News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by superchroma on Saturday July 23, 2022 @03:08PM (#32206540)
Yet another impractical vaporware passion project with no use-case/demand.

One is left with a feeling, however, that they are missing out on a free money party if this is an example of the level of thinking that is being encouraged. Maybe we should be spitballing ideas to Saudi royalty too.

Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by skippyboxedhero on Saturday July 23, 2022 @03:56PM (#32207005)
> Yet another impractical vaporware passion project with no use-case/demand.

The use case is services professionals extracting cash from extremely credulous members of the KSA royal family (this is part of the new city project, another insane waste of resources).

Softbank raised $50bn in a ten minute meeting with MBS. They then turned around, set the whole thing on fire...this has been going on for almost half a century (the very first financial crisis caused by the Saudis was the boom in EM debt in the 70s, this bankrupted Citi and wasn't resolved fully until the early 90s...they on the same tier as German bankers when it comes to losing massive amounts of money very quickly).

It is a crazy situation.

Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by adhesive_wombat on Saturday July 23, 2022 @04:04PM (#32207087)
To be fair (to be fairrrrrr), extracting huge wodges of a cash from the KSA royal family for "services" and putting it pretty much anywhere else is probably not the worst thing you could do.
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by skippyboxedhero on Saturday July 23, 2022 @04:16PM (#32207191)
It leads to a massive overproduction of people with no skills.

If you take Softbank, some of the stories out of there are insane. People in senior leadership positions doing things that are very weird (one of them was forced out of Softbank, his first move...raising a $5bn+ VC fund from ME investors).

As I said too, it actually has a real impact on the economy. When 2008 happened, everyone pointed to the investment banks..."how could you do this to us?"...no-one asked why investment banks had clients who specifically required investments that were so toxic...I will tell you: Japanese saving institutions, German/French banks, some non-Japanese East Asian saving institutions, and Middle East SWFs (they have been behind almost every financial crisis in the last ten years: MBS, Eurocrisis, Turkey, EM debt, tech...every single time, going back decades).

People ask why financial markets produce things that are pointless...this is why, because the distribution of assets globally is not guided by the market in any way.

Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by tablespoon on Saturday July 23, 2022 @04:48PM (#32207426)
> People ask why financial markets produce things that are pointless...this is why, because the distribution of assets globally is not guided by the market in any way.

What do you mean? Wasn't "the distribution of assets globally" in this way guided by the market? The market wanted oil, so it sent vast quantities of money to the Saudis, who are the most effective producers.

I think this is more an illustration of how the market, left to its own logic, often does pointless or dysfunctional things.

Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by skippyboxedhero on Saturday July 23, 2022 @06:08PM (#32208038)
The most effective producers because of non-economic reasons (i.e. geological properties). So they end up being one of the largest investors in the world because of geology.

The market does often not do pointless or dysfunctional things because markets tend to give most capital to the most efficient users of that capital. But those rules do not apply to things like oil where there are significant non-economic returns (to an extent, the Saudis will always lose all their money, I have named other reasons who repeatedly do the same thing...but it is not terribly efficient spending resources to prise capital from them).

Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by adhesive_wombat on Saturday July 23, 2022 @05:20PM (#32207684)
Expanding the global B-ark personnel manifest is still not the worst thing a trillion dollars in the hands of that theocratic royal family could achieve.

Far, far from the best, but not the worst.

Also the "free market"[1] gave KSA all that money willingly in exchange for oil (as opposed to, say, sorting out alternating energy technologies 30 years ago).

[1]: Well, maybe with a generous geopolitical subsidy delivered by Raytheon and US Marines.

Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by skippyboxedhero on Saturday July 23, 2022 @06:12PM (#32208063)
Again, it caused two decades of political upheaval in South America, multiple military dictatorships, hyper-inflation, economic chaos, etc. (this was all mediated by US banks btw, who were the ones doing the lending...but the reason they were in that position is because ME countries insisted on depositing all their money with US banks).

Right, but the reason the "free market" gave that money was because of the geological properties of KSA, not their ability to invest capital wisely. The failure to realise that this is a path to nowhere is the fault of our politicians however.

For comparison, if I am raising capital for a hedge fund and I start talking about the geological properties of the earth under my house then I will carted out. But that logic is how KSA are one of the largest investors in the world...it is going about as well as you might imagine (the same is true for Taiwan, Japan, Germany in more subtle ways...they have created systems that expropriate wealth from consumers for investors, and those investors essentially spend a huge amount of time setting that money on fire...the only country that has got out of this is Sweden, which decided to give substantially all their material wealth to one family, the Wallenbergs, who turned out to be the some of the best investors globally...but that is a rare example of arbitrary wealth allocation ending well).

Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by adhesive_wombat on Saturday July 23, 2022 @06:41PM (#32208285)
This is also a large part of why the US is as powerful as it is. Through a quirk of history and geography, it found itself with enormous amounts of highly productive land, crammed with resources and thousands of miles and oceans away from conflicts which decimated others.

For all the high-minded aspirations of the early Americans, their grand experiment would not have worked so well if they'd annexed Greenland.

> raising capital for a hedge fund and I start talking about the geological properties of the earth under my house then I will carted out.

Certainly they'd be wondering why you're faffing about with a hedge fund when you could be mining that.

Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by MomoXenosaga on Saturday July 23, 2022 @04:56PM (#32207473)
Less credulous and more desperate. Saudi Arabia needs something that can sustain the current lifestyle of Saudis when oil and gas revenue start to go down.
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by Oarch on Saturday July 23, 2022 @03:34PM (#32206807)
You're right about that. I personally know 2 people about to leave the UK to work on Neom (one of 3 new cities they're building) and you wouldn't poach them without a mind blowing offer.
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by adhesive_wombat on Saturday July 23, 2022 @03:41PM (#32206887)
I got a lot of adverts for Oxagon when I posted a CV online.

I probably could make bank going there to help shovel cash into a pit in the desert but...eh. I also feel like the managers of such a project will be complete nutters.

Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by reactspa on Saturday July 23, 2022 @05:52PM (#32207925)
I googled Oxagon and got this:

> A city in NEOM, OXAGON will be a new paradigm where people, industries and technology come together in harmony with nature.

Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by adhesive_wombat on Saturday July 23, 2022 @06:46PM (#32208327)
It's basically that they want to build city made of Gigafactories in the desert (what they produce is apparently not yet defined). Also it's octagonal for some reason and half of it floats.

There are lots of flashy renders and a slick video but that's about the measure of it.

Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by moomin on Saturday July 23, 2022 @04:27PM (#32207264)
It might look expensive, but you’ve got to bear in mind that positive publicity is fairly hard to come by for the investors.
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by googlryas on Saturday July 23, 2022 @03:14PM (#32206601)
At the very least, it would be a huge jobs program for Saudis.
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by superchroma on Saturday July 23, 2022 @03:26PM (#32206715)
In my impression, such endeavors (when they actually happen) seem to be a confluence of western engineers and architects and near slave labor sourced from a variety of very poor countries, complete with stories of indenture, passport witholding, etc. I hope that's not the case in Saudi Arabia but I wouldn't put money on it.
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by csomar on Saturday July 23, 2022 @04:28PM (#32207276)
The situation did improve comparing to the last few decades; but nowhere as good as western or semi-developed nations.

It’s still better than what these guys have back home; however.

Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by mistrial9 on Saturday July 23, 2022 @04:17PM (#32207196)
construction work has a gravitational pull towards the bottom; safety and flexibility for workers is only a cost center
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by Ekaros on Saturday July 23, 2022 @03:23PM (#32206696)
I actually wonder what is the ratio between Saudis and expats like ones from Africa and so on.
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by reactspa on Saturday July 23, 2022 @03:17PM (#32206626)
A rich prince and his money are soon parted.
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by housedrafta on Saturday July 23, 2022 @03:32PM (#32206782)
My $5+ gas begs to differ.
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by kube-system on Saturday July 23, 2022 @03:55PM (#32207000)
The prince made their money off $1.00 gas. $5 gas will make the cobalt and lithium nickel and cobalt miners rich.
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by the_third_wave on Saturday July 23, 2022 @08:16PM (#32208937)
> The prince made their money

The prince is clearly a man and as such there is no need for the use of the plural "their". The prince made his money conveys more information and does not violate rules of grammar and as such is readable to anyone who understands English, this in contrast to the hypercorrect use of "their" which turns an already irregular language into an even more convoluted puzzle.

Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by kube-system on Sunday July 24, 2022 @02:31AM (#32210932)
I’m using “the prince” in an metaphorical sense referring to the oil industry as a whole. I’m not talking about literally one prince.
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by hypertele-Xii on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:22AM (#32213236)
Re:Saudi Arabia’s Plan to Build a Skyscraper That Stretches ... by jjj123 on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:10PM (#32209590)
The original wording was plenty readable, I didn’t even notice the singular they until your comment.