News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by gambiting on Friday August 12, 2022 @06:31AM (#32436565)
Even the article mentions it.

Edit: if this wasn't 100% crystal clear, judging by some replies - I mean "even the article mentions it [Canada being a source of mustard seeds]"

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by seszett on Friday August 12, 2022 @06:43AM (#32436633)
I don't even care much about mustard or live in France (though I am French) and I knew it just from reading French news months ago.

But I've heard so much disinformation in the last weeks when I was back at home with my family, many aging people (not especially lacking education, and of various social status but just "normal" people) who seem to get most of their information from random posts on Facebook, that I've lost any remaining trust in democracy (or at least direct democracy as many people advocate today) as a viable system for the coming years.

Democracy needs a well-informed population making informed decisions, but what I see is the total opposite. If these people (who make up the majority of the population in our aging society) were to take decisions themselves, we would likely ally with Russia to finish the war against the "maybe-not-as-bad-but-still-very-bad" Ukrainians to restore mustard production and make gas flow again since there is no exceptional drought or any climate change at all, since summer last year was not so warm. Or some other nonsense.

Sorry for the rant, but my reflections were actually triggered by the comments I heard back then regarding the mustard shortage. I had never realised how misinformed people were.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by kergonath on Friday August 12, 2022 @07:50AM (#32437069)
My impression as well. I am not too hopeful for the future.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by dorfsmay on Friday August 12, 2022 @09:17AM (#32438152)
Direct democracy would allow to discuss and debate ideas for their own sake rather than choosing one of a very few camps. A person could be pro-guns and pro-vaccination without needing to identify with a party, their people, etc... Disinformation will still exist (see brexit!),it might even be worse, but people will be able to point to it without being called a plant for the other side.

The problem with current systems, representative democracy, especially with non-proportional voting systems, is that getting elected becomes the only goal, and supporting extreme views is one of the strategy, which has been pushing parties, from all sides, towards extremes. There is a self-feeding vicious circle as soon as one party supports extreme views, it reinforces the opposite party support for the party over ideas, and that now affects the first party etc...

Being informed is like driving, every single person thinks they are better informed than the average! If you don't believe in democracy, can you please tell us what system is better?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illusory_superiority#Driving_a...

Experiences with "sortition" has shown that a group of "average people" tend to make better decisions for the group then a few supposedly "elite".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sortition

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by talideon on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:39AM (#32439356)
I think that the main benefit of sortition is that you end up with a set of people without any need to get re-elected, and that it's this that lends them the ability to make better decisions because their careers don't depend on it.

Here in Ireland, we've had a number of Citizens' Assembly meetings going back just shy of a decade (if you include the 2012 Constitutional Convention, which was effectively the first one in all but name) that have been tremendously productive and have lead to a lot of positive change that would never have happened if it were left purely to professional politicians. You might find it worth a read: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_Assembly_(Ireland)

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by themadturk on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:23PM (#32440764)
> If you don't believe in democracy, can you please tell us what system is better?

Just because you don't believe in something doesn't mean there's a better alternative. It simply means there may not be an alternative to believe in.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by seszett on Friday August 12, 2022 @09:26AM (#32438269)
> If you don't believe in democracy, can you please tell us what system is better?

None that I know of, that is the real tragedy.

On the illusion of superiority, I'm well aware of that but do not forget that it does not mean that some people are not actually better or worse (at information, driving, cooking or anything) than the others.

Some abilities can actually be evaluated, for example there is such a thing as truth, so even though one person can be bad at evaluating themselves, it is absolutely possible to recognise misinformation in others.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by dorfsmay on Friday August 12, 2022 @09:49AM (#32438604)
> it is absolutely possible to recognise misinformation in others.

And this needs to be part of the education, part of the direct democracy.

Keep in mind that in many situations there isn't a single truth, compromises need to be made, different implementations of a system that should work in theory needs to be tested etc... The belief in a single great system has lead to many bad societies.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by PurpleRamen on Friday August 12, 2022 @07:07AM (#32436773)
Not anymore? The article does not mention china at all. Maybe it was corrected in the meanwhile. As I'm reading it, Canada is named as the majority source for seeds.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by latch on Friday August 12, 2022 @07:18AM (#32436833)
your parent means that even the article mentions Canada [so there's no need to just be 'pretty sure']
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by finikytou on Friday August 12, 2022 @06:53AM (#32436686)
I guess you one of the well-informed french that would probably have called on chirac being a crazy man for not siding with usa when they went to bring "democracy" to irak against a bad dictator that had weapons that did not exist. because between above narrative and russian one that went there to "denazify" and fight a dictature of nazis there's not a big difference. every information is one-sided and no one can control it. it is easy to make fun of people that believe things on facebook. much harder to understand that you at your level are also one of them
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by ztrww on Friday August 12, 2022 @07:30AM (#32436921)
While I don't want to justify the invasion (or rather the motivation behind it and it’s actual execution), Sadam’s regime was OBJECTIVELY worse than the Ukrainian government. They are not even on the same level, the Ukrainian government may be thoroughly corrupt but they did not murder hundreds of thousands of their own people (using both conventional and chemical weapons).

The real crime was propping up Sadam in the 80’s when US did not see him as a threat and living him alive in 1991 (which just prove that US had zero actual concerns about the wellbeing and freedom of the people of Iraq in 2003)

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by sudosysgen on Friday August 12, 2022 @09:14AM (#32438086)
It doesn't matter though. Both invasions were based on very similar lies. Just because in Iraq the lies were 10% true and in Ukraine 3% true doesn't make any difference.

The invasion itself was a far far worse crime that supporting Saddam materially.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by throwaway_4ever on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:57PM (#32441906)
> living him alive in 1991

what?

1991 was the same decision to make as 2003, except they chose restraint. When they flipped in 2003, almost everyone universally agrees, including you

> the US war in Iraq was unjustified

it was a bad decision, thus 1991 was the right move.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by ztrww on Monday August 15, 2022 @06:09AM (#32467830)
> except they chose restraint

No they chose to instigate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1991_Iraqi_uprisings and then left the rebels out to dry. Thousands (possibly hundreds of thousands) of Iraqis were killed by Sadam's forces.

The equivalent of 1991 (obviously on a very different scale) would be the Allies stopping at the border of Germany in 1944 (after liberating France) and allowing Hitler to stay in power (while simultaneously claiming that it’s the job of the German people to remove him).

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by nebulousthree on Friday August 12, 2022 @07:59AM (#32437151)
Team America: World Police
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by seszett on Friday August 12, 2022 @09:08AM (#32438004)
Since you were intending to reply to me, I'll try to answer you here.

I'm really not sure I actually understood what you meant, though. In my opinion, the US war in Iraq was unjustified and the Russian war in Ukraine is unjustified as well, and indeed between the US narrative back then and the Russian one today, there is no big difference.

But the main take I get from our conversation is that you were the one that was initially misinformed (thinking French mustard mainly comes from China), didn't read or believe the linked article by a "respectable" established news outlet (that clearly says the mustard in question comes from Canada), then spread your wrong information (in your comment) and now you're trying to say that I'm as misinformed as anyone when you are factually, indisputably, the one person who is misinformed in this particular discussion.

I do believe I am more effective at checking the accuracy of the the information I read or hear about than other people. I do not think that everyone is equally as misinformed, far from it.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by throwaway_4ever on Friday August 12, 2022 @02:01PM (#32441955)
> between the US narrative back then and the Russian one today, there is no big difference.

The US war in Iraq can be unjustified, while the US' intention against an actually terrible Saddam regime being benevolent, while Russia's is actually selfish territorial control and Donbas resources. Equating the Saddam regime to Zelenskyy's Ukraine is egregious.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by finikytou on Sunday August 14, 2022 @05:22AM (#32457787)
I made a mistake between mustard and pickles that are indeed made in china and you directly jumped to me looking at facebook post and being misinformed. but my point is the same. making abroad and branding it as dijon is a fraud.

And just to let you know. go back in time a bit. any one that was against iraq was someone "misinformed" that was not following mainstream opinion. so at that time you would have indeed said that chirac was spreading wrong information :) people like you - the ones that are always on the good side / the right side of history are more dangerous than people that inform themselves on facebook

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by kergonath on Friday August 12, 2022 @07:57AM (#32437133)
> I guess you one of the well-informed french that would probably have called on chirac being a crazy man for not siding with usa when they went to bring "democracy" to irak against a bad dictator that had weapons that did not exist

This was actually probably Chirac’s (and Villepin’s) finest hour.

It is also a non sequitur. Invading Iraq was (as was predicted back then) a catastrophe. We are still paying for it, even France, and will in the foreseeable future.

Invading and annexing a peaceful, if corrupt, neighbouring country, however, is much worse. Genocide in Iraq was well documented and at least the point could be made. There is nothing remotely similar in Ukraine, even ignoring both bits of disinformation (WMDs in Iraq and Nazis in Ukraine).

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by suoduandao2 on Friday August 12, 2022 @11:20AM (#32439902)
I think the point GP was trying to make is, the 'good old days' when there was no misinformation was when it was still possible to manufacture consent without your rivals interfering. The current wave of competing worldviews is... one could say difficult to assimilate... but if people evolve better bullshit filters as a result, we'll probably be better off than when we were being fed smaller amounts of bullshit from only one entity at a time.

Which doesn't help your family and their weak bullshit filters, of course, and my condolances for their situation - if I knew how to speed up developing such a filter, I'd share it.

Edit: Didn't realise GP wasn't addressing you, my comment on your family was meant for someone else - how easy it is to be confused by online discussion even without bad intentions.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by gambiting on Friday August 12, 2022 @07:58AM (#32437141)
>>I guess you one of the well-informed french that would probably have called on chirac being a crazy man for not siding with usa when they went to bring "democracy" to irak against a bad dictator that had weapons that did not exist.

I'm not french, I have no idea who "chirac" is, and in general I think you maybe replied to the wrong comment?

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by finikytou on Friday August 12, 2022 @08:16AM (#32437335)
sorry my reply got wrongly placed I was talking to seszett