News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by ren_engineer on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:12PM (#32451192)
because their anti-nuclear environmental groups were actually being funded by Russia behind the scenes.

And there are still fools who think that economic integration somehow prevents wars, which was shown to be false after WWI. These people said if Europe just paid a bunch of money for Russian energy they'd obviously never attack them. See what's happening with China and the US as more proof that handing over your economy doesn't placate anybody

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by _fizz_buzz_ on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:32PM (#32451410)
> because their anti-nuclear environmental groups were actually being funded by Russia behind the scenes.

I am German and very pro nuclear, but this is conspiracy bs. And why make such a grand claim without a single source?

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by 323 on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:54PM (#32451617)
> Nunes, as chairman of the House Intelligence Committee: Russia is secretly funding the environmental movement, particularly in Germany, to help pressure the closure of nuclear power plants.

https://www.eenews.net/articles/devin-nunes-claims-russia-is...

Dominique Reynié: "We found that Gazprom funded environmental NGOs that provided ministers to various governments, such as Belgium, which then advocated abandoning nuclear power".

https://twitter.com/ziontree/status/1497998920739274757

> For instance, the Soviets used front organizations to influence the anti-nuclear movement, the initiative that most visibly put Western leadership on the defensive. West German Interior Ministry and FBI reports concluded that Soviet-linked organizations were successfully swaying local peace movement initiatives to conform to Moscow’s positions

https://warontherocks.com/2017/09/russian-active-measures-in...

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by panick21_ on Saturday August 13, 2022 @05:30PM (#32453972)
Its not a conspiracy. Its for certain that there was a real anti nuclear movement but its also true that fossil industry and Russia spent money to fund these efforts.

So it happened but how effective it was is questionable.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by AnonCoward42 on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:23PM (#32451303)
> because their anti-nuclear environmental groups were actually being funded by Russia behind the scenes.

Every competing energy source lobby is probably trying to stack the chances against each other, but the activists were not by and large funded by Russia.

> These people said if Europe just paid a bunch of money for Russian energy they'd obviously never attack them.

You can't expect any party to hold still forever. If you provoke your partner long enough they might react at some point. In the long-term that is basically a guarantee.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by osigurdson on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:29PM (#32451363)
Not German, but I suspect memories of Fukushima and Chernobyl could be weighing on the minds of some. Perhaps this is an irrational concern but people are not necessarily rational - particularly when randomly polled on topics they know little about.
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by Cwizard on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:41PM (#32451495)
What I don’t understand is how those two incidents are even relevant. Chernobyl happened because of a faulty design + mismanagement and Fukushima was located on a region prone to earthquakes/tsunami’s caused by earthquakes. The factors do not really apply to Germany. And even if it did, the deaths caused by those accidents were quite low. Meanwhile coal pollution is killing people by the thousands but this is somehow ok?

I think the sole reason the west moved away from Nuclear is because it sounds scary and because the oil countries had a strong interest in maintaining the non-nuclear status quo.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by balentio on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:52PM (#32451600)
> What I don’t understand is how those two incidents are even relevant. Chernobyl happened because of a faulty design + mismanagement and Fukushima was located on a region prone to earthquakes/tsunami’s caused by earthquakes.

To use an old phrase, shit happens. When it happens where a Nuclear Power Plant is, the happening continues for a very, very long time. That kind of liability is not worth the risk and of course there are other power solutions than the fossil/fuel nuclear divide.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by p1mrx on Saturday August 13, 2022 @03:09PM (#32452816)
There are ways to design a nuclear plant that reduce the probability of shit happening by orders of magnitude. We should focus on building plants that can shut down using only passive systems with no human action.
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by formerly_proven on Saturday August 13, 2022 @01:04PM (#32451715)
The irrational fear-factor associated with anything nuclear is highlighted by how much attention Fukushima, the nuclear disaster, which gravely injured like a dozen people, gets relative to the earthquake and tsunami causing it, which killed 20k people and leveled a huge stretch of coast.
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by GordonS on Saturday August 13, 2022 @03:11PM (#32452830)
If you asked 100 random people on the street, I'll bet most would say the Fukushima nuclear disaster killed hundreds or thousands of people.

As a single data point, I just asked my wife (who, for background, is well educated and pays close attention to the news), and her guess was "hundreds".

The modern mass media has a lot to answer for.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by formerly_proven on Sunday August 14, 2022 @02:15PM (#32461513)
Media, perhaps, but interest groups probably share more of the blame, because the FUD originates with them. E.g. Greenpeace claims one million deaths from Chernobyl, GSS claimed something to the effect of "more than 1.5 million with most of the damage still to come" a few years ago. I almost can't blame people in an environment like that when they think TMI or Fukushima killed hundreds or thousands and gave a lot of people cancer or whatever.
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by osigurdson on Sunday August 14, 2022 @12:49AM (#32456440)
Did the media (in 2011) state that 100s or thousands died?
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by Gwypaas on Saturday August 13, 2022 @01:27PM (#32451931)
> Meanwhile coal pollution is killing people by the thousands but this is somehow ok?

Pitting nuclear against coal is fighting a straw man. The alternative is renewables. With a tiny fraction of the negative side-effects either nuclear or of fossil energy brings.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by Muromec on Saturday August 13, 2022 @01:21PM (#32451867)
> Meanwhile coal pollution is killing people by the thousands but this is somehow ok?

There is a tram going on a track, killing 10 children each week. You can switch it yo another track where it has a small chance of killing a thousand and you will be blamed for that.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by ALittleLight on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:34PM (#32451431)
Perhaps irrational? It's certainly irrational. Nuclear is among the absolute safest methods of energy production. Looking at Wikipedia one person died and sixteen were injured at Fukushima. That risk should dictate energy policy? "Irrational" is being kind.
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by osigurdson on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:50PM (#32451583)
When you think “power plant disaster”, what power plant instantly comes to mind? It’s a powerful “brand” that is quite difficult to displace in people’s minds. That is the problem to solve.
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by ALittleLight on Saturday August 13, 2022 @01:30PM (#32451949)
I think of hydroelectric dams which can destroy whole towns. There is a single hydroelectric disaster that has killed many more people than all nuclear incidents put together.
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by osigurdson on Saturday August 13, 2022 @03:12PM (#32452841)
Ok!
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by FourthProtocol on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:32PM (#32451398)
Indeed so. I've been following nuclear in Germany ever since those railroad protests when they tried to transport nuclear waste from somewhere to somewhere else which I thought was crazy (the protests).

The part I felt had merit is that none of Europe's lofty solutions to safely storing/disposing of the waste output ever came to anything. I believe until this day that industry is still trying to work out how to dig 30km down to safely store the waste underground.

That said I haven't kept up to date on any progress or better solutions.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by RF_Savage on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:50PM (#32451588)
Onkalo in Finland is not 30km deep, which none have achieved anywhere.

But Onkalo is one of the few actually built long term nuclear waste storage locations anywhere.

It is for domestic nuclear waste only. There is no desire to become the international dumping ground for nuclear waste.

Tbh I believe the waste should be reprosessed as fuel and burnt in reactors instead of burial.

But non-proliferation things make that impossible.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by panick21_ on Saturday August 13, 2022 @05:33PM (#32453996)
These geological repositories are such political bullshit theater. Its fucking sad.

The are actually more expensive then simply developing the reactors to burn up that fuel.

Its just crazy that we live in this world.

The US collected money from nuclear plants for 50 years for disposal, and had plenty of money to develop waste burning reactors. And yet that money is totally unused. While politicians dead-lock on this idiotic Yucca Mountain project.

Its beyond sad the state we are in.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by vimy on Saturday August 13, 2022 @01:31PM (#32451963)
After more than 50 years of nuclear power plants in use we can say that there is no nuclear waste problem. The ‘waste’ has been stored above ground for decades and nothing has happened. It’s clearly safe. We should just keep doing what we’re doing. No need to dig expensive holes.
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by _ph_ on Saturday August 13, 2022 @04:09PM (#32453328)
While I believe this is the most safe option right now - some candidate dumping grounds have failed spectacularly (the Asse), this of course only works as long we are vigilant and also pay the upkeep for storage locations for many millenia. Both from environmental and safety concerns.
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by cinntaile on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:20PM (#32451276)
Russia and the EU aren't at war, neither is the US and China. You haven't really proven that economic integration doesn't prevent wars.
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by Kim_Bruning on Saturday August 13, 2022 @01:07PM (#32451753)
In context your statement makes sense.

Though, this being HN, I'd like to point out that you are technically correct, the best kind of correct. There is no official declaration of war between the EU and Russia (even if one could figure out how to do that).

Of course in practice there is very much a proxy war going on on Ukrainian soil. It is being done fairly openly at that: Weapons shipments are mentioned on the news, and eg. the movements of EU-based AWACS and Drones (patrolling along borders and over black sea, peeking in and providing intelligence) are also not hidden.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by inglor_cz on Saturday August 13, 2022 @04:45PM (#32453631)
While not directly at war with Russia, many European nations are engaged in Ukraine by proxy.

Poland stands out as a massive military logistics hub without which the Ukrainian army would struggle to import any Western stuff.

If the Poles weren't under the protective umbrella of NATO, I suspect that the Russians would already have tried to destroy Rzeszow airport.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by hash07e on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:28PM (#32451362)
Really?

No sanctions? No finland minister asking to ban russian tourists from schengen?

Really?

Ok.. turn the ac then!

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by rowanG077 on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:32PM (#32451406)
Are you really equating sanctions with full on war?
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by hash07e on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:35PM (#32451435)
Yes

Us providing guns and trainning is not war?

Eu providing arms and guns is not war?

Economic sanctions are not war?

War is not a movie with bang.

War is happening now.

It started when they sunk the war ship russian..

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by cinntaile on Saturday August 13, 2022 @01:05PM (#32451732)
Ukraine sank the war ship as far as I know? I do not consider providing supplies war, the same goes for economic sanctions.
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by formerly_proven on Saturday August 13, 2022 @01:06PM (#32451739)
> War is happening now.

> It started when they sunk the war ship russian..

I'm sensing this is a (((they))) kind of they.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by panick21_ on Saturday August 13, 2022 @05:34PM (#32454007)
> Us providing guns and trainning is not war?

No.

> Eu providing arms and guns is not war?

No.

> Economic sanctions are not war?

No.

> War is not a movie with bang.

No.

> War is happening now.

Yes between Ukraine and Russia.

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by Ygg2 on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:18PM (#32451256)
You're going to need some citation on that Russia connection.
Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by ren_engineer on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:33PM (#32451415)
>“Ninety-nine per cent of the text of the articles of association is about climate and environmental protection, but 99 per cent of the money comes directly from Nord Stream II AG, which belongs to Gazprom.”

>“It’s quite a curious foundation. It is a puppet construction,” said Sascha Müller-Kraenner, head of Environmental Action Germany, a green charity, which is challenging the legality of the organisation both in the German courts and with the European Commission.

https://archive.ph/KXgC0

and German politicians from pretty much every single party have been taking bribes from Russia for years. Their energy policy of simultaneously shutting down coal but not spinning up any nuclear made them reliant on Russian natural gas, which they've been warned about by the US for years and are now paying the price for

from 2019 - https://washingtonmonthly.com/2019/06/06/how-europes-green-p...

and a video from 2018 of Germany's UN delegation quite literally laughing at the suggestion they'd be reliant on Russia for energy if they proceeded with Nordstream 2. Some good schadenfreude here- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FfJv9QYrlwg

Re:Germany sees shift in sentiment toward atomic energy by _fizz_buzz_ on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:55PM (#32451627)
True that foundation exists, and is heavily criticized by other German environmental organizations in Germany as even this article points out. Also it was founded after the nuclear exit was decided. You are falling for the trap where you know a little bit about a subject but draw the wrong conclusions from it.