News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by ptr on Saturday July 30, 2022 @04:51PM (#32290186)
So, what are we supposed to do with actual Russian disinformation? Or are you saying it doesn’t exist?
Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by miracle2k on Saturday July 30, 2022 @04:57PM (#32290243)
You let it be published and broadcast, like a normal free country would.
Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by simion314 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @05:19PM (#32290445)
In my free country media has to obey rules. There are rules for porn, ads, defamation, bad language. Not sure where youa re from that media can has no rules and they can publish anything without any consequences.
Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by ajsnigrutin on Saturday July 30, 2022 @05:25PM (#32290494)
But that media is not in your free country, it's hosted outside. You're banning people connecting to servers in other countries, hosted under their laws.
Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by simion314 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:16PM (#32290905)
That is irrelevant, Google, PornHub respect the local laws if they want to do business here. I don't think my country constitution protects the free speech of Russian media, they can spawn a local media and then follow the local laws if they want constitutional protection, but just to emphasize in my country TV channels were closed because they ignored the laws too many times and fail to pay their fines.

Also no need to pretend you don't know what Russian version of the "facts" are, you can find what their claim in media and social networks. But in Russia world each fact might be in a superposition of 3 realities, the initial Russian fake reports, then when caught the second altered fake report , and the third convoluted fake version where the army of trolls found all their previous holes and patch them with more idiotic falsehoods. 2

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by ajsnigrutin on Saturday July 30, 2022 @09:18PM (#32292179)
> That is irrelevant, Google, PornHub respect the local laws if they want to do business here

But they don't do business "here", they do their business "there". We're "here" and connecting to their service "there". EU doesn't want us to connect to their business "there".

> Also no need to pretend you don't know what Russian version of the "facts" are, you can find what their claim in media and social networks. But in Russia world each fact might be in a superposition of 3 realities, the initial Russian fake reports, then when caught the second altered fake report , and the third convoluted fake version where the army of trolls found all their previous holes and patch them with more idiotic falsehoods.

I was born in yugoslavia, I know how the government-lead media is. And that's another reason to not-censor foreign media, even foreign government owned, because the real truth is always somewhere between what russians say and what the western media says. I really don't want to read articles like this: https://www.theguardian.com/world/gallery/2022/may/17/evacua...

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by simion314 on Sunday July 31, 2022 @03:25AM (#32293906)
Maybe read higher quality media, if you don't like the West go ahead and read media from here in Easter Europe. I am also checking BBC News and I am plesently surprised that they always mention things like "Ukrainians say" , "Russian diplomat says" , "we can't confirm" . This means that you will get the news with a delay on this website because they have actual employee that will connect with real people in all camps and ask fora response, they also have articles debunking fake news from Russia etc.

I am in EU and I have access to TASS https://tass.com so at least in my country I can get free access directly to Russian main media, I can also see the Russian trolls version of facts on social media and Russia has a group of fans that promote their alternate reality so we are not in "danger" of not knowing what Putin wants us to know.

TL:DR

- we don't have absolute free speech in EU, most constitutions have limits and consequences for bad behavior (we are not USA)

- there is high quality western media(stop reading tabloids)

- if you hate the waste read Easter European media, Ukrainian neighbors have journalists on the ground and they are also more familiar with the history of the region and remember media past Russian/Putin actions

- only a few propaganda media channels might be blocked, there are plenty Russian media channels available, so only "concerned trolls" will raise the issue that we the poor EU guys can't read Putin approved facts.

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by w7 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:51PM (#32291174)
Your entire statement is nonsensical.

If I make a law in my country that allows me to throw rocks at people in another bordering country without repercussions, then that other country should just let me do it because those are my country's laws?

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by ajsnigrutin on Saturday July 30, 2022 @09:21PM (#32292211)
If Netherlands allow smoking marijuana, and your country doesn't, should you remove all the signposts pointing towards the Netherlands (DNS block) and block the border crossings (IP block), because you're afraid some of your people will go there to get high?
Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by w7 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @11:34PM (#32292904)
Again, nonsensical.

You're conflating intent of one law with execution of another.

No one would do that, because it's stupid and ineffective.

Instead you potentially punish the citizen for having committed a crime on foreign soil, and/or arrest the dealer should they come to your country. This is something nearly every nation state already does. Another thing to look at is extradition treaties.

In the case of disinformation, punishing someone for reading it doesn't stop the spread, but the manufacture of it is undesirable. Current execution is the best method to reach the intent, because doing things like blowing up webservers is undesirable.

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by ghostwriter on Sunday July 31, 2022 @05:18PM (#32298937)
> In the case of disinformation

how do you know if something is disinformation if your government blocks your direct access to the content and suggests that you read local moderated outlets instead? You just blindly delegated your conclusion forming capacity to a third party that decides for yourself.

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by trasz on Monday August 01, 2022 @01:00PM (#32308978)
Because all this content is still easily available, it’s just that you need to consciously want to access it instead of being served it by “I’m being lucky”.
Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by ajsnigrutin on Sunday July 31, 2022 @08:39PM (#32300406)
> Instead you potentially punish the citizen for having committed a crime on foreign soil, and/or arrest the dealer should they come to your country. This is something nearly every nation state already does. Another thing to look at is extradition treaties.

But they didn't commit a crime on foreign soil... they did something legal there.

The servers, manufacture and the information is created and stored in russia, and we're just "travelling" (with our IP packets) to russia to read that content there (I'm assuming the servers are located there).

I still remember when freedom of speech was a right people fought for, even if they didn't like what "the other person" said.... sadly, this is changing and bringing with it dark times.

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by w7 on Tuesday August 02, 2022 @07:32AM (#32317337)
> But they didn't commit a crime on foreign soil... they did something legal there.

Irrelevant to how a state chooses to organize its criminal code. If the act is considered severely criminal in nature then most nation states do not care where it occurred, nor should they.

> I still remember when freedom of speech was a right people fought for, even if they didn't like what "the other person" said.... sadly, this is changing and bringing with it dark times.

Lies by foreign actors are not the same as opinions or criticism of a country's own citizens. They are an offense against the public and should be policed. This isn't about simply "not liking what someone said". This is about statements that have negative value; created for the express purpose of causing confusion and harm.

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by xdennis on Saturday July 30, 2022 @11:23PM (#32292858)
> You let it be published and broadcast, like a normal free country would.

You're being irrational. Free countries don't broadcast the enemy's information during a war.

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by vogre on Sunday July 31, 2022 @12:49AM (#32293259)
Are the free countries in war with Russia?

Is US in war with Russia? Is EU in war in Russia?

If so, should we already send nukes?

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by solar-ice on Sunday July 31, 2022 @02:44AM (#32293750)
> Are the free countries in war with Russia? > Is US in war with Russia? Is EU in war in Russia?

Yes.

> If so, should we already send nukes?

No.

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by wiseowise on Sunday July 31, 2022 @03:26AM (#32293910)
The word you’re looking for is “conventional war”. We’re in information war at the current stage.
Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by trasz on Sunday July 31, 2022 @03:57AM (#32294053)
Of course we are at war - Russian nazis invaded, and so we are defending. But you can’t send nukes, because

1. Nukes are bit more complicated than vodka or coal, and given that nowadays Russia can’t even make a car, nukes need regular servicing, and the rest of its armed forces are a joke, it’s highly unlikely their nukes are any better.

2. Sending nukes would turn Russia into wasteland; rest of the world would do better because of its natural advantage.

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by w7 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:48PM (#32291149)
What is your definition of "free country"?

It seems to have been reduced to "country that allows enemies a free platform".

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by ptr on Saturday July 30, 2022 @05:08PM (#32290350)
I’m sorry but people in general aren’t critical thinkers — broadcasting false and misleading communication should be avoided since it’s extremely dangerous. See the storming of the Capitol Building. It’s especially dangerous when that communication is meant to undermine your country and what your country stands for.
Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by throwaway0x7E6 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @05:34PM (#32290562)
so then why do we have this conversation at all? Russia has done nothing wrong, it's just protecting its own dumb proles from false and misleading information meant to undermine their country and what it stands for.

I delight in the irony

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by ptr on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:10PM (#32290855)
Maybe that’s what it all comes down to if you can’t reference “truth”. People can pick the side that appears to be the lesser evil.
[dead]
Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by ptr on Saturday July 30, 2022 @05:33PM (#32290552)
Relevance? Why do you feel a need to pull out such arguments when we have a complete war criminal over in the kremlin?
Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by ajsnigrutin on Saturday July 30, 2022 @05:47PM (#32290686)
It's relevant, because we didn't ban western media (well, our own) back then, for spreading false propaganda (ending in many many deaths), and we're banning RT now, because it's "them" and not "us".

If we hate false news/propaganda/... then ban cnn (and many other media), but we clearly want (and allow) "that kind" of propaganda, just not the russian one.

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by josephcsible on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:27PM (#32290991)
There's a big difference between intentionally lying and saying things that you honestly believed but turned out to be false.
Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by ajsnigrutin on Saturday July 30, 2022 @09:06PM (#32292084)
I mean honestly.... I know it's not bbc, but still:

https://www.theguardian.com/world/gallery/2022/may/17/evacua...

Look at the headline image, the title ("evacuated"), and the "feels" that they're trying to produce. And the reality? They surrendered and were taken as prisoners of war to siberia.

If someone has surrendered, i want our media to report "surrendered" and if they were taken as prisoners, I want to see "prisoners" mentioned somewhere... I have no idea what they were trying to achieve with an article like this, but it sure as hell wasn't truthful reporting.

Re:Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship by CamperBob2 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:16PM (#32290910)
Whataboutism is a longstanding Russian doctrine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_you_are_lynching_Negroes