News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by xg15 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:25AM (#32285640)
> But our businesses are viable as subscription services, and not as one-off or ad-hoc puchase models.

Doesn't explain businesses that had been per-purchase for a long time and are now still switching to subscriptions though. (E.g. photoshop, jetbrains...)

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by ChildOfChaos on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:51AM (#32285763)
Agreed, it's usually nothing to do with the fact they weren't viable before, it's just that subscriptions are more profitable.

With cost of living crisis and such, soon enough though it won't be able to last. People are already cancelling one of the biggest main subscriptions they have (netflix).

Also I fear this is really changing society. Many years ago, as you got older you got into a better place in life because you had saved up and bought all the stuff you need and slowly aqquired good equipment and everything you need.

Now our lives are full of tech that needs to be replaced every couple of years, heck even now headphones have gone wireless, your headphones needs replacing every few years and now with more and more things being subscription, it's fine when your are young, but your not able to save so much as your constantly having to replace/buy new stuff, when your older what happens? You don't have the same stuff you would have built up in the past, you need to keep paying for it all.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by feanaro on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:47AM (#32286073)
What happens is that you'll have to use less stuff and learn to be content with it.

What this means for the endless, exponential "consumer" ideology is that it isn't sustainable in the long run. This should be blindingly obvious but for some reason many people weren't or aren't seeing it.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by xg15 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @11:59AM (#32287795)
There is a difference though between "making the most of what you have" and "navigating a growing amount of deliberate, arbitrary restrictions".

Only because you can't afford a subscription won't mean that people will stop trying to upsell. Instead you'll be constantly confronted with all the things you're supposedly missing out on, will be stuck with purposely annoying workflows and generally will feel like constantly using the shareware version of everything. That's not a future I personally look forward to.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by feanaro on Wednesday August 03, 2022 @06:31AM (#32329881)
Maybe in the short term, but I'm talking about a somewhat longer time frame where the entire world will realize exponential growth is no more. Eventually there will be no more upselling because there will be no one left to buy it.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by spaceman_2020 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:48AM (#32286365)
> your headphones needs replacing every few years

This part is absolutely bonkers to me and absurd that we’ve accepted it.

I’m an amateur music producer. Many producers I know, even pros, use headphones that are years old, some even decades old. Most of the bestselling models haven’t changed at all in decades. You can use them for years and the only parts you need to replace are the ear cushions and cable. Most manufacturers even build them with replaceability in mind with detachable cups and cables.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by golergka on Saturday July 30, 2022 @10:15AM (#32286968)
Different headphones are suited for different use cases. I have AKGs for the studio, Pioneers for DJing and airpods for traveling and video calls. And if there was a more durable version of airpods, I wouldn't buy it anyway because I expect to lose them sooner than they would break anyway.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by pakitan on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:13AM (#32285903)
> Also I fear this is really changing society. Many years ago, as you got older you got into a better place in life because you had saved up and bought all the stuff you need and slowly aqquired good equipment and everything you need.

Your grandfather's wheelbarrow didn't need replacing every 2 years but he also didn't have Netflix. You can easily have your grandfather's lifestyle by buying a future-proof wheelbarrow and cancelling your Netflix subscription.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by williamtrask on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:23AM (#32285952)
Believe it or not the wheelbarrow was considered modern technology at one point.

Software is fixed cost to create and near-free to distribute. Sure there are tiny cloud costs for running things and maybe you need a couple engineers to fix bugs, but the subscription pricing model doesn’t fit this.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by SQueeeeeL on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:35AM (#32286013)
Yeah, your grandfather was still respectable to the average person in his class/social group. Now it's really hard to imagine someone being able to engage socially without having technology of some form.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by jdbernard on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:13AM (#32286189)
Fixed cost to create, sure. Not fixed cost to keep up to date, running on the current version of OS, hardware. The basic design of a simple wheelbarrow has not needed to change since its invention. A wheelbarrow made 30 years ago will still work just fine. Almost no software written 30 years ago will still work on modern systems without someone doing additional work to support it. And for the few that do, no one wants to run the 1990s version. They want to run the 2020s version.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by jagged-chisel on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:37AM (#32286020)
Are future-proof wheelbarrows being made now? If the trend of lower quality power tools has reached wheelbarrows, you probably still have to replace one every few years.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by pessimizer on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:03AM (#32286143)
They're only slightly lower quality, but now you rent them in kg/m increments. Once your account is empty, the wheelbarrow will be disabled until you recharge through the app. If you're done with the wheelbarrow, you should just leave it on the sidewalk. I'm sure someone will pick it up.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by K0balt on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:55AM (#32285781)
This is a much bigger deal than most people appreciate.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by safety1st on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:34AM (#32286008)
It's certainly cause for concern but I would say the major change over the years has been that in addition to buying good and reliable things that last (and maybe are expensive), you can also buy cheap crappy stuff that breaks down.

To use headphones as an example you can still go get a pair of wired Sony headphones that will have great sound and last for a decade for $50. I just did. (Or you can spend more and get even better.)

I've also bought $15 Chinese Bluetooth earbuds that were janky and dead in less than a year.

Sometimes the simple, older, reliable stuff is better.

You can build a desktop PC that will last you for a decade with occasionally upgrading components. Now you can do it with a Framework laptop too.

Personally I bought a nice i7 laptop about a decade ago and will only get around to retiring it this year, it stopped being my main workhorse several years ago but has been great as a secondary living room entertainment machine.

I don't need the latest greatest, I play a lot of retro and indie games and watch movies at picture qualities that video snobs would sneer at, but that gets back to whether you want to develop expensive tastes or not.

Not that life has fundamentally become unliveably expensive.

There are some places where cost of living really is a serious problem - homes, health care, education.

But a lot of this I feel is really about younger generations having voracious consumer appetites, like an absolutely off-the-charts, record-setting desire for luxury and status. A lot of it is driven by a heightened sense of needing to keep up, look good on Instagram etc. which is a whole other can of worms. Do you really need to keep up with the rat race, the Joneses, the latest fashions etc.? Maybe it's different now, but the Boomers went through their own version of this, they had their big hippie anti-materialism movement in the 60's (and then by the 80's they seemed to have forgotten all about it).

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by SQueeeeeL on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:41AM (#32286048)
> But a lot of this I feel is just the younger generations having voracious consumer appetites (and a lot of it is driven by a heightened sense of needing to keep up, look good on Instagram etc. which is a whole other can of worms).

I think a big part of this is just how much better advertising has gotten, basically cementing consumer goods as required to the average person. Add on to that how good high quality laptops are specialized goods for those who spend their lives obsessed with tech (i.e. the framework laptop). If you walk into Walmart or BestBuy, your options will be severely limited to products which aren't built to last. I can't blame anyone for feeling confused when it comes to which products to buy.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by FranzFerdiNaN on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:43AM (#32286056)
Most stuff has significantly degraded in build quality, from clothing to tools to electronics. Planned obsolescence is real. So maybe it’s not the youths and their bad morals, but people getting used to having to replace shit often, or simply not knowing how to find the items that do last longer.

Also, capitalism can’t help but lower the quality of products as a way to increase numbers sold. It’s inherent to the system. Companies would be insane to produce for example a phone that lasts 15 years, it would cut into their profit marges.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by dwighttk on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:01AM (#32286135)
>nothing to do with the fact they weren't viable before, it's just that subscriptions are more profitable.

more profitable is more likely to be viable in more future situations

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by Joeri on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:18AM (#32285928)
Software used to require little maintenance work. You would buy your software and run it without a single byte changed for 5 or 10 years, and then buy a new version. This worked because OS updates were rare, and everything was local and file-based. In the modern era though software requires continuous maintenance, because we expect our data to move freely between all our devices and the cloud, because operating system vendors force breaking changes often (especially apple), because we expect more integrations with other software, and in general because we expect software to continually receive feature updates. This maintenance has to be paid somehow, and subscriptions have proven to be the most acceptable model.

Jetbrains is a great example, because with a steadily growing ecosystem of third party developer tools that they must integrate with, their maintenance cost is probably high and rising. We expect our IDE’s to support everything under the sun but balk at paying for the never-ending work needed to support that. Something’s gotta give in that equation.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by danieldk on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:41AM (#32286042)
I fully agree with your JetBrains point. I use Rust and CLion and they have to continually adapt to new Rust features, etc. I happily pay for my JetBrains All Products Packs and their model is better than most subscriptions, since you get to keep versions that were released 12 months before the end of you subscription.

However, there are a bazillion other applications -- password managers, note taking applications, Git clients, you name it, for which this is not true. I made a very niche-specific GUI application in 2010-2012 (a search application for Dutch treebanks), written with Qt. It runs on Windows, macOS, and Linux. It's effectively abandonware or just done (depending on your perspective). I have released updates since then to make sure it keeps running on the latest OS versions. It takes me, maybe 2-4 hours per year? (Typically replacing some deprecated Qt APIs and I there was one libxml2 API change.)

I think a lot of software companies just want to get on the gravy train. Usually, their yearly price is close to what a perpetual license used to cost. So if you successfully switch to a subscription model, you have much more income than before.

The primarily loser here is the user. You are poorer after an application switches to a subscription model. If a company goes bankrupt or decides to pull the plug, better hope that your data is not in a proprietary format (while I can still run some old WordStar in DOSBox and open old files).

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by bluedino on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:37AM (#32286300)
You can still run 30 year old accounting and manufacturing software on your midsize IBM. Plenty of people still do it.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by imperfect_blue on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:57AM (#32286426)
They do it not because they want to but because they have no choice. The UX on those software are horrible by modern standards and incur massive wastes of manhours.

Had a subscription model been used, those software might have benefited from 30 years worth of usability updates...or they might still be garbage, looking at SAP.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by isoprophlex on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:45AM (#32285734)
Jetbrains actually aren't that user hostile: buy a yearly subscription now, and you get a perpetual licence for the current version.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by cplli on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:45AM (#32285738)
I wouldn't throw Jetbrains in the same boat. I quite like their pricing model. You get to keep the last version, so you're basically paying for updates in the end (which are worth it IMO). On top of that, you get a discount after the first year.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by xg15 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:48AM (#32285750)
Yeah, Jetbrains' model is one of the better ones in that. At least your money doesn't completely vaporize with that, even though you'll still lose a year of features and improvements once you cancel.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by Semaphor on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:57AM (#32285790)
You’ll lose it now, but under the old model you would never have had those features and improvements.

While it took a community outcry, I think Jetbrains now has the best subscription model, that’s a positive for both users and the company.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by xg15 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:05AM (#32285846)
I still think there is a bit of a dark pattern in it, because when you cancel, you have to give up features which you've already been using for a year and likely integrated into your workflow. In the worst case, there were some breaking format changes and your project files are not compatible with the version you'll be rolled back to.

They could just let me keep the version I already have and block me from future updates. The way, they set it up right now, they are deliberately causing some disruption when unsubscribing.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by codq on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:38AM (#32286026)
My favorite pricing model is by the note-taking app Agenda[0].

It's called a Cash Cow[1] model—you make a one-time purchase, which allows you updates for the next year. At the end of the year, you can either purchase another year of updates, or enjoy the full-featured app you currently have.

The thing keeping me from subscriptions is the fact that if you decide you no longer want to pay, you no longer get access. This encourages devs to continue to ship great updates, while not gimping your software at the end of the payment term.

[0] https://agenda.com/

[1] https://drewmccormack.medium.com/a-cash-cow-is-on-the-agenda...

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by O__________O on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:22AM (#32285944)
It does, as OP mentioned, they’re making money doing it and it’s a better business model for number of reasons.

For example, Adobe is the largest SaaS by revenue:

https://www.mikesonders.com/largest-saas-companies/

— Model clearly works if you look at Abobe’s revenue per year since 2004:

https://www.statista.com/statistics/266399/revenue-of-adobe-...

— Here’s a detailed history of Abobe, if you’re interested in the SaaS part, just search for “SaaS” on the page:

https://producthabits.com/adobe-95-billion-saas-company/

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by manigandham on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:32AM (#32285672)
Restate it as "more viable".
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by xg15 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:49AM (#32285758)
Yeah, I'll restate that as "more profitable", a.k.a. "we're greedy and if we can make more money by lowering the quality of our products and restricting the range of people who can use them, of course we'll do that."
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by manigandham on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:56AM (#32286107)
More profitable, of course. Why do you assume a corporation wouldn't do that?

That doesn't mean the rest of your statement, but if that happened then competition in a free market would take care of it. Perhaps you can start the next billion-dollar Adobe?

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by yarky on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:55AM (#32285785)
It does though. Once a new money-making strategy is found to work by a market participant, others will try that same path (it's a competition).

The fact that so many companies are moving to the subscription model shows that it works better than others.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by xg15 on Sunday July 31, 2022 @04:51AM (#32294294)
Yes, and if at some point drugging the users became legal, then the market would adopt this as well if it lead to more profit.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by isitpro on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:05AM (#32285848)
What explains some of that is that when the whole eco system shifts and now each of your competitors has recurring revenues you can not compete.

Want to run an ad? Prices have gone way up because you're the only one that's clinging to the old model. Want to pay premium to hire someone better? You can't, your competitor can because they have turned to subscriptions. In many cases your hand is forced.

Customers vote with their wallets and social shares. If you find a product that it a one time purchase, then you should share it, post about it since you will be rewarding the company, for they sure are not able to compete on customer acquisition.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by rco8786 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:51AM (#32285764)
Dear customers: Also, we realized that even when our ad-hoc purchase models were working that we could triple our margins by making it a subscription service and most people just went along with it.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by torginus on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:29AM (#32286267)
These kinds of software used to be always kind of subscription based - as new language features came out, new IDE features got added, the platform got updated to support new OSes, you would find that Company X would release IDE 2.0

Even if for some reason you didn't need all of this, IDE 1.0 would eventually stop getting updated and the bugs would stop getting fixed, so you would naturally need to update.

Considering people naturally want the latest and greatest, and devs hate maintaining legacy stuff, a subscription makes sense in this case.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by xg15 on Sunday July 31, 2022 @04:48AM (#32294280)
That's moving the goalposts. "Paying for updates" is not the same as a subscription. A subscription is if I pay automatically, no matter what - and usually, I will get some negative change to the status quo once I stop paying: I might lose access to the service immediately, I might be downgraded to a previous version, etc etc.

> Considering people naturally want the latest and greatest

They often don't. Especially with updates, those are often far more in the interests of the developers than of the users. That's why so much development effort has gone into auto-updating schemes.

Remember how much effort Microsoft had to invest to get people off Windows XP. A large part of their userbase would have been perfectly fine with staying on XP for all eternity. It was Microsoft who wanted them to update to Vista, not the users.

Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by bluepizza on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:35AM (#32286014)
Photoshop was way too expensive. Adobe’s subscription system saw most of their illegal users drop their cracked versions and move to a subscription.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by pyrrhotech on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:01AM (#32286133)
take a look at ADBE stock chart before and after they switched to SAAS model
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by ekianjo on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:50AM (#32286380)
stock pricings are poor indicators of performance.
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by pyrrhotech on Saturday July 30, 2022 @10:49AM (#32287210)
in the short run, yes, in the long run, no
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by cptaj on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:10AM (#32285880)
Heated seats
Re:Dear startups: I hate subscription services (2021) by danielvaughn on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:59AM (#32285800)
These weren’t online, so you had to pay for new versions of the software. Do you want to pay again each time a new version of a website is released?