News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet giants place full-page anti-SOPA ad in NYT by _delirium on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @06:18PM (#3245630)
The Business Software Alliance (BSA) seems to be in favor: http://www.bsa.org/country/News%20and%20Events/News%20Archiv...

Its members are made up of mainly non-web technology companies that sell expensive products and are worried about piracy or counterfeiting of those products: Oracle, Microsoft, Adobe, Intuit, Symantec, etc. Conversely, they don't run user-generated-content sites like YouTube or Facebook, so aren't worried about the problems with weakening safe harbors.

Re:Internet giants place full-page anti-SOPA ad in NYT by fmota on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @06:30PM (#3245679)
Allow me to be cynical but, if SOPA passes and breaks the Internet, these software companies would gain a lot. Especially Microsoft. Remember the "good old days" of Microsoft Everything? I hope you're as fond of them as these software companies seem to be.
Re:Internet giants place full-page anti-SOPA ad in NYT by Joakal on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @07:09PM (#3245779)
I hope Bill Gates with his philanthropy drive goes publicly against Microsoft company's support for censorship.
Re:Internet giants place full-page anti-SOPA ad in NYT by maaku on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @11:23PM (#3246382)
Bill Gate's philanthropy is funded with Microsoft (and Berkshire-Hathaway) stock. They'd be fighting against themselves.
Re:Internet giants place full-page anti-SOPA ad in NYT by rbanffy on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @09:01PM (#3246078)
I envy your optimism.
Re:Internet giants place full-page anti-SOPA ad in NYT by einhverfr on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @06:49PM (#3245731)
The paranoid security geek in me says "You know those Microsoft contributions to SAMBA lately? Could they go for a takedown order of the open source project on the allegation of copyright infringement now and make the SAMBA project fight to get their domain back?"
Re:Internet giants place full-page anti-SOPA ad in NYT by nitrogen on Thursday November 17, 2011 @02:55AM (#3246852)
The cynic in me says that Microsoft's contributions are a subtle sabotage. Back in the day, Samba was incredibly easy to configure as a domain controller with full UNIX account sync. The latest Samba now requires the creation and maintenance of an actual Windows registry, a separate account system, etc.
Re:Internet giants place full-page anti-SOPA ad in NYT by sliverstorm on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @08:21PM (#3245974)
Is "You gave it to me!" no longer a valid defense as for why you have someone else's IP?
Re:Internet giants place full-page anti-SOPA ad in NYT by Symmetry on Thursday November 17, 2011 @11:10AM (#3248069)
Yes it certainly is. And its so obvious that I bet the trial would take less than a year. But that's a year where Samba doesn't have a web page now.
Re:Internet giants place full-page anti-SOPA ad in NYT by rbanffy on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @09:02PM (#3246083)
No. If they contributed something, it's now under a free license.
Re:Internet giants place full-page anti-SOPA ad in NYT by abrahamsen on Thursday November 17, 2011 @04:21AM (#3247012)
Microsoft contributed the code under "GPLv2 or later", despite samba being under GPLv3.

GPLv2 does not contain the explicit patent grant that are part of why GPLv3 was created. And I very much doubt the courts will consider "or later" to include the patent grant.

The code in question seems very peripheral (something about using Firefox for configuration), and have received zero comments on the developers list. I would be very surprised if Microsoft had any other motivation for the release, than to make the engineer who worked on it happy.

However, it is probably not an accident that they choose the version of the GPL without a patent grant.

Re:Internet giants place full-page anti-SOPA ad in NYT by rbanffy on Thursday November 17, 2011 @01:56PM (#3248747)
It would be interesting to see the implicit patent grant in v2 (remember - you can't grant all the liberties required in the license without granting use - and the right to grant it further down the chain - of any patents embodied in the code) tested in court.

Also, unless I'm very wrong, the terms "GPLv2 or later" means you can use the software under v3 if you prefer to use it that way. The only way to block the explicit patent grant (but stay will the implicit one) would be to license it under plain v2.