I guess there must be further detail in the paper and I will have to read it to understand the nuance.
Another question is whether this increases the total amount of successful donations. I was looking around for studies and found this one [1], which basically says "in some countries, yes".
[1] https://behavioralpolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Does...
That is, all you're doing is tricking people who didn't read carefully. People don't know they've opted in and would opt out if you called and told them that they checked the box.
I find it generally plausible that defaults don't matter much for what people consider very important decisions. I have minimal experience in this area, though.
https://blogs.bmj.com/medical-ethics/2017/09/25/organ-donati...
Capital wants to have the spigot left on. If people don't feed the beast voluntarily, Capital will make that the default.
Id say this is a large part of the reason Gmail, Android and Chrome exist.
My pet theory is, these results hinge on, “does it scale?”
Like, yes, you can do nudges and see behavioral changes. But what about when everyone is doing it constantly? Then people will get fatigued and form countermeasures.
Imagine this dynamic in another context:
“Guys, guys check this out, people are guaranteed to buy your product if you show arguments for it to random people!”
But, oops, centuries of marketing later, advertising isn’t automatically effective enough to cover its costs, people don’t automatically believe the ads.
https://sparq.stanford.edu/solutions/opt-out-policies-increa...
I grant that it would be surprising if it had no influence at all, but I think the effect is more the social signal that you should want to save the max, that your neighbors probably do (it's the default after all), etc., rather than people completely ignoring/missing it.
Again, it would be surprising if it didn't matter at all, but not unimaginable. What you're saying is that almost everybody in your company would have contributed a lesser amount if not for the default. It means you can all afford to give up $20k or whatever in income this year. There are other factors.
There is no truth to the matter of "whether defaults change behavior". This thread started about 401ks and then was taken into color preferences on the web. If someone has a gun to their head is asked if they want to die, I'm sure we'll agree that whatever the default is doesn't matter. Whether defaults do anything depends on what we're talking about. Nudges might work in web ux but not economics, why is that so incredulous?
Defaults are very strong when there is a lot of uncertainty about the payoffs of different answers.
It's a no brainer that defaults will alter outcomes for users who aren't willing or capable of making a selection for the choice in question.
I mean I just found out two weeks ago you could change the hacker news banner color. Are you telling me I’m in a statistically insignia can’t minority of hacker news users?
Also how many settings are there in the average application, you can’t tell me most users go through all of those settings to get exactly what they want.