News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by Matt_Cutts on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:16PM (#3239659)
For the vast majority of users, things like spelling correction are a huge help. Roughly 10% of all queries are misspelled. Switching the default to "search for exactly what I typed" would hurt those users and lead to more spam and malware for the average user.

We try to find the balance that helps users the most, and searching for a term with "term" or the literal mode provides an escape hatch for power users.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by JoshTriplett on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:46PM (#3239826)
Personally, I like the previous "did you mean" behavior; if Google thinks I misspelled a word, or that I want a synonym, by all means give me the alternative, but by default I want the exact query I searched for, because more often than not I really did mean what I searched for rather than what Google thought I meant.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by daveungerer on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:11PM (#3239938)
Can't agree enough this. I'm pretty sure user interface research has shown that it's incredibly frustrating to users when you tell a computer to do one thing and it does something else. The suggestions are helpful, but it should default to what I tell the fucking thing to search for!
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by JoshTriplett on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:45PM (#3240113)
If the computer successfully guesses exactly the thing you wanted and does that instead of what you said, it can make you marginally more happy than a "did you mean", since it avoids the reaction of "well why didn't you just do it then?".

However, if the computer guesses wrong, that will cause significantly more frustration to the user. This disproportionate amount of annoyance means that the computer must guess correctly far more often than it guesses wrong. Unfortunately, Google's current system frequently guesses wrong, and then compounds those incorrect guesses by using them by default, taunting the user with their original search.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by moultano on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:11PM (#3240546)
That's been our observation as well, and we've tried to constrain launches in exactly that way. Techniques that can fail in a way that disrespects the query have to have a much much higher win to loss ratio in order to launch.

What I think we're understanding now is that something that fails 1% of the time, might not fail for just 1% of queries, it might fail for 1% of the users and work perfectly for the rest, and that small set can be really unhappy as a result. This is one small step in the direction of fixing that, but it's an issue we're paying close attention to, thanks in part to the feedback we've seen on HN.

We very much want to avoid systematic failures like this, and if technical queries are a blind spot then please send them over whenever you see them. My email is in my profile and I'll make sure they get routed appropriately, and I tend to watch threads about Google trying to get good examples to debug.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by TillE on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:20PM (#3240581)
I'm getting worse and worse results for all sorts of queries over the past few years, not just technical ones. I can't think of specific examples from the main search right now (I finally snapped and switched to DDG a few weeks ago), but here's a particularly terrible one from the Android Market:

https://market.android.com/search?q=yore&so=1&c=apps

I appreciate that Google thinks I'm an illiterate chimp who doesn't know how to spell "your", but really truly, I was looking for a game with "yore" in the title. That's why I typed it. It's even an English word.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by JoshTriplett on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @06:24PM (#3240843)
> What I think we're understanding now is that something that fails 1% of the time, might not fail for just 1% of queries, it might fail for 1% of the users and work perfectly for the rest, and that small set can be really unhappy as a result.

Excellent insight. Linux kernel developers have had a similar experience with the use of the likely() and unlikely() hints on conditionals; it took a while to realize that unlikely() has to mean unlikely for any user, not just "unlikely for most users, and likely for the rest". So, for example, it doesn't make sense to write "if (unlikely(feature_disabled))", because anyone with the feature disabled will meet that condition every time.

I've definitely had the experience that Google's automatic correction does the wrong thing for me more often than not; I almost always end up clicking the link to go to the search results I actually asked for.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by moultano on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:09PM (#3241392)
Send over the examples when you come across them (or if you have it turned on, try www.google.com/searchhistory/ to find queries you've issued in the past.) I'll make sure they get to the right place.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by edanm on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @03:40AM (#3242355)
"I'm pretty sure user interface research has shown that it's incredibly frustrating to users when you tell a computer to do one thing and it does something else."

You honestly believe that Google is doing something that is worse for the vast majority of their users? That makes the vast majority of their users more frustrated? And that they know this is true because research has proved it?

Why would they act like that?

Most of the people in this thread keep forgetting that they're not regular users. I'm willing to bet that the average Google user (90% of the population) often mistypes. I know I do, and I'm a pretty good speller and typist.

You keep forgetting that most people can't type fast, can't spell that well, and you know what, a lot of the people typing on Google don't even know English all that well, either. For them, Google's spelling auto-correct is incredibly useful.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by daveungerer on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @04:19AM (#3242443)
You're putting words in my mouth. Please don't do that.

I think it should be a given that it's frustrating when a computer doesn't do what you tell it. That doesn't mean that the cost of that frustration isn't offset by the added convenience for many users. In my case it isn't, and those (relatively frequent) times when it does frustrate me, I seriously consider switching search engines.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by edanm on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @04:21AM (#3242454)
"You're putting words in my mouth. Please don't do that."

You're right. I'm sorry.

For the record, most of my comment was addressed to everyone in this thread, not just to you.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by eavc on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:38PM (#3240386)
Actually, spelling might be the only exception to that rule.

If you genuinely misspell a word, it's nice to have it fix it for you in one motion.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by waqf on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @06:10PM (#3240806)
Funny, for me spelling is least likely to be an exception to the rule. If I misspelled a word in my query then I meant it to be misspelled ... I was probably trying to track down a specific article in which I knew the word to be misspelled, or else I wanted to know how common the misspelling was. And my experience is that Google hates me a little more every year.

Meanwhile, the synonym replacement is actually helpful sometimes. I wish I could turn off one without the other: that's why "verbatim mode" isn't going to do it for me.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by nzmsv on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @08:01PM (#3241173)
There's a magic "nfpr=1" flag in the query string that seems to revert back to the old "did you mean" behaviour. Sometimes it randomly fails though. I don't know if this feature is going away with this update.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by scott_s on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @11:31PM (#3241782)
I guess I'm in the minority here. I'll even often use Google as my spell checker.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by barrkel on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @08:11PM (#3241199)
Fully agree with this. Approximately 90% of the time Google thinks I misspelled something, it's wrong.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by Steko on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @08:58PM (#3241356)
For me it's the opposite but I'd love to be able to manually toggle these things on or off.

My ideal setup might be to get url bar searches to show regular google and ctrl-k searches to be google verbatim searches.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by jerrya on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:14PM (#3241400)
This is especially true on Android and other low bandwidth/hard to type devices, where I have time and again searched for the specific exact thing I am looking for only to have instant search and spelling correction help me find something I could not care less about.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by kitsune_ on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:48PM (#3239833)
I think the algorithm does too many "magic" things lately. I've noticed this when I had some search queries for "flask" (python micro web framework) and some programming related input and most of the returned results were about "flash".
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by Matt_Cutts on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:56PM (#3239877)
We're always trying to find the right balance. The nice thing about this change is that it gives people an escape hatch if we get it wrong. In theory, I could imagine we could look at the corresponding data to improve the balance in the future too.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by strictfp on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:16PM (#3239973)
Could you not add a hacker mode? Put it at google.com/h or something and remove all the cuddly fuzziness that drives us power users completely mad. I'm sure your intentions are good and that the latest changes are helpful for many or most users. But I for one have always enjoyed Googles assumption that the user is intelligent and therefore never autocorrected me, countrary to for instance MS office. Suggesting corrections does not interrupt my flow and are generally helpful. Auto-corrections are in great part highly disruptive for me. Please don't deviate from this very sound principle, at least not for us power users.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by Matt_Cutts on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:36PM (#3240073)
I think of this literal mode as pretty close to the hacker mode. Most of the time our query rewriting is an improvement, but we wanted it to be very quick (just a couple clicks) to go into hacker mode if we get things wrong.

My hunch is that someone could a search shortcut for verbatim mode, but if you used it enough you'd find that you missed the query improvements.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by waqf on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @06:15PM (#3240816)
Can I enable literal mode permanently with a cookie? Otherwise, you better make sure that going into literal mode is fewer clicks than, say, going to DuckDuckGo.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by conradfr on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:33PM (#3240649)
I was thinking the same thing lately. I've wondering if I was crazy to notice that Google was ignoring my " ".

It is quite infuriating.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by timtadh on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:21PM (#3239691)
How do you tell the difference (for mis-spelled words) between people doing an actual search and people spell checking a word? It could be that a significant percentage of the 10% are not "search queries" but "spelling queries"
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by smackfu on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:18PM (#3239672)
If only Google had some sort of "account" system that could store user-specific preferences...
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by Sargis on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:24PM (#3239708)
It'd be better if we could just append a "v" after the URL to make verbatim searches. That way we can bookmark it and there will be no need to be logged in.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by botker on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @10:20PM (#3241588)
You can. Append:

  &tbs=li:1
Ugly, but it works.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by noibl on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @10:32PM (#3241611)
Heh, I just found this too and added it to my default omnibox search in Chrome.

You may have to add your own to the list:

hXXp://www.google.com/search?q=%s&le=en&start=0&tbs=li:1

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by bambax on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:11PM (#3240254)
Although now is not the time to be picky (to be thankful, rather), why not simply let logged in users default to literal search, while still displaying the "did you mean" suggestions somewhere on the page...?
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by rhizome on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:46PM (#3240117)
For that 10% figure to be meaningful, we'd need to know how many people are trying to search for something precise and not receiving it.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by anjc on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:00PM (#3239894)
Spelling correction has nothing to do with "" being worse than +.

I think a lot of us would welcome spelling suggestions while we're using our + operator.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by ars on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @10:42PM (#3241639)
All I really want is for google to tell me when it didn't search for what I wrote. I put a word in the search, I expect it in the results - even if the result has a low page rank.

If you want to default considering some words optional, that's fine. But say that above the search results.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by SCdF on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @06:31PM (#3240878)
I use Google as a spellcheck quite a bit, because it's generally better at working out what my tortured attempt at spelling really means than dictionary sites / apps.

I wonder how many of the 10% are intentional.