News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by nosianu on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:12AM (#32212278)
> genocide

> confiscation of their property and land

Which is how they got it too, so at the very least I would be careful about using that as justification.

From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Haiti#Spanish_histo...

"Following the arrival of Europeans, La Hispaniola's indigenous Taino population suffered greatly to near extinction, in possibly the worst case of depopulation in the Americas."

I don't think that just because it's different people now on both sides makes it possible to use such actions to argue from a moral high ground, the power difference and who oppressed whom remained in place even though the peoples changed.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by ambrozk on Sunday July 24, 2022 @02:01PM (#32215967)
With Haiti, you don't have to go all the way back to the settling of the island for brutality. The closest analogue I've read to the behavior of the French who ruled Haiti was the treatment of camp inmates by the Nazis. Haiti was the worst colony in the Caribbean. It made the antebellum South look like a utopia in comparison. The life expectancy for slaves sent to Haiti was abysmal. Most of them died on the plantations within about 10 years of stepping on the island. So many died that in order to sustain the slave population, the French had to import tens of thousands every year. They wanted to create a native slave population, but it didn't work because they worked the slave women so hard that they made them infertile. They ruled by means of terror. The stories are sickening. They executed disobedient slaves by stuffing their rectums with gunpowder and blowing them up. They strapped them down and poured boiling cane sugar over their heads. They buried them up to their necks and smeared them with honey so that they'd be eaten by insects. For punishment, they cut off their slaves' limbs and poured hot wax on the stumps. This had gone on for a century prior to the revolution. By that time, there were about 500,000 slaves being ruled over by 30,000 whites (as well as, partially, 40,000 mixed-race Haitians).

It was not smart or good for Dessalines to massacre the 4000 or so whites that he did, but that act is so minor in comparison with the horror that the French visited on Haiti for 100 years that it's barely worth talking about.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Glawen on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:31AM (#32212411)
You forgot to mention that it was due to diseases carried by europeans, it was not voluntary. The 5000 white killed the day of independence of Haiti was voluntary.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by EdwardDiego on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:35AM (#32213383)
Yeah, the Spanish were renowned for their moderation in Central and South America... they never killed anyone on purpose...

Seriously?

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by kzrdude on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:43AM (#32212485)
How many voluntary mass killings of thousands of people did the europeans not commit in their clash with the new world?
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by randunel on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:35AM (#32212834)
As a European whose country suffered and was enslaved for long periods of time, I take offence in the rhetoric of "Europeans" committing such crimes. Be specific, a subset of European nations, a subset of American nations, and a subset of Asian nations try to dominate others through violence.

So, name your country if you've done such deeds, but keep mine out of it.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by orangepurple on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:09AM (#32213130)
To add to this, there are 87 distinct peoples in Europe (Pan and Pfeil (2004))
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by EdwardDiego on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:34AM (#32213373)
Your country joined the Axis, massacred Jews, fought alongside Nazi Germany in Ukraine, and annexed Transnistria.

Really weird hill you've chosen to take offense and die on. But sure, a subset of European nations try to dominate others through violence.

And your country is in that set.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Glawen on Sunday July 24, 2022 @11:06AM (#32214167)
Don't put every european nation on the same scale when it goes to mass killings. Here the subject is Haiti, now please tell me how many voluntary mass killings happened.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Nesco on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:10AM (#32212664)
This is textbook whataboutism
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by kzrdude on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:15AM (#32212698)
That starts with nosianu's post a few levels up, not here, don't you agree?

My response is trying to poke a hole in what Glawen said to deflect.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by nosianu on Sunday July 24, 2022 @02:54PM (#32216471)
Not quite sure about where we ended up here, but just to clarify, just in case.

I don't think it is whataboutism when it is relevant. I think it should have been considered in the initial argument, the one I replied to, to begin with.

The "genocide of its white population and confiscation of their property and land." - from the comment I replied to - was preceded by terrible atrocities by the people then in power against those who revolted (also see the comment from ambrozk). I think that is relevant to the discussion. Whataboutism brings in stuff that is not relevant and unrelated, to distract. I think I'm still right inside the same topic, one leading to the other.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by ZeroGravitas on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:13AM (#32212288)
Confiscation is a strange word to use if the "Property" included slaves:

> France demanding a 150 million franc indemnity to be paid by Haiti in claims over property – including Haitian slaves

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by zajio1am on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:17AM (#32212703)
It is not all or nothing. From today viewpoint, slave freedom and compensation from slaveowners is a legitimate goal, while confiscation of property (especially of non-slaveowners) and genocide is not defensible.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by wittycardio on Sunday July 24, 2022 @04:51PM (#32217583)
Killing of slavers is perfectly defensible actually.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by throwawaycities on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:27AM (#32212373)
The old and rarely used we stole your land and enslaved you fair and square defense.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by mandmandam on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:42AM (#32212476)
Not that rarely used, unfortunately. I've heard this argument delivered genuinely from kind old ladies who care a lot about ethics, history, anthropology etc.

It seems to be the "Godwin's Law" of political discussion. At some point it always goes back to might making right.

... Apologies if that was your [ought to be obvious but these days sure af isn't] point.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by throwawaycities on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:41AM (#32212876)
> I've heard this argument delivered genuinely from kind old ladies who care a lot about ethics, history, anthropology etc.

You ever ask them how many wars they fought?

It’s one thing to champion might is right, it’s another to draw a line in the sand once the slaves revolt and overthrow the slave masters.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by ambrozk on Sunday July 24, 2022 @01:38PM (#32215746)
Note that the "property" that the Haitians had confiscated from the French included, in the opinion of the French government, the Haitians themselves. So the French, in effect, forced the Haitians to pay for the right not to be slaves.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by VictorPath on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:10AM (#32212269)
> confiscation of their property and land

Observe the colonial/imperial mindset - gun-trotting French sail to the Caribbean and steal land from Taino Indians, and kidnap and enslave Africans to do the work. Then back home, the king is guillotined and eventually even Danton is guillotined. The enslaved Africans eventually rebel against the slave masters, and they get into a sanctimonious huff about how "their land" was confiscated.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Glawen on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:40AM (#32212468)
As you mention, it is also not the slaves land either as they came from Africa. So why is it more slaves land than french land?
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by boomboomsubban on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:52AM (#32212543)
Ignoring the evidence that the enslaved Taino to some extent integrated with the imported slaves, the slaves made up 90% of the population and likely an even higher percentage of the workforce. That should give them the best claim to the land
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Glawen on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:52AM (#32214051)
So once we reach 90% of the population we can rightfully claim the land? That's how it works? Let me take note for the future then.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by boomboomsubban on Sunday July 24, 2022 @11:38AM (#32214488)
I mean yeah? If your people spend a century integrating with the locals and working the land to the point where you make up the overwhelming majority of the population, it's pretty fair to say you have some right to it.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Glawen on Monday July 25, 2022 @02:51AM (#32221302)
Well that is one way of achieving it, the other being killing the local population and get more settlers.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by concordDance on Sunday July 24, 2022 @06:42PM (#32218528)
Doesn't every modern nation have the land owned by a tiny minority?
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by zajio1am on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:26AM (#32212773)
Stealing land from Taino people is as much unacceptable as confiscation of land of french citizens, and i am sure if there were some large Taino empire then it could protect property rights of Taino people against colonialists, but that is centuries before Haiti revolution, and since that property rights were clearly established.

If you look on individual level, then it is clear that person A cannot just stole property from person B and defend that by the fact that great-grandfather of person B stole it from person C.