News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Tells Salman Rushdie He Has to Go By His Given N... by RexRollman on Monday November 14, 2011 @08:40PM (#3236556)
In other words, arbitrary "real name" rules only apply to non-famous people.
Re:Facebook Tells Salman Rushdie He Has to Go By His Given N... by naz on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:28PM (#3236696)
I think this happened precisely because he is famous. Facebook assumed he was a fake Salman Rushdie, and demanded identification.
Re:Facebook Tells Salman Rushdie He Has to Go By His Given N... by darklajid on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:56AM (#3237703)
Right. Now _that_ totally makes sense.

They disabled the page and asked for his ID (okay, your defense, works until now). They got his ID, which according to the article lists a different first name and Salman as a middle name.

Now how can you explain the following discussion? At this point the owner of the account formerly known as Salman Rushdie provided (state issued, no less..) evidence of being that guy - but Facebook claims he has to use the first name listed on the ID instead?

It worked out in the end, but your explanation falls short. The biggest WTF (if we ignore the idea that you should provide a copy of any ID to a site that is used for Mafia Wars and things of similar importance) is the requirement to stop using his middle name.

Even if he _weren't_ the author publishing as "Salman Rushdie" and just some random guy named "Ahmed Salman Rushdie" he should be allowed to go as "Salman Rushdie". Even with a brain-dead real name policy in place. That is his real name.

(Granted: In that case he arguably still shouldn't be allowed to pose as the author. But that's a different problem)

Re:Facebook Tells Salman Rushdie He Has to Go By His Given N... by z92 on Monday November 14, 2011 @11:24PM (#3237017)
That's what probably happened. And I can also assume that Rushdi never tried to claim there "I am the real Rushdi", only tried to show that "My name is Salman Rushdi [too], see my passport, therefore I should be allowed to use this name". While FB was trying to protect that name for the real Rushdi.

If FB employees really knew this is the real Salman Rushdi they are talking with, this probably would have never happened.

Re:Facebook Tells Salman Rushdie He Has to Go By His Given N... by codezero on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:41AM (#3237558)
An easy explanation for this slipping through the cracks is that the person handling this didn't know who Salman Rushdie was.
Re:Facebook Tells Salman Rushdie He Has to Go By His Given N... by officemonkey on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @07:30AM (#3237992)
My friend is a semi-famous Jazz singer named Spider Saloff. FB wouldn't let her join Facebook because "Spider" is not considered a "real" first name. She got the run around because her first name isn't really Spider, she just has gone by it for nearly 30 years. Nope. Go by your real name or go home, said FB.

Finally a friend comes up with the idea: "Spidie Saloff" works like a charm.

Re:Facebook Tells Salman Rushdie He Has to Go By His Given N... by achompas on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:22PM (#3236677)
Salman Rushdie is a NYT-bestselling, world-renowned author and a frequent contributor to The New Yorker and Times. He's hardly a non-famous person.
Re:Facebook Tells Salman Rushdie He Has to Go By His Given N... by mguillemot on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:46PM (#3236752)
I think the parent meant that if you are a non-famous person and this kind of stuff happens to you, then you're screwed.
Re:Facebook Tells Salman Rushdie He Has to Go By His Given N... by RexRollman on Monday November 14, 2011 @10:02PM (#3236810)
Yes. I probably should have phrased it better.
Re:Facebook Tells Salman Rushdie He Has to Go By His Given N... by redwood on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @12:16AM (#3237139)
On the other hand they don't ask for passport copies from non-famous people (I presume and hope, but then again this is a slippery slope)
Re:Facebook Tells Salman Rushdie He Has to Go By His Given N... by msbarnett on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:49AM (#3237449)
They ask for official ID from anyone trying to prove that a name they've flagged is, in fact, their legal name. It's their process for getting your account unbanned.