> (A) Modern computers run on electricity [not ones and zeroes]
> (B) one could build a computer out almost anything that lends itself to both being on and off
You got it right in B, which is exactly the point when people say computers are just 1s and 0s. Computers are a mathematical concept, not just some electrical device, as you seem to claim in A. The fact that you can build a computer out of water or air pressure or Minecraft Redstone is exactly the point people are making when they say they're built up from 1s and 0s (not electricity, not silicon and copper, not Redstone).
Granted, many of these people have been around since before typewriters and phones were a common thing, but the ”1s and 0s” explanation does not offer anything tangible for people who cannot see the trees from the forest (sic), and thus it only widens the ”digital divide”.
In my experience the best thing to get people interested in computers is to show them more than MS Word in school. Fortunately a substitute teacher was more competent than that and absolutely blew my mind with a for loop.
Imagine if people generally understood that automobile combustion engines work by ”combusting fuel” without knowing anything more about their car.
That’s absolutely true in a sense, but if we left things at that, drivers would probably be inclined to think some kind of magic is happening, because that’s what science thought of combustion for a long time! (see ”Phlogiston theory”)
I wonder how those drivers would explain the functioning of the pedals and the shift knob.
> Imagine if people generally understood that automobile combustion engines work by ”combusting fuel” without knowing anything more about their car.
No need to imagine.
There's lots of different answers here in different contexts. The reason 1s and 0s are good is because they represent the information in the digital domain, not the implementation in the analogue.
Then people kept wandering up and agreeing with me and by the end it was practically an intervention.
Long before standing for true or false, 1 and 0 have stood for the presence or absence of something arbitrary, so I don't see any issue here.
- byte and word size,
- endianness,
- semantics of what means what in a string of bits (think Two’s Complement, IEEE 754, ASCII, ISO-8859-1, Shift-JIS, Unicode),
- what it means to do certain operations on bits (Boolean algebra),
- how different binary operations can be constructed from transistors / logic gates (ALU design),
- how information can be retained in and recalled from memory (basically just flip-flops),
- how said memory is laid out with respect to internal/external devices and program regions (conventions!)
- how said memory can be addressed, and how information can be transferred between CPU and memory (bus architectures),
- how the computer architecture can be programmed to do things (processor instruction sets),
- and whatever I forgot just now…
And then some people design and build trinary computers, imagine that.
(There is no completion. The trailing off is intended.)
It is true in the sense that 1 and 0 are common representations for true and false in computer science, but really, it is false and almost certainly establishes magical thinking in the layperson.
Modern computers run on electricity, and in electrical circuits such as computers, true/false is represented as a transistor semiconductor being in a conducting or non-conducting state. Current can either flow, or it can’t.
In fact, one could build a computer out almost anything that lends itself to both being on and off, and to being controlled by its on/off state (or that of another equivalent assembly).