega-3s or omega-6s—can cause rough, scaly skin and dermatitis [5].

Then when we go look at [5] we get:

> Institute of Medicine, Food and Nutrition Board. Dietary reference intakes for energy, carbohydrate, fiber, fat, fatty acids, cholesterol, protein, and amino acids (macronutrients). Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 2005.

That's not actual data.

Presumably the reference intakes are based on some sort of data (would take some digging to find out, since it's incoveniently not hyperlinked) -- I might speculate it's based on exactly the 1929 Burr study that Peat is arguing was mistaken.

Hard to know though, without some digging.

Do you think PUFA is essential because it's what the NIH tells you, or because of specific experiments that have been done which demonstrate it?

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by feet on Saturday August 20, 2022 @10:32AM (#32532321)
Signaling molecules such as endocannabinoids are constructed from specific essential PUFAs, that combined with our cells swapping out different fatty acids to alter membrane fluidity tell me that we do need them in our diet because we literally lack the enzymes to construct them.

If you had read the entire page that I linked you would have seen that

Do you think biochemical research into these pathways just stopped in the 1930s?

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by dilap on Saturday August 20, 2022 @12:24PM (#32533180)
If you're trying to support a claim, it's more useful if you specifically point out which facts you believe support the claim, rather than linking to a many-page summary, with some 183 footnotes.

Usually if someone does this, I take it as an indication of arguing in bad faith, and give up on the conversation, but in this case I assumed good faith and scanned your link for the section that seemed relevent to your claim.

Anyway:

> Signaling molecules such as endocannabinoids are constructed from specific essential PUFAs, that combined with our cells swapping out different fatty acids to alter membrane fluidity

No dispute there...

> we literally lack the enzymes to construct them

...or there.

> tell me that we do need them

But you can't conclude that! You're still missing a demonstration that not being able use PUFA in these ways would lead to pathology.

And if it does, then what is the minimum level of PUFA consumption needed to to avoid it?

As far as I know, those questions have not been answered.

That said, I do think you're probably right, on an intuitive level. Any traditional diet (or indeed any diet that incorporates whole foods) will contain some PUFA, so it would make sense we were evolved to function best with some PUFA in our diet.

But, at least per Ray Peat's claim, all experiments with diets claiming to show the essential nature of PUFA were manifestly defficient in other ways.

So it seems the claim has yet to be demonstrated, and remains somehwat uncertain.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by elevaet on Thursday August 18, 2022 @12:52PM (#32512101)
Its use as a lubricant is irrelevant to the discussion.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by kritiko on Thursday August 18, 2022 @02:02PM (#32512903)
rapeseed is a brassica - do you avoid broccoli, cauliflower, mustard, brussels sprouts, etc?
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by landemva on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:45PM (#32516146)
Humans didn't consume large quantities of seed oil until relatively recently. I don't consume processed seed oils, even if the seeds are sourced from a vegetable plant.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by feet on Thursday August 18, 2022 @10:03PM (#32516965)
How do you define what is processed
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by feet on Friday August 19, 2022 @06:53AM (#32519478)
I do not have a goal to minimize PUFA intake, I don't understand why I should have that ad a goal. Can you cite any sources for why PUFAs are bad?