Octopi live underwater. Light diminishes with depth. More data gained from feeling around currents, so brain goes in tentacle.
Edit: Ok, "as far as possible" is an exaggeration, but they aren't close.
And there are lots of reflexes to fire, before we have time to understand what we're seeing. Like putting your hands in front of your eyes when an object approaches rapidly, long before you recognize what the object is. There needs to be something between the retina and visual cortex to respond to this quickly enough.
duration for the signal to travel is one explanation, but not a great one because nerves are fast. (a lot of nerves take weird detours, the visual cortex itself is located at the back of the head). More mundane explanation is heat dissipation. The brain consumes a lot of energy and emits a lot of heat. Would be pretty hard to get rid of it anywhere else.
Maybe with some more billion years of evolution our DNA would create more abstractions, like how to generalize optical nerve paths and not just touch/muscle etc, but as we are now it seems like the logic isn't there. Such a thick nerve bundle would need to get added to the spine with everything else, or risk getting pinched and disabled just by moving around, but for now it seems like the spine abstraction doesn't support optical data.
Assuming the brain and stomach both need mutually exclusive physical space, let's swap the two and see what happens.
If the stomach is in the head rather than where it is now then it is right by the mouth, so food need to travel less. So it might be a first order solution to optimal spatial layout of the body components. Except, now there isn't enough time for the food to be digested so you have to move the stomach further away...
No they’re not. If your optic nerve had to travel from your stomach we’re talking a delay of 100s of milliseconds.
If the brain was in the abdomen, the latency to move your head would be a roundtrip longer.
especially for animals which orient using scent.
That's reddit-level submission spam[1]. Altough single user account with multiple links to the same content[2] would possibly get filtered there.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=nautil.us
[2] https://hn.algolia.com/?q=We+Might+Already+Speak+the+Same+La...
In many ways it is a bad thing compared to a faster centralized brain. Seems like an evolutionary local minimum where the organism supports an energy expensive peripheral nervous system that is just good enough to function.
Limb independence, is not the same thing as limb independent intelligence. Independently intelligence would mean when separated from the would the arm still shows signs of intelligence. Limb independence is simply central brain with limbs that are concurrently able to independently and meaningfully able to function, either in unison or separately; for example how a human drummer can use four limbs to tap out four separate beats, each with different timings, but that are in sync.
Quick Google turned up: “Octopuses have an extensive nervous system, with over 500 million neurons, similar in number to that of a dog. But unlike dogs and other vertebrates, where the majority of neurons are in the brain, over two thirds of the octopuses' neurons are located within their arms and body.”
Appears neurons are evenly distributed among the each the eight arms. That said, unable to find any research that shows the arms show any signs independent intelligence.