I also wonder if Netflix thought that perhaps content could be licensed on multiple platforms. It's unfortunate that movie/TV content seems to have exclusive licenses in contrast to music which is available on multiple platforms.
Their advantage was licensing (Marvel, Friends, The Office etc.) and tech. In both cases eventually competitors caught up - they launched their own platforms, and licensing contracts expired. That gave Netflix a few years more to develop their own content, but now it's over.
That's probably a company worth billions. But not the hundreds of billions Netflix is valued at.
But the days of walking into department stores and purchasing things based on a service rep's recommendations are behind us. We understand stores are incentivized to sell you the item most profitable to them. The Internet has a vast amount of places to inform your decisions independent of parties acting against your interests.
Netflix is a gigantic warehouse of a lifetime of content. Some bad, some good. If you select something poorly, perhaps you're better served honing a better selection criteria.
I suppose because they should be able to do this well. They know what I have watched, what I bailed out early on, terms I search for and which results I looked at, and so on. And no shortage of tech talent to do the right thing with all of that.
Funny, Netflix is my least favorite app (on AppleTV), followed by the AppleTV TV+ app. The current version of the HBO Max app is fine. It lets me find what I want, keeps track of what I was watching so I can easily resume, surfaces interesting content.
Netlfix by contrast makes it hard for me to resume where I left off unless I explicitly add a show or movie to my list, which it still makes it hard to get to. Netflix refuses to expose its catalog to Apple, so I can't search for shows via Siri. Netflix also still forces the end of a show/movie down to a thumbnail sometimes before the credits even roll. And yes, it does this regardless of the autoplay settings, which I have turned off.
The only annoying bug HBOMax continues to have is that it constantly turns subtitles back on.
My favorite streaming app is Criterion. Netflix at the bottom, the others all in the middle.
You know what has none of these problems? Playing locally from my NAS using Infuse. When I'm watching something I care about, I download it to my NAS in advance. Sad, but true.
There was a time when the player for some streaming services was so terrible I'd avoid it, though sometimes only terrible on a specific platform (Roku, etc). I think you're right though, they are all now good enough that it's not a real factor for the basic player functions.
Though I do still tend to prefer Prime over some other services when picking something that's available on many, like a new-ish movie rental. Mostly because of the "X-ray" feature where I can see the list of characters and actors by scene. So, at least for me, there's some tech advantage left here and there.
I don't think it is about tech choices but user hostility. Any streaming service could differentiate by allowing you to turn off autoplay or not have some pushy in-your-face "feed" berry your recently watched series list.
But ye, in the end its probably all down to content, like you say.
That doesn't seem to be the case with video unfortunately. I predict a resurgence of piracy.
For years, Netflix stock has been growing, Netflix has been hiring great software engineers, and people considered them a tech company. But the tech there is not a differentiator. I don't know anyone who will choose Netflix over Disney+ or HBO because of better tech. My brother hates the HBO app, but he uses it because it has content he likes to watch.
Streaming still provides technical challenges, and people will praise providers for great UX, high quality video etc. but in this case, very clearly content is the king. Netflix has had a few years to catch up with competitors who have decades worth of content. It wasn't a lot of time, and they did what they could, but it seems this time is over now. Netflix is no longer the sole player, it's one of a few competitors.