Turns out we were tragically wrong about that, causing tens, perhaps hundreds, of millions to suffer in old age and die prematurely.
So if I saw some mild evidence, like most nutrition scientists retiring, that the industry has reformed, that would be one thing.
As it is? I think they're lying, from Doing My Own Research™, but your mileage may vary. The important part is that you'd be a fool to trust the industry consensus with your own health.
After reading the books based on some internet persons suggestion I realized there’s controversy. Some say it’s junk science pushed by snake oil doctors others says it’s the next scientific revolution.
One fact remains, heart disease has gone way down and obesity has gone way up.
When I search for it, I just see studies about PUFA (polyunsaturated fats) benefits where they seem to always use canola oil (like swapping saturated fats for canola oil) to show benefits.
Yet overnight it seems like popular twitter accounts and podcasters have echoed seed oils = bad.
(I'm assuming in the above your goal is to keep PUFA low and n6/n3 balanced.)
There's also some animal studies w/ canola oil specifically that showed adverse effects, though I don't have them at hand.
Just looking at the characterization of fatty acids by unsaturatedness is omitting details which can matter -- the particular makeup of the fats (chain length -- a fatty acid w/ the same unsaturatedness can have varying effects on metabolism at different chain lengths; cis vs trans) as well as all the other chemicals that are in the oil, whether beneficial or harmful.
As one example, canola oil used to contain high levels of erucic acid, which is a 9-chain monounsaturated fat generally considered toxic. Over time the levels have gotten lower.
You might enjoy this video showing how canola oil is made:
Canola (Canadian Oil) or rape seed was used as an industrial lubricant oil. The first human lifecycle testing is now showing results. I avoid consuming it.
On a similar note, note, water is used as a lubricant, an industrial cleaner, an industrial solvent, and has strong corrosive properties. Too much water consumption can cause death.
https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Omega3FattyAcids-HealthPro...
The page you link to say says:
> A deficiency of essential fatty acids—either omega-3s or omega-6s—can cause rough, scaly skin and dermatitis [5].
Then when we go look at [5] we get:
> Institute of Medicine, Food and Nutrition Board. Dietary reference intakes for energy, carbohydrate, fiber, fat, fatty acids, cholesterol, protein, and amino acids (macronutrients). Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 2005.
That's not actual data.
Presumably the reference intakes are based on some sort of data (would take some digging to find out, since it's incoveniently not hyperlinked) -- I might speculate it's based on exactly the 1929 Burr study that Peat is arguing was mistaken.
Hard to know though, without some digging.
Do you think PUFA is essential because it's what the NIH tells you, or because of specific experiments that have been done which demonstrate it?
If you had read the entire page that I linked you would have seen that
Do you think biochemical research into these pathways just stopped in the 1930s?
Usually if someone does this, I take it as an indication of arguing in bad faith, and give up on the conversation, but in this case I assumed good faith and scanned your link for the section that seemed relevent to your claim.
Anyway:
> Signaling molecules such as endocannabinoids are constructed from specific essential PUFAs, that combined with our cells swapping out different fatty acids to alter membrane fluidity
No dispute there...
> we literally lack the enzymes to construct them
...or there.
> tell me that we do need them
But you can't conclude that! You're still missing a demonstration that not being able use PUFA in these ways would lead to pathology.
And if it does, then what is the minimum level of PUFA consumption needed to to avoid it?
As far as I know, those questions have not been answered.
That said, I do think you're probably right, on an intuitive level. Any traditional diet (or indeed any diet that incorporates whole foods) will contain some PUFA, so it would make sense we were evolved to function best with some PUFA in our diet.
But, at least per Ray Peat's claim, all experiments with diets claiming to show the essential nature of PUFA were manifestly defficient in other ways.
So it seems the claim has yet to be demonstrated, and remains somehwat uncertain.