News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @11:45AM (#3238850)
Cool. Portable. Cheap. Can run Quake II.

But what does that get you? Still need to plug into a monitor, keyboard, mouse. So you can only use it where those things are.

For real portability, how about an SD system thumb drive I can plug into any computer, and it boots as my computer. That would be portable. Useful for a student lab, at my Mom's house, in a hotel.

Just a thought.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by beagle3 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @12:52PM (#3239220)
> For real portability, how about an SD system thumb drive I can plug into any computer, and it boots as my computer.

Linux distributions have been doing this very successfully for the past 9 years (knoppix paved the way, but almost every linux distribution today can run live from a CD/SD/DiskOnKey, and store your data on an SD/DiskOnKey (the same one, if properly partitioned).

And it's unlikely a hotel or your student lab would actually let you reboot into your own distribution; once you have control of the hardware (which you must have), you practically own it from that moment.

CherryPy is actually a much better solution than yours:

Your lab, and your hotel room, is likely to have a screen that can take VGA or HDMI input - so you've got a display; You can get foldable silicon keyboards for $10 or so, and a small travel mouse for $10 more. So, for $45, you have something you can _already_ use at your lab or hotel room, with no one having to fear you're putting viruses on their system.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by 101000101 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:49PM (#3239515)
A comment like Joe's really surprises me. Time and again I see brilliant coders who for whatever reason cannot see the path to making their own live USB/SD sticks.

But there's a better solution than beagle's suggestion.

Sell hardware that has no bundled OS. Sell different OS's on removable media (e.g. memsticks). Or users can create their own OS memsticks.

Apple is primarily a hardware company, as evidenced by the value they place on their design team and design patents, and where they derive the lion's share of their revenue.

If I could buy Apple hardware without it being tied to Apple's OS's, I would be willing to pay Apple hardware prices more frequently.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by beagle3 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:36PM (#3241467)
I've read all of Joe's comments in this thread, and I'm not really surprised. He is either a troll (and not a very successful one if he is), or, more likely, a bigot who believes that the any software worth running costs >$100 (office, photoshop).

Unfortunately, he represents a non-negligible majority of users out there. But I care not discussing anything with him and his like on HN. I've got better use for my time.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by 101000101 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @10:49PM (#3241652)
Maybe he works for a company that sells software priced at over $100?

I have no doubt such companies have employees, or contractors, who not only monitor message boards on behalf of the company, but who post comments on them in a deliberate attempt to influence discussions in ways favorable to the company's interests. Whether they are effective is another question. But they are trying.

Younger readers should be aware of this as they are the ones being targetted.

Perhaps it's not that a majority of users are convinced price equates to quality control so much as a majority are aggressively manipulated in terms of what information about software they are exposed to.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by DanBC on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:07PM (#3239599)
uh, you can run other OSs on Apple hardware. It's a little bit trickier because of EFI but it's not hard.

What you can't do (Apple say) is run Apple OSs on non-Apple hardware.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by 101000101 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:03PM (#3239901)
I don't want the Apple OS. Remove it completely from the hardware, make the firmware more friendly to non-Apple OS, then I'll buy more Apple hardware.

Other than NetBSD, I was not aware it's "easy" to run other OS's on Apple hardware. Knowing Apple, I'm still not sure I believe it.

But I will investigate. Thanks for the FYI.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by aidenn0 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @10:25PM (#3241599)
It's actually pretty easy to do. I've seen several Windows, several BSDs and linuxes as well as some open-solaris derivative on x86 Macs.

The PowerPC macs are a bit less well supported just because there are fewer distros for PowerPC, but on the other hand, since apple's pretty much abandoned them, going with linux or a BSD has its own advantages

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by srl on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:51PM (#3240731)
_I was not aware it's "easy" to run other OS's on Apple hardware. Knowing Apple, I'm still not sure I believe it._

I run linux (arch now, but once ubuntu) on a MacBook5,4. It's somewhat harder to get set up if you want to dual boot (the dual partitioning scheme is finicky, and although linux doesn't need it, OS X forces you to use it if there's a foreign OS, ugh..). See http://wiki.freebsd.org/AppleMacbook and https://help.ubuntu.com/community/MacBook .

Only one proprietary driver (for wireless) is needed - the rest Just Works. (And flash plays smoother than on OS X :P )

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by kennywinker on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @11:59PM (#3241867)
I tossed a ubuntu cd in my MacBook Pro, rebooted holding down option, and it booted up just fine. Could it be easier?
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by DanBC on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @02:13AM (#3242187)
One thing that could be easier is booting MacBook Pro from USB stick. A Unetbootin that works on Mac, and builds usb sticks bootable on Macs, would be good.

Or maybe bootcamp could mention Linux.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by 101000101 on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @03:28AM (#3242330)
My preference is to use only the bootloader for the OS I'm booting, as opposed to a "boot manager" that presents a menu of OS's. I avoid using chaining techniques the way something like GRUB does. And I don't use MBR's if I don't have to. Disklabels alone will suffice. So the stick contains only an OS-specific bootloader and the OS, usually just a kernel with embedded ramdisk or a loadable kernel module containing a filesystem and userland. I keep it very simple.

This works well for me with PC's. Would this work with today's x86 Macs?

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by nobody31415926 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @11:06PM (#3241710)
I installed Windows as dual boot on a friends Mac. It's far easier than installing it on a windows PC. Put in the windows disk and follow the Apple instructions - it includes all the drivers and even gave advice about sharing files .
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by willyt on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:27PM (#3239724)
But you can already buy apple computers and run Windows, Linux, OS X or a combination of all three. I dual boot osx and windows on my laptop.
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:12PM (#3240257)
Joe here - I am unaware that USB/SD sticks are fast enough to run as my system drive. Ok, cool. I haven't used a stick in years (ever since this new thing called the Internet showed up).

Yes, agree with Mr Binary - in a perfect world, computer hardware and software are completely divorced. The hotel wouldn't worry about viruses, because there would be no storage on their computer at all - I provide that with my stick. All I need is a 'kiosk computer', hardware that I can repurpose.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by vidarh on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:16PM (#3240569)
> I haven't used a stick in years (ever since this new thing called the Internet showed up).

The first USB sticks came on the market in 2000, so I very much doubt you stopped using them before the Internet showed up.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by 101000101 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:06PM (#3240521)
If what you're using works for you there's little reason to switch. I have had certain consraints in how I use computers that motivated me to explore different alternatives that "do more with less". But as users demand smaller devices and more portability I'm beginning to wonder if these "unconventional" alternatives are not generally useful for others besides me.

Not only do I divorce the OS from the hardware, but I separate the OS from my personal data. Unless I have both wholly residing in RAM (which I find generally faster than HDD or USB/SD), they are not on the same media. As much as possible I try to make the OS read-only and the media used for data (e.g. RAM for short-term data storage or HDD for long-term data storage) read-write. Perhaps there are parallels to certain object file formats and their separation of code and data.

I've also thought a lot about and experimented with the use of separate, simplified, fast-booting OS's for different purposes. I am forced to use different OS's to perform certain tasks. But the popular all-purpose OS's are huge and often I only need a small fraction of their functionality.

What if we did not think in all or nothing terms about OS functionality? What if some OS's were small and only limited-purpose?

Rebooting is the slow step. But these limited-purpose OS's, being small and simple, can be very robust and responsive once booted.

The smaller the kernel and userland, the more RAM I have for storage.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by jodrellblank on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:20PM (#3239369)
What it gets you is the ability to give it to a household with a TV, and they can have a computer to play with cheaply.

It's not meant for us, it's meant for people with no computer, or maybe one computer they aren't allowed to (or don't dare to) fiddle with in case they break it. It's for educational use.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by codedivine on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @12:18PM (#3239053)
Well, I think the idea is that you will plug it into a TV that you probably already have in the house. Thus both the HDMI port and composite TV-out. Keyboard and mouse still will be required though.
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by andyking on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @12:29PM (#3239113)
Rather like some of the early, low-cost home computers which came out of Cambridge in the 1980s; see ZX Spectrum. It almost feels like history coming back on itself.
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by eugenejen on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @11:49AM (#3238871)
I want to use them as cheap embedded systems that without KVM.
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @11:55AM (#3238908)
Right, that's the primary use in my mind. Not gonna be much use to a primary school student.
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by ctdonath on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:54PM (#3239540)
Au contraire, it's perfect for kids. First off (as a parent of two toddlers) it's CHEAP; if a kid manages to destroy it (the little entropy generators kids are), so what - get another. Next, it starts so simple (and CHEAP) that you'll have no qualms about running simple cheap software on it. Then, you'll think nothing of putting money into a computer for any/all TV in the house (I'm waffling about a Mac Mini, but a RasberryPi is a no-brainer). So there's an easy, cheap, nigh-unto-disposable (we're talking kids here) computer that can run powerful stuff yet you'll have no qualms about devoting to a young mind.

BTW: I started programming in 4th grade, with printing terminals and acoustic-coupled dial-up mainframes. A few years later I had a then-equivalent of the RasberryPi: Dad soldered together a $100 Sinclair ZX-80 (likewise, the screen was your TV), and I programmed that thing darn near non-stop. Heck yeah the RasberryPi is "gonna be much use to a primary school student". Can't wait to get my kids going on it.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:16PM (#3240274)
Sounds idyllic; but what are you going to run? The latest Office suite? Photoshop?

Whatever you answer, the cost dwarfs the device, and swamps its processing power.

So, we're talking about teaching kids to use some special kid-computer with software/tools they will never encounter ever again. What tools are these? A BASIC interpreter?

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by vidarh on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:13PM (#3240553)
> Whatever you answer, the cost dwarfs the device, and swamps its processing power.

Linux costs 0, and runs on far less capable devices than the RaspberryPi.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by colomon on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:33PM (#3240646)
And is already ported:

"What Linux distros will be supported at launch? Debian, Fedora and ArchLinux will be supported from the start." (Raspberry Pi FAQ)

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:38PM (#3240674)
So, Photoshop for linux? Mac dev tools? What apps?
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by vidarh on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @06:06PM (#3240794)
Why don't you go look up Linux, that way I don't have to list tens of thousands of applications, including dozens of language implementations. If you want someone to learn software development, or computing in general, Linux is a far better starting point than Windows or OS X.
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @11:31PM (#3246391)
Yeah, yeah. Lots of open-source half-baked projects with no support and incomplete features. Advertised as "photoshop replacement" or "complete IDE" but turns out, missing critical features, crash right and left, won't work on modern hardware etc etc.

Been down that road, burned more times than I can count. I wish it were true, but I don't fool myself into believing it.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by burgerbrain on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:09PM (#3241390)
You do realize that with the exception of one or two of the IDEs, the "mac dev tools" run or originated on Linux or other similarly now free systems, right?
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by ctdonath on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:45PM (#3241491)
In 6th grade I learned programming on a $100 computer with 1/1,000th the speed of this and 1/1,000,000th the memory and, yes, a BASIC interpreter.

Load DSL (Damn Small Linux) on this, get gcc set up with a decent minimal text editor, and yes I'll start them with C++ from the ground up - akin to how I started, but with industry standard tools from square 1 and more introduced as they progress.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by gravitronic on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @12:21PM (#3239070)
It will be all in the software. Make this thing boot into a python IDE with pygame installed and you have this generation's QBASIC.
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by tlear on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:18PM (#3239673)
I would prefer lua, but completely agree I am buying one for every kid of every relative or friend of mine age 3+
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by nitrogen on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:17PM (#3241411)
I bought my first PC when I was eight (at a very discounted price from my parents). I already knew how to do trivial graphics programs in Logo. I had a "100 in one" electronics kit as well, but didn't have anyone to teach me how to read schematics. So, I got the example circuits running by following the numbered wiring sequences printed below the schematic. I learned how to use DOS before that by watching the output of my parents' first computer as it ran through AUTOEXEC.BAT (I was insanely excited when I typed "prompt SpSg" into a command line and the computer actually did something -- later on I figured out that the S should have been a $). By the time I was 13 I was buying scrap computer parts, assembling working computers, and selling them. Don't underestimate the potential of children.
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by easp on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @06:30PM (#3240872)
You seem to have fixated on the portability. Understandable, but I don't think that is the point. The point is to build a cheap but capable device that kids can hack on. The portability is a byproduct of that focus on cost: the fewer parts, the smaller the PCB, the cheaper it can be.

Keyboards and mice are pretty cheap these days. Monitors, not as much, but this can work with TVs, which are surprisingly common, even in the developing world.

Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by digikata on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @08:00PM (#3241172)
If an aspect of this is hackability, I'm wondering if a schematic or a datasheet for the CPU will be released. Under "schematic", in the wiki right now I see a pcb "gerber" layout, and Broadcom isn't one of the more open companies with datasheets. But, I figure they're in a pre-shipping crunch right now, so we'll all wait and see...
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by gps408 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @12:47PM (#3239196)
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by rosstafarian on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:56PM (#3240173)
This thing does 1080p through hdmi and has a hardware video decoder. An xmbc port is being worked on for it, i plan on getting a few of these and using them as xbmc server's on my hdtv's. Can't beat it for $25/$35 + a few bucks for a 4 gig memory card
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by dguaraglia on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @02:43AM (#3242242)
My thoughts, exactly. That's what I have in mind as my first project with these babies. It's the easiest thing to get right the first time around (as it's mostly playing around with software).
Re:Raspberry Pi reveals the final PCB design for the $25 PC by burgerbrain on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:01PM (#3239571)
"Still need to plug into a monitor, keyboard, mouse."

Why?