News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by ehsankia on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:16PM (#32346401)
Another win for the extremist anti-porn group Exodus Cry. They are just using a small handful of cases slipping through the cracks to make it look like PH is doing nothing to moderate this content. Their end goal was never to protect children, their goal is to eliminate all pornography from the internet.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by sandworm101 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:40PM (#32346694)
>> goal is to eliminate all pornography from the internet.

Funny story: Pre-9/11 the Bush administration was talking about cracking down on internet pornography. The Christian right was saying the same things they had about magazines in decades past. So some industry people got together and founded websites dedicated to the most horrible pornography possible, in full expectation that they would be attacked. They were going to be champions of the first amendment in the same was that Hustler magazine had been a generation previously. But then 9/11. The expected crackdown didn't materialize. Those websites are still around, having evolved into some of the biggest names in the biz.

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by Dma54rhs on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:28PM (#32347225)
Right now a lot of socialist parties in Europe want to shut down porn and sex work under the name of feminism as well. As an example Spain where they are also in power. Thinking only about American Christians is short sighted, there's a lot of pressure from people who want nothing to do with Christianity but see the industry as exploitive and anti woman.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by schwartzworld on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:38AM (#32356744)
Maybe, but there is a fundamental difference between being anti-abuse and anti-smut.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by error54 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:11PM (#32347041)
source?
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by sandworm101 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:14PM (#32347080)
https://www.wired.com/2001/01/bush-to-porn-run-for-cover/

06-Jan, 2001.

"The conservative queen of syndicated outrage, who happens to be George W. Bush's pick to head the Department of Labor, has repeatedly warned of what she describes as the perils of sexually explicit material online and urged government action against it. If the Senate gives her the nod, Chavez will not have any day-to-day responsibilities dealing with online speech. But her nomination signals the approach that a Bush presidency is likely to take toward sexually explicit material online."

For the rest of the story, you will have to dig into the history of certain websites that I shall not link to here on HN.

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by nerdjon on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:36PM (#32347313)
I am very worried about where this is going.

We already have enough issues with puritanical people pushing their views on everyone else, but I always felt at least some mild level of safety that I could still mostly do what I want if I was in certain states/cities.

I do realize that Visa was in a really hard place at this point and they likely had to make this decision, so I don't exactly blame Visa here. But it worries me that it could even get to this point that Visa is somehow responsible and I see they are not trying to go over Discover.

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by VictorPath on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:34PM (#32346630)
In 1910, Emma Goldman wrote "The Traffic in Women" about how the supposed efforts against sex traffic in the day had nothing to do with helping women, and were all done for other purposes.

112 years later nothing has changed from what she described - fundamentalist churches in supposed campaigns against sex trafficking, yellow journalists printing sensationalist stories - 112 years and nothing has changed whatsoever.

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by BasilPH on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:58PM (#32346904)
Totally agree. SESTA-FOSTA is just the current instalment of this pattern.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by atlasunshrugged on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:37PM (#32346663)
I think this time it was a win for activist investment given Bill Ackman's investment and tweet thread https://twitter.com/billackman/status/1553510104200351746?s=...
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by iso1631 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:41PM (#32346709)
> Their end goal was never to protect children, their goal is to eliminate all pornography from the internet.

That's never going to happen. All it would do is drive regular porn to the same corners of the internet where snuff films and child porn live, and nobody wants that as that drives more people to those areas.

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by techdragon on Thursday August 04, 2022 @09:44PM (#32350508)
They probably know they can’t realistically drive it off the net, so they are likely well aware that it would end up in those corners… and with my cynicism hat firmly on I think that the organised puritanical groups know this and are hoping they can then use the association with more unpleasant things in those corners of the internet to push even harder on their puritanical agendas.
[dead]
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by GekkePrutser on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:36PM (#32346644)
I understand you may not like porn but why not let other people enjoy it?
[dead]
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by tedunangst on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:46PM (#32346764)
Other people already are allowed to enjoy cigarettes?
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by missedthecue on Thursday August 04, 2022 @10:18PM (#32350738)
It is made more difficult to enjoy a cigarette every year. Taxes go up and up, smoking permissible places become fewer ans fewer, fines get higher and higher...
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by csomar on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:54AM (#32351857)
I mean if you want to smoke, smoke. Smoking and hand-smoking other people is not a good idea, however. The higher taxes, I agree. But that's affecting everything and it's everywhere (inflation is also a tax).

There should be special tax on smoking where the proceeds go to smoking-related healthcare; however.

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by missedthecue on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:50AM (#32356941)
At least in my country, there is a smoking specific tax with proceeds that go to smoking related research and healthcare
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by oarsinsync on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:02PM (#32346958)
I’d like it more if people were welcome to enjoy cigarettes in the same way that they’re welcome to enjoy pornography: not in public places.

Alas, smoking in public places is still permitted, despite the fact that it has negative impact on others in those public places.

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by ALittleLight on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:20PM (#32347141)
In this context the argument against Visa is that (through MindGeek) they are profiting from child pornography, revenge porn, and actual rape pornography. I'm sympathetic to the idea that consenting adults not hurting others should be allowed to do what they want - but that's not the issue here. Real people are really being hurt so saying "Why not let others enjoy it" is beside the point.

If you found out Disneyland employees raped one out of every thousand guests then saying "I understand you might not like Disneyland but why not let other people enjoy it?" Wouldn't be a great argument. I don't think companies should profit off of child, revenge, and rape pornography and if they can't figure out how to run their platform such that they aren't doing that, then they should be penalized or shut down.

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by nemothekid on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:49PM (#32347450)
>they are profiting from child pornography, revenge porn, and actual rape pornography.

This statement buries the lede; MindGeek profits off porn, but it isn't clear to me that "child pornography, revenge porn, and actual rape pornography" are the actual money makers for the company. Is it the case that they are actively distributed and profiting off of said content, or are they just deficient in moderating the platform.

The distinction is important, if all it is is that they are not moderating the platform, the Facebook, Instagram and TikTok have far more cause to be deplatformed by Visa than MindGeek.

MindGeek's platforms gets billions of impressions per day, and I find it hard to believe that most of the world is consuming child porn.

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by peyton on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:30PM (#32347245)
Are you comparing Visa to Disneyland? One’s a theme park, while the other controls over half of all credit purchase volume. It’s more like the power company shutting off access to Disneyland; the likely outcome is the rapists will just move elsewhere—there wasn’t anything Disneyland-specific making them rapists.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by JamesBarney on Thursday August 04, 2022 @04:12PM (#32347714)
I bet the % of sex acts that are non-consensual from Tinder or Bumble is at least as high as the % on porn web sites considering there are more controls around porn and documented evidence of the crime.

There is also decent evidence that proliferation of porn tends to reduce the number of rapes.

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by GekkePrutser on Thursday August 04, 2022 @05:36PM (#32348601)
I know, but the topic in the reaction above was that the real motive behind this was purportedly the banning of all porn by conservative groups and the OP thought this to be a good thing. This is what I responded to.

Of course Child Abuse should be banned but it already is and there are already copious laws against it, which could be brought to bear against pornhub if they really facilitate it. However payment providers are starting to regulate even normal consensual adult porn now, which I definitely object to.

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by TingPing on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:31PM (#32347250)
There is no evidence this is a widespread problem though.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by ALittleLight on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:04AM (#32352707)
It is quite silly to talk about the frequency with which this happens. Knowingly facilitating payments for videos of children being raped is illegal. It's illegal even if you mostly don't do that.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by TingPing on Friday August 05, 2022 @01:04PM (#32358867)
They deleted like 90% of content on their site and required ID verification for all uploads. There is no evidence they knowingly do anything illegal.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by autoexec on Thursday August 04, 2022 @08:37PM (#32350121)
It doesn't matter if it's a website or Disney World. If someone is doing something that is against the law, the police should handle it. There is zero reason for visa, or anyone else to involve themselves (aside from informing law enforcement so that they can deal with the matter).
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by malfist on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:33PM (#32346601)
You know if porn bothers you....you could just not browse it. Leave it for the rest of us. It doesn't impact you.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by Dma54rhs on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:37PM (#32347329)
You live in a society with other people. Unless you're full libertarian it's common sense that we make laws to protect the society from harm like public vaccination programs against diseases etc.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by throwfh80h82 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:13PM (#32347067)
That's really not true. We live in a society and interact with each other, we're not isolated, atomized robots (despite Silicon Valley's best efforts).
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by nerdjon on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:28PM (#32347224)
How does legal consenting porn, sex work, or similar impact you if you are not consuming it yourself?

It has no more of an impact on you than if someone else spends their nights playing video games.

If you have a problem with it existing that is your fault and not the fault of other people. But that is an internalized problem for you.

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by throwfh80h82 on Friday August 05, 2022 @02:07PM (#32359709)
I didn't say I have a problem with it existing personally, but rather that the statement isn't true. It's not personal. All the things you're asserting are also not true, you're just stating your opinion as fact.

It's unclear to me how you'd think the norms and cultural practices of a society don't affect someone living in that society, unless you believe everyone is completely atomized. If everyone is a junkie, and I'm sober, my life is still markedly different living amongst junkies. Just like if a devout Muslim moves from Saudi Arabia to San Francisco their life will be different, even if they maintain their Muslim practices.

If everyone spends their nights playing video games, they'll be tired all day, talking about video games all the time, and I may have difficulty making friends since I'm not into video games and prefer to spend my nights sleeping.

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by knaik94 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:26PM (#32347207)
You can put up a internet porn filter for yourself.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by ravenstine on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:52PM (#32346845)
Maybe Visa should also suspend card payments for the theaters and streaming platforms that enable major Hollywood studios to sweep the jailable crimes of their producers under the rug.

But muh Marvel movies! /s

Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by npteljes on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:23AM (#32353225)
Why is that?
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by NHQ on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:42PM (#32346717)
im having trouble viewing this comment
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by donkarma on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:43PM (#32346729)
Agreed, awful for the mind
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by AlexandrB on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:50PM (#32346825)
So is religion, but I wouldn't advocate for banning it.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by jmprspret on Thursday August 04, 2022 @06:28PM (#32349118)
I see this retort far too often without any actual knowledge whether the person is religious. To be against porn one does not have to be religious.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by amanaplanacanal on Thursday August 04, 2022 @07:10PM (#32349469)
I think the point stands regardless of whether the person is religious or not.
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by jmprspret on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:11AM (#32352753)
Yes that's fair
Re:Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on Por... by LatteLazy on Thursday August 04, 2022 @04:39PM (#32348042)
Perhaps it's time to start regulating it though...