The wording in this rule is probably not great. There is a difference in promoting, "Be nice to everyone, but pay special attention where you may have a gap with marginalized folks experience" and how this rule reads. I'm not sure that there's a difference in outcomes though.
So, everyone but cisgendered heterosexual white men without health/emotional problems? I guess it’s okay to attack me then.
Edit: just noticed your reply includes the term "rainbow allies" so I think we're done here.
Edit: I am truly shocked I have greyed text while the person I'm replying to has fully blackened text.
If you're showing up to a conversation that has no relation to the issue you described other than the fact that people are discussing Islam and you interject that so as to throw a topic off track, yes I can understand why they see it that way.
If you're showing up to a conversation regarding religion and child sexual exploitation and you mention that, then no I cannot understand why they see it that way.
That's a, generally, new-ish social standard so I was trying to give you, and them, some benefit of the doubt, but I think at this point I kind of get why you were banned.
In time, if people do not oppose, it may well become a standard, but right now, it is not. It may well be viewed as such in the extreme bubbles of tech workers, but in the general population? not even a tiny tiny bit.
Nobody's wondering, we already know it's an organized hate movement against the personal freedom of LGBT individuals.
>I do it because it's good for the brain. To do good work you need a brain that can go anywhere. And you especially need a brain that's in the habit of going where it's not supposed to.
It seems to me that you're underestimating the (vast) amounts of repetition and bile in the style of flamewar comment that you're practicing. That has nothing whatsoever with that essay, nor any of the other values PG wanted to see practiced on HN. This is supposed to be a site for curious conversation, not smiting and tarring enemies.
ummm....
> Everyone has a right to use Reddit free of harassment, bullying, and threats of violence.
Do you mean that they stopped at _threats of violence_ without including "violence" itself?
>Remember the human. When you communicate online, all you see is a computer screen. When talking to someone you might want to ask yourself "Would I say it to the person's face?" or "Would I get jumped if I said this to a buddy?"
The new rule is there to allow two minutes hate against anyone who is against the current thing.
You can act coy about the meaning of this, but the usage of such language is obvious. It is trying to compare a voluntary public exchange between anonymous internet users to acts of physical violence.
The usage of that word there is essentially an underhanded attempt at justifying future censorship through its ambiguous meaning. When moderators agree with the "attacked" the message becomes a bannable offense, but when moderators agree with the "attacker" the message becomes "fair criticism".
I think there is a time and place for insults and flamewars. Maybe not everywhere all the time, but what you are seeing on the web today is selective enforcement of "politeness" and "civility" rules to benefit whatever side of the "flamewar" that the moderators approve of.
HN is a good forum insofar as the users think that admins enforce reasonable rules and users agree to abide by those rules and not evade bans. On HN, moderation is rather sophisticated and neutral. When that changes I'll leave.
Not if they're using the platform to make other users miserable. That's got negative value.
It's the user's community and content, but Reddit Inc's platform.
The people who are there for free are not the customer. They are the product.