They're already doing that.
Edit: To clarify (since someone downvoted me), you are making a true statement, but I don't see how it is in conflict with anything I'm saying, or what other point it supports.
1. clawback clauses. when investments underperform, you take back bonus money. this goes well with:
2. long term vesting. you don't collect the entire bonus up front. you get it spread out over an extended period of time (say, 10 years), contingent on continued success / your bank still existing.
in fact, many banks and hedge funds already implement these ideas. of course, if you're writing a newspaper article, you can get a lot more pageviews by papering over this fact and saying the most populist thing you can think of.
Say my bonus is, I dunno, 2% of profits.
I go put 100 billion dollars on a single hand of blackjack. If I win, I make 2 billion. If I lose, I'm out 400k. Easy choice. Do it!
The Black Swan is an interesting book. You might disagree with Taleb's claims, but he's not making elementary mistakes.
But suppose you make a bonus of 20% of your gains, and no bonus for losses. Would you make this bet? Is opportunity cost a sufficient disincentive, or is that an elementary mistake, since the expected return seems to be 16?
I think this claim contains a pretty elementary mistake. No bonus is a disincentive, because base salaries can be relatively low; not receiving a bonus is a large opportunity cost. If I could get a 400k salary, but I instead opt for a 200k salary with a 400k expected bonus, then if I don't get my bonus I'm 200k behind where I could have been if I just took the salary.