News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by orionion on Friday July 22, 2022 @04:47PM (#32196937)
"We thought we could engineer nature… huge mistake," the general manager of the Colorado River District says
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by jacquesm on Friday July 22, 2022 @04:56PM (#32197022)
That's interesting. Here in NL that is also pretty much the attitude, and it so far seems to be working out reasonably well except that we get the occasional surprise. The latest large infrastructure project ("ruimte voor de rivier") is an unqualified success and has seen many other countries following the example.

I think one big difference is that it all happens on a much smaller scale in a much more densely populated country. What happens 'upstream' outside of the borders of NL could well have massive effect.

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by WkndTriathlete on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:39PM (#32197954)
Well, to be perfectly honest, well-engineered projects manage rivers in the US as well - e.g. the system of locks and dams all along the Mississippi courtesy of the US Army Corps of Engineers.

The two big problems with the management of the Colorado River water are big disincentives not to lose legal water rights, resulting in farmers growing water-hungry crops in the desert just to preserve those rights; and water allocations that were larger than even optimistic Colorado River flow rates during a very wet season in the 1930s. In order to preserve the river basin and reservoirs, both of those issues have to be addressed, concurrently, and there are a lot of stakeholders that are going to be very angry about whatever solution is proposed to them (or imposed on them very soon, out of necessity, to keep the lights on.)

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by jacquesm on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:48PM (#32198029)
Well, they might want to have their cake and eat it and find themselves without cake at all. That's mostly a matter of time at this point and irrigation for crops is secondary to drinking water.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by Ekaros on Saturday July 23, 2022 @05:15AM (#32201692)
On other hand moving people is much simpler than moving crop land... So why shouldn't the people be ones to move?
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by jacquesm on Saturday July 23, 2022 @07:39AM (#32202403)
Oh they will move. Just not voluntarily, but move they will. That's one of the biggest effects of all this climate stuff: people will end up displaced. Millions / year already.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by worik on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:06PM (#32198686)
I think the NL is a more civilised place. (Sorry Mid West USA, but if the cap fits....) People have been eking out a living, together, in those swampy lands for so long they have learnt much more than even they realise.

In the Mid West USA the requirement for civilised behaviour (listening to reason, getting along with your neighbours, compromise) was much less.

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by Denvercoder9 on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:03PM (#32197637)
I wouldn't really consider "Ruimte voor de rivier" to be engineering nature in the way that's discussed in the article. Most of the projects were about removing human-made constraints on the rivers and giving it more land to flow freely.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by jacquesm on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:22PM (#32197803)
That's literally what it means. "Space for the river". In the past NL tried to contain the rivers in smaller basins so there would be more land to build on, but this backfires when there is a lot of water at once (such as two years ago). It's engineering nature but this time in favor of nature, rather than in favor of the humans occupying the borders next to the rivers, which falls under 'watermanagement', which includes controlling the flow and the level of water throughout the country.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by Denvercoder9 on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:36PM (#32197922)
Ah yeah, you're right, I do agree; I misread which comment your original comment was a reply too.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by GauntletWizard on Friday July 22, 2022 @05:46PM (#32197484)
If by "Smaller Scale" you mean "17% of total land area"...
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by jacquesm on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:01PM (#32197616)
No, I mean that NL is simply much smaller than the US.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by AlchemistCamp on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:31AM (#32203183)
Wouldn't the more reasonable comparison be America to the EU or CO to NL?
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by jacquesm on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:51AM (#32203834)
There isn't a transnational unified water management policy in the EU. It would be nice but unfortunately I don't think that will happen any time soon. There are various treaties for particular rivers though.

For example: https://www.vnsc.eu/over-de-vnsc/scheldeverdragen-en-memoran...

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by AlchemistCamp on Saturday July 23, 2022 @11:19AM (#32204099)
It's similar in the US, AFIK. The Colorado River Compact was a treaty between nearby states that has nothing to do with the federal government.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by hinkley on Friday July 22, 2022 @05:44PM (#32197465)
But we can engineer nature. Beavers did it for tens of thousands of years before we showed up.

There are groups experimenting with reestablishing beavers on tributaries of the Columbia river, with positive results. We really need to be doing these on the upper reaches of the Colorado.

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by stirbot on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:53PM (#32198080)
you can build the largest reservoir in the world, but if water consumption and evaporation exceed precipitation in the watershed you're on borrowed time.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by hinkley on Saturday July 23, 2022 @12:45AM (#32200460)
Wet forest land cools the air. When humid air hits cold air you get rain. We don’t know the extent to which biological systems create their own rain, but we know it’s greater than zero. Also ground water recharging helps restore the water table, which helps keep the flow rate of the river higher for longer.

So yes, keeping water in the system longer doesn’t magically increase the rate you can draw it down… unless it does.

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by Amezarak on Friday July 22, 2022 @07:07PM (#32198191)
I wonder how beaver activity impacts evaporation rates versus human reservoir-building? Does lots of small ponds (perhaps mostly in wooded areas?) work better than a few massive reservoirs?
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by monkeynotes on Friday July 22, 2022 @07:32PM (#32198394)
Wait, what? You'd need hundreds of thousands of "small ponds" in the woods to approximate a comparison with a human mega reservoir like Lake Mead and associated reservoirs. I don't really understand the comparison.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by hinkley on Saturday July 23, 2022 @12:50AM (#32200487)
I think you're underestimating the extent of beaver altered terrain in the west. Estimates are between 60 and 400 million beaver before the fur trade started. We are currently sitting at 6-12 million and there are a number of watersheds where they have to be reintroduced because there are no populations in that area.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by Amezarak on Saturday July 23, 2022 @08:20AM (#32202648)
I was actually reading the other day about beavers and supposedly as much as 10% of North America was covered in beaver-built reservoirs and ponds. There were a lot of beavers.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by orionion on Friday July 22, 2022 @05:59PM (#32197585)
How much water does generating electric power waste? Or does the system suck everything dry?
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by Denvercoder9 on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:05PM (#32197666)
Power generation doesn't generally waste water, it just extracts the potential energy from discharges that would've happened anyway.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by hinkley on Saturday July 23, 2022 @12:52AM (#32200498)
It does however increase the carbon footprint of the river. Submerging forests to create reservoirs has created huge methane releases that nobody who thinks hydro is green power wants to talk about.

As someone living in the West, we have another reason to dislike dams: loss of salmon breeding grounds.

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by pvaldes on Saturday July 23, 2022 @04:52AM (#32201585)
> loss of salmon breeding grounds.

There are technology available to alleviate this problem. Not easy, but solvable

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by googlryas on Saturday July 23, 2022 @02:19AM (#32200879)
The angel's share might account for a fair bit, most importantly if people are expecting water downstream. eg 20 kAF yearly at Lake Mojave with expectations in Mexico for the water.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by majormajor on Friday July 22, 2022 @05:49PM (#32197514)
Seems like the problem is more "we thought we could do some stuff and then stop" while meanwhile adding a ton of population AND fucking with the atmosphere.

We're gonna have to do a lot more engineering of SOME sort soon.

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by xbar on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:16PM (#32198758)
If packing up and moving out of the Southwest is engineering, then I agree.
Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by icegreentea2 on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:42PM (#32197968)
I would love to know the quote's original context.

I think that the manager was speaking specifically about the Central Arizona Project, in the context that the negative impact of the project was already predicted.

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by drewcoo on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:12PM (#32199539)
That's what engineering means.

"We thought we'd had smarter officials in place." - me

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by Aarostotle on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:36PM (#32197921)
What a pessimistic view from the person managing the River District.

How many people would the river basin have supported without damming and irrigation? Far fewer than 40M. In other words, the engineers clearly engineered nature and made it much more hospitable to human life in the arid West.

Sounds like they might have overshot and can't meet tomorrow's demand, but even so, the status quo is certainly far superior to an un-engineered Colorado River Basin.

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by klyrs on Friday July 22, 2022 @07:19PM (#32198294)
> What a pessimistic view from the person managing the River District.

Good managers are honest about their ability to address a problem given the tools at their disposal.

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by voz_ on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:42PM (#32197967)
> but even so, the status quo is certainly far superior to an un-engineered Colorado River Basin.

Making an uninhabitable area, habitable, at the cost of a total destruction of natural resources does not seem like its "far superior".

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by Aarostotle on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:50PM (#32198046)
That depends on your standard of value.

Do you justify things in terms of human life? Conversely, is your standard that nature should be left untouched?

As for me, I would say that flooding the valleys that are now Lake Mead and Lake Powell, enabling tens of millions of people to live, is worth far more than whichever critters and plants were displaced.

Besides, the issue here is not "total destruction" it is over-allocation. We have not destroyed the Colorado River. Rather, it seems like we just have too much demand for its supply. Did I misread that?

Re:Soon, life for 40M people who depend on the Colorado Rive... by voz_ on Friday July 22, 2022 @07:34PM (#32198410)
We have absolutely different perspectives here. I do not justify anything in terms of quantity of human life. The destruction of critters and wild plants to me is as painful as the destruction of human lives. Also, we rob future generations of that nature.

> Only when the last tree has been cut down, the last fish been caught, and the last stream poisoned, will we realize we cannot eat money.

That quote is oft-posted, and cliche at this point, but it has a ring of truth to it. Life in an area that cannot sustain in long term (1000+ years?), in balance with nature, is not really life but an exploitation of the environment for short term gain. Why? Because what happens when, in your own (terribly chosen, btw) words, we run out of supply? What happens to those people? Do they die? or do they move on, like locusts, elsewhere? What's the endgame there?