News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by detaro on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @12:45PM (#32485367)
According to German sources the government denies this report and points to the currently running evaluations. (e.g. https://www.rtl.de/cms/atomkraftwerke-in-deutschland-verwirr...)
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by koheripbal on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @01:45PM (#32486229)
Given that the Prime Minister appointed an ideologue Greenpeace activist as the head of Climate policy, I too am skeptical that Germany has reversed its decision.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by DasIch on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:11PM (#32486562)
Assuming this refers to Jennifer Morgan:

  * Germany has no prime minister, Germany has a chancellor.
  * The prime minister didn't appoint her, the cabinet did.
  * She is not head of climate policy, she is a special envoy for climate policy as part of the federal foreign office. This is a diplomatic position. That means such decisions are out of scope here entirely.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by _ph_ on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @05:20PM (#32489107)
Almost. The chancellor proposes the ministers, the president appoints them (never not followed the proposal of the chancellor). But she isn't heading a ministry, but reports to the foreign minister, which probably proposed her. She might or might not have the administrative rank as a minister, but she isn't a member of the cabinet.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by DasIch on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @04:28AM (#32493774)
https://www.zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2022-02/klimabeauftr... for example mentions that the cabinet appointed her. Of course she isn't part of the cabinet but that is also not what I claimed.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by sveme on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:15PM (#32486615)
Thanks for the clarifications, it's always shocking to see the amount of bullshit on hackernews (and reddit) when it comes to Germany, renewable/nuclear energy and the like. Makes me want to question everything else that is posted here where I know less of. Reminder of the Gell-Mann Amnesia.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by colechristensen on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:24PM (#32486723)
There is a lot of overconfidence on HN for non-core subjects of the HN crowd.

Non-computer sciences and engineering comment sections are full of people speaking their guesses with authority.

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by Archelaos on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:42PM (#32486965)
> Non-computer sciences and engineering comment sections are full of people speaking their guesses with authority.

Any idea why this is the case? I wonder, because I would expect most engineers to have had a university education that taught them respect for the complexity of things around us in the first place. The realisation alone of how little one really knows about one's own subject after several years of study should make one very cautious when it comes to subjects one has only heard about in passing. Or is it simply that an overwhelming majority of modest people simply remain silent, and that is why a few uninformed who rush to judgement stick out?

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by colechristensen on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @03:03PM (#32487273)
As always, there's a webcomic for that: https://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=2475

Technical people with some knowledge of a topic will often find themselves on the peak of mount stupid (see comic).

In other words, knowing just enough to feel like you know a lot, not knowing enough to realize how much you don't know.

And... well university education often doesn't succeed in teaching people to estimate their knowledge on a subject appropriately. "I don't know but I want to know more!" isn't a very common outcome when a topic comes up. I think it really has to do with people who spend a lot of time being the most knowledgable one on most topics around getting used to just having an answer whether or not it's correct.

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by DasIch on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:33PM (#32486845)
There is a lot of overconfidence on core subjects also. Think of the rsync dropbox thing or any thread about kubernetes (I don't need it, so nobody does!)
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by honkler on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:41PM (#32486954)
tbh, you probably don't need kubernetes
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by DasIch on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @04:31AM (#32493790)
True but frequently people claim that it is bad and nobody needs it. Whereas I would say Kubernetes is a bit like a bucket excavator, you probably don't need it and a shovel would do you just fine but that doesn't mean nobody needs bucket excavators.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by sdoering on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @04:57PM (#32488816)
I currently need (to know) it and would rather not.

Especially in a multi cluster, kustomize, istio, argocd, Jenkins on bare metal over multiple physical data centers.

To me with intermediate data dev ops knowledge this is quite a level of complexity.

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by _ph_ on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @04:46PM (#32488689)
That is wrong. That former Greepeace member works for the foreign ministry, it seems with the purpose of dealing with international actions against climate change. This office has nothing to do with the German climate policiy. That would be the minister of environmental affairs and the minister of economy.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by causi on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @01:59PM (#32486414)
I don't know why you're flagged. Germany's special envoy for international climate policy, Jennifer Morgan, is indeed the chief of Greenpeace International. Granted it's debatable how much direct power the post has.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by _ph_ on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @04:47PM (#32488699)
Because it is wrong. She isn't heading German climate affairs.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by causi on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @01:20PM (#32499147)
Being wrong is not a valid reason to flag a comment under the HN guidelines.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by _ph_ on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @05:01PM (#32501682)
Well, I didn't flag it, but it was completely and utterly wrong. So I can understand it being flagged. I did comment onto it to correct the post.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by forty on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:18PM (#32486645)
I haven't downvoted, but I think it might be because calling someone an ideologue because you disagree with them is bad taste.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by causi on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:29PM (#32486788)
“Nuclear power plants are not the solution to climate change. To make fuels for nuclear power plants, we have to go through the whole process of uranium mining, transporting, and disposing. Considering this fact, there will be a lot of carbon emissions.”

When you're so rabidly anti-nuclear that you ignore the fact uranium is 1.5 million times as energy-dense as coal, you are an ideologue. Uranium has so much energy per kilogram you could fuel the world's reactors by shipping it via airplane.

There's plenty to criticize about the environmental damage of uranium mining. Carbon emissions is not one of them.

It's my opinion this choice to attack nuclear energy by casting it in whatever critical light is trendy rather than its actual weaknesses demonstrates Morgan is against nuclear energy for ideological reasons that have nothing to do with its actual dangers, hence she is doing little or no risk/reward calculation, and that her future choices will not be based on human energy needs and accurate assessments of nuclear technology and industry.

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by jonny_eh on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:39PM (#32486920)
By comparison, mining of coal emits carbon, and using it emits carbon. Double whammy of carbon emissions.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by forty on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @06:11PM (#32489632)
I don't know the person we are discussing about in this thread and I don't know her opinions or the opinion of German green party etc, but I do know some arguments of green parties here in France that are also anti nuclear too (note also that France and Germany are very different when it comes to nuclear as here most of our electricity is nuclear already)

The arguments they make is that producing electricity and most usage of electricity are bad for our planet and thus we should use less electricity if we want to preserve it (and as a result wouldn't need to add extra nuclear or coal capacity).

This part is often forgotten which results of thinking they want to replace nuclear by coal, which would be absurd.

I imagine it's probably hard to imagine that someone would think that seriously from a US perspective (one of my US based colleague asked "when are you getting AC in Europe??" when here many people are wondering if the Americans are going to stop being crazy with their freezing AC ^^)

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by bluefirebrand on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @08:47AM (#32495561)
> The arguments they make is that producing electricity and most usage of electricity are bad for our planet and thus we should use less electricity if we want to preserve it

Unless they have ideas about how people and society can continue to accomplish all of the things we want to, using less electricity, this is not a serious argument. It's simply ideological fluff, advocating for people to embrace a lower standard of living for nothing in return.

If a person advocates against cleaner sources of energy on the grounds that "we should just be using less energy", then I don't think they are a serious person and they should be ignored. Let them go live their hippie life on a commune somewhere and free up the space for the adults to talk about real solutions.

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by forty on Thursday August 18, 2022 @03:29AM (#32506425)
Well, what they would get in return is preserving the planet were we live. Even if they don't have children, the consequences of the past and current carelessness are already showing and severely impacting many people's life.

But there are also plenty of things that can be done to reduce energy consumption without impacting anyone's little confort. Regarding thermal confort the obvious solution is to improve insulation so they wouldn't have to heat or cool as much and might even save money in the long run

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by bluefirebrand on Thursday August 18, 2022 @12:27PM (#32511746)
> Well, what they would get in return is preserving the planet were we live. Even if they don't have children, the consequences of the past and current carelessness are already showing and severely impacting many people's life.

The anti-nuclear-power movement started 60 years ago. Imagine what our past would look like now if instead we had replaced all coal and gas with nuclear back then. Is there a chance we would have had more disasters? Sure. But it's impossible to know. What we do know for a fact is that coal and gas emissions are killing the planet.

We have a problem with CO2 emissions and here you are talking about better insulation in homes to reduce power usage. We have a great, direct solution to reduce emissions by orders of magnitude. But no, let's continue to burn gas and coal, just use less of it.

This is why I say anti-nuclear isn't a serious position.

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by forty on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:30PM (#32515142)
> Imagine what our past would look like now if instead we had replaced all coal and gas with nuclear back then

It's not hard to imagine, I'm French and we did replace most things with nuclear back then ^^

The result is that right now we are purchasing (probably coal made) electricity to our neighbors because around 50% of our theorical nuclear capacity is unavailable either for maintenance or because we don't manage to cool them enough with the current heat :)

Nuclear is certainly a good thing overall but not the obvious and only solution to all problems as some would like to believe.

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by stjohnswarts on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @04:24PM (#32488369)
It's people like her that won't sit down at a spreadsheet and put in basic arithmetic for things like recurring costs, nonrecurring costs, amount of pollution (broken down for the entire lifetime of the energy source) and make an educated call. They just react to their own knee-jerk opinion that they do not want to have challenged.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by forty on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @05:52PM (#32489465)
The problem with nuclear is that the other side does the same, which is why it's hard to have interesting discussion on the topic. If you want actual arguments on how nuclear is not the miracle energy some people would like to believe it is, look how here is in France half of our reactors had to be shutdown because of the heat during the recent heatwave or for maintainance, how we are unable to build those new gen reactors in any predictable deadline and budget, and how we struggle to shutdown older reactors which means we have to pay to prolong them over and over which is getting more and more expensive - and it's for an old tech from the 70s.

Of course there are many upside to it too (low carbon emissions and not from Russia among the obvious ones)

But it's pretty rare to find balanced and nuanced speech on the topic unfortunately, and I don't find the anti nuclear side to be any worse than the pro nuclear side on this.

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by curtainsforus on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @05:30PM (#32489212)
Do you think she cares? She's just catering to the common person.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by natmaka on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @05:23AM (#32494049)
The life-cycle CO2 emissions of nuclear power may become comparable with those of fossil power as high-grade uranium ore is used up over the next several decades and low-grade uranium is mined and milled using fossil fuels.

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2051332

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by causi on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @07:28AM (#32494798)
Their worst-case scenario is still twice as much power per kg of CO2 as natural gas and over four times as much as the lignite used in German coal plants.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by natmaka on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @11:23AM (#32497575)
Indeed, however no one (or nearly) now advocates those energy sources (as they emit way too much greenhouse-gases). This is to compare to emissions of renewables sources.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by colechristensen on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:22PM (#32486699)
If we go ahead and look at the definition of the word, I think it would almost be an automatic label for a Greenpeace leader.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by forty on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:31PM (#32486817)
Admittedly I'm French and the negative connotation of this word might not have carried to English but looking at an English dictionary [1] it does seem to me that's it's something you would only say of someone you disagree with.

[1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/ideologue

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by colechristensen on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:34PM (#32486862)
I'm one to think ideologues "on my side" also deserve to be disagreed with because of their methods and absolutism.

But you are right, it's not a thing you'd really say about somebody you liked.

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by SECProto on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:25PM (#32486744)
Dictionary definitions generally don't include information on connotation.

Edit: I searched to find a dictionary for word connotations, best I found in a couple mins is https://www3.cs.stonybrook.edu/~ychoi/connotation/

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by raverbashing on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:55PM (#32487156)
Greenpeace, true to its name and thanks to its anti-nuclear position is one of the big reasons why 2022 is not Green nor Peaceful
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by ianpurton on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @03:05PM (#32487300)
I was sceptical. Turns out you are right.

> Greenpeace has always fought - and will continue to fight - vigorously against nuclear power because it is an unacceptable risk to the environment and to humanity. The only solution is to halt the expansion of all nuclear power, and for the shutdown of existing plants.

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by s_dev on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:28PM (#32486771)
Insane that Greenpeace is anti-nuclear. Really undermines the organizations goals.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by the_third_wave on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @05:49PM (#32489449)
They would have to admit they were wrong when they opposed nuclear power, always a difficult thing for ideologically driven organisations. Some individuals manage to make amends with their mistaken activism but it takes a number of influential individuals to convincingly steer an organisation away from the cliffs it has been aiming for. Those individuals will initially be lambasted by the true believers so they often choose to leave the organisation instead of trying to reform it. This means the organisation is pulled even more towards the old/failed ideology which makes it even harder for it to be reformed.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by darthrupert on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:51PM (#32487092)
Fortunately, a majority of the new generation of Greens around Europe are coming to their senses and support nuclear power.

Not sure about Greenpeace though, they are a bit messed up.

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by senectus1 on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @07:35PM (#32490463)
Because of green washing.

Nuclear is carbon friendly, might even be climate change friendly but its a long way from being environmentally friendly.

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by ETH_start on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @02:36AM (#32493017)
Nuclear is extremely environmentally friendly. It uses very little land and materials, and produces very little waste, relative to energy produced.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by s_dev on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @11:01AM (#32497323)
Green washing refers to calling fossil fuels like natural gas "green".
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by Tomte on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:08PM (#32486535)
The foreign minister, not the Chancellor (that's what our prime minister is called).
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:08PM (#32486529)
Greenpeace is pro-nuclear now.
Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by LawTalkingGuy on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:15PM (#32486609)
They say otherwise. https://www.greenpeace.org/international/tag/nuclear/

"Greenpeace has always fought - and will continue to fight - vigorously against nuclear power because it is an unacceptable risk to the environment and to humanity. The only solution is to halt the expansion of all nuclear power, and for the shutdown of existing plants."

Re:Germany to Keep Last Three Nuclear-Power Plants Running by kube-system on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:15PM (#32486603)
I know nothing about Greenpeace, but their website seems to disagree with that:

https://www.greenpeace.org/usa/fighting-climate-chaos/issues...