News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Another Path to Intelligence by O__________O on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @07:04PM (#32502934)
Scanned the article for any significant insights and only notable reference to me was the distribution of neurons, though it was lacking any meaningful details.

Quick Google turned up: “Octopuses have an extensive nervous system, with over 500 million neurons, similar in number to that of a dog. But unlike dogs and other vertebrates, where the majority of neurons are in the brain, over two thirds of the octopuses' neurons are located within their arms and body.”

Appears neurons are evenly distributed among the each the eight arms. That said, unable to find any research that shows the arms show any signs independent intelligence.

Re:Another Path to Intelligence by jakeinspace on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @07:22PM (#32503103)
I can imagine that arms equipped with significant neural processing would allow higher-level signals to be sent from the central brain. Rather than in most animals like ourselves, where the motor cortex basically tells which muscles to contract, the arms might be given a signal to feel around and lift a rock, or just explore and report back. Basically, leaving some or all of the planning to the brain, but offloading control. That, plus tightening the feedback loop between sending (touch) and actuation would make for some pretty useful advantages I would guess.
Re:Another Path to Intelligence by hypertele-Xii on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @07:46PM (#32503338)
Land animals' brains are behind their eyes because seeing is everything.

Octopi live underwater. Light diminishes with depth. More data gained from feeling around currents, so brain goes in tentacle.

Re:Another Path to Intelligence by kkylin on Thursday August 18, 2022 @02:15AM (#32505925)
Actually, the visual cortex of mammals is in the back of the head, about as far from the eyes as possible (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visual_cortex), whereas the visual area of octopus are (I think) right next to their eyes. That said, the comparison is not quite that straightforward because our axons are myelinated, which speeds up signals tremendously.

Edit: Ok, "as far as possible" is an exaggeration, but they aren't close.

Re:Another Path to Intelligence by hypertele-Xii on Thursday August 18, 2022 @11:35AM (#32511096)
The visual cortex has a direct pathway to the retina via the lateral geniculate nuclei.

And there are lots of reflexes to fire, before we have time to understand what we're seeing. Like putting your hands in front of your eyes when an object approaches rapidly, long before you recognize what the object is. There needs to be something between the retina and visual cortex to respond to this quickly enough.

Re:Another Path to Intelligence by Barrin92 on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @10:14PM (#32504403)
the necessity to see explains the position of the eyes but not necessarily of the brain. After all, you'd see just as well if your brain was in your stomach as long as it's connected to your eyes.

duration for the signal to travel is one explanation, but not a great one because nerves are fast. (a lot of nerves take weird detours, the visual cortex itself is located at the back of the head). More mundane explanation is heat dissipation. The brain consumes a lot of energy and emits a lot of heat. Would be pretty hard to get rid of it anywhere else.

Re:Another Path to Intelligence by Jensson on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @11:08PM (#32504798)
I'd bet on it being too hard for evolution to put eyes far away from the brain. The eyes are basically a part of the brain in every species, the optical nerve is so thick and does signal processing midway, I don't think our genes has a concept for dragging more optical nerves around the body or extending it etc.

Maybe with some more billion years of evolution our DNA would create more abstractions, like how to generalize optical nerve paths and not just touch/muscle etc, but as we are now it seems like the logic isn't there. Such a thick nerve bundle would need to get added to the spine with everything else, or risk getting pinched and disabled just by moving around, but for now it seems like the spine abstraction doesn't support optical data.

Re:Another Path to Intelligence by zasdffaa on Thursday August 18, 2022 @12:07AM (#32505141)
Latency. Nerves are not fast, but it's irrelevant if they were: if the man-eating giant cat has a the edge, speed becomes relative, yours vs cats, not absolute.
Re:Another Path to Intelligence by andsoitis on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @11:39PM (#32504988)
> After all, you'd see just as well if your brain was in your stomach as long as it's connected to your eyes.

Assuming the brain and stomach both need mutually exclusive physical space, let's swap the two and see what happens.

If the stomach is in the head rather than where it is now then it is right by the mouth, so food need to travel less. So it might be a first order solution to optimal spatial layout of the body components. Except, now there isn't enough time for the food to be digested so you have to move the stomach further away...

Re:Another Path to Intelligence by fuckstick on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @10:55PM (#32504711)
> because nerves are fast

No they’re not. If your optic nerve had to travel from your stomach we’re talking a delay of 100s of milliseconds.

Re:Another Path to Intelligence by Barrin92 on Thursday August 18, 2022 @01:44AM (#32505741)
they definitely are, about 300 mph (so that'd be about 10-20 ms). In fact one of your nerves, the laryngeal nerve enabling you to control your vocal cords wraps from your head around your heart back to your head, even in giraffes! Evolutionary it was apparently just more beneficial to make the thing longer.
Re:Another Path to Intelligence by fuckstick on Thursday August 18, 2022 @07:58AM (#32508307)
That should be up to about 300 mph. There is wide variability depending on the structure of the nerve. Even so that maximum is tremendously slow compared to a wire.
Re:Another Path to Intelligence by hypertele-Xii on Thursday August 18, 2022 @11:43AM (#32511190)
You're forgetting to account for response latency as well. It's not enough to see danger quickly, you also have to be able to move your body in response.

If the brain was in the abdomen, the latency to move your head would be a roundtrip longer.

Re:Another Path to Intelligence by mellavora on Thursday August 18, 2022 @04:47AM (#32506942)
> because seeing is everything.

especially for animals which orient using scent.

Re:Another Path to Intelligence by Koshkin on Thursday August 18, 2022 @06:17AM (#32507501)
Indeed, and dog’s vision is not very good to begin with.
Re:Another Path to Intelligence by stevebmark on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @10:50PM (#32504682)
This is nautilus, they are likely running a Hacker News upvote ring, based on their history posting here. Their articles rarely have substance.
Re:Another Path to Intelligence by jonnybgood on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @11:43PM (#32505012)
Or maybe people like reading Nautilus like I do and wanted to share what they thought was interesting. I think Nautilus has substance. It briefly introduces me to new ideas, people, and other miscellany that I otherwise would have never come across. It’s not an academic publisher or college-level lecture.
Re:Another Path to Intelligence by hericium on Thursday August 18, 2022 @12:06AM (#32505139)
> nautilus, they are likely running a Hacker News upvote ring

That's reddit-level submission spam[1]. Altough single user account with multiple links to the same content[2] would possibly get filtered there.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=nautil.us

[2] https://hn.algolia.com/?q=We+Might+Already+Speak+the+Same+La...

Re:Another Path to Intelligence by JackFr on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @09:21PM (#32504054)
There’s not a lot of meat in the article. Cephalopods it seems are a fantastic jumping off point for rewarding thought experiments about the mind and it’s relationship with the brain. But any claim to insight about “how cephalopods think” is pure bunk.
Re:Another Path to Intelligence by frozenport on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @09:08PM (#32503955)
Lot of info that they are independent, the extent is debatable. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/11/201102120027.h...

In many ways it is a bad thing compared to a faster centralized brain. Seems like an evolutionary local minimum where the organism supports an energy expensive peripheral nervous system that is just good enough to function.

Re:Another Path to Intelligence by O__________O on Thursday August 18, 2022 @06:09AM (#32507460)
Had already reviewed that article; from the article, “This study makes it clear that octopus's arms don't behave totally independently from the centralized brain.”

Limb independence, is not the same thing as limb independent intelligence. Independently intelligence would mean when separated from the would the arm still shows signs of intelligence. Limb independence is simply central brain with limbs that are concurrently able to independently and meaningfully able to function, either in unison or separately; for example how a human drummer can use four limbs to tap out four separate beats, each with different timings, but that are in sync.