I nailed everything from context except the particular crime being alluded to.
Of course, this is Amazon we’re talking about, so they may just go for it and plan to clean up the mess later. Walmart got away with that approach for decades.
Your language, IMO, is value-laden. Card-signing is a common "tactic" for unions like the presidential election is a "tactic" for deciding the next president.
I'm not opposed to unionizing but I take issue with the idea that getting 50% support means "it is obvious that they don't need an election."
Maybe that’s not always the case, but that’s what I’d guess is happening in this case.
(via https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Card_check)
Without reforming the secret ballot process, you’re just handing power to the companies by advocating against card-checks
However, a huge percentage of companies today are actively doing these things to their workers, and if you selected 10 companies at random where there were unionization efforts, I'd bet you money that in at least 9 of them, management was doing everything they could legally, and probably some things that are questionable or outright illegal, to try to prevent unionization.
Stop the "both sides"-ism. It's disingenuous and detrimental to genuine understanding of the situation.
-- Bezos in helium voice
I remember quitting from Krogers bagging groceries when I was a kid. I forget why, but I did give less than 2 weeks notice. Mr. Manager gravely conveyed that if I did this, I'd be barred from working for them again forever. Pretty sure my poker face then was not what it is now, but in any case I did not find that to be anywhere nearly as distressing as he seemed to think I should.
I was raised to believe that a job is more important than just about anything, so I decided to try to go in as I was out of town. I crashed my car as I fell asleep at the wheel. It shouldn’t take that to get someone to realize the relative unimportance of a job, but the US culture (as channeled through my conservative parents, at least) doesn’t value anything higher than work and productivity in the service of capital as this deified virtue.
r/Kroger and r/Walmart are real people just trying to deal with life as best they can.
Even if powerful groups aren't using r/antiwork to affect western economies (it would be incredibly neglectful not to at least attempt to leverage it), a grassroots organization of well-intending people can ALSO be its own engine of propaganda.
The FAQ for r/AntiWork is full of "calls to action":
> How can I effect change in my workplace? Resources: 30-minute overview on how to unionize.www.iww.org - Join your local IWW chapter for support in your own workplace or to support local organizing campaigns. www.amazoniansunited.org - Check out what amazon workers have been up to for inspiration. Legal handbook for labor action
Don’t
Stand up to your boss alone. You will get disciplined and possibly fired.
Allow your boss to overhear your discussions about workplace conditions. Most businesses have a plan to shut down a union campaign before it begins.
Try to organize a strike before less aggressive actions have failed. Start with approaching your boss as a group with your demands. Smaller actions can include work slowdowns, intermittent strikes, sabotage, picketing your boss’s house, public informational campaigns, etc.
Make everything a political conversation. The current needs of your fellow workers can be addressed through workplace action aside from the larger conversation of politics.
Do Get to know your coworkers on a personal level, and spend time with them outside of work. Solidarity can only exist if you understand your fellow workers’ needs and barriers, and if you are there to support them outside of the union campaign.
Contact local unions to get support once a few of your coworkers are on board with organizing.
Keep your scope small. Getting everyone from a seven-person department to call off on Black Friday will have more impact than 1,000 workers calling off around the country.
-----------------------Note that r/AntiWork is also incredibly hostile to any good-faith discussion which even potentially goes against their _prescribed_ norms and strict beliefs. Bans are handed out very frequently. There is a dedicated effort to create a self-reinforcing echo chamber. -------- Other propaganda subreddits:
r/steroids (died quite a bit after r/steroidsourcetalk was closed, likely because the economic interest died with that)
r/worldnews
r/liberalgunowners (fascinating to watch this migrate from a kum-bay-yah liberal propaganda to a fear-mongering firearm manufacturer propaganda)
r/entertainment
r/StartingStrength
r/ADHD
r/UkrainianConflict
r/publicfreakout
---------
Some that are not yet propaganda:
r/adhdmemes
r/AustralianCattleDog
r/woodworking
r/walmart
r/OSHA (surprisingly!)
r/Construction
r/IllegallySmolCats
-------
Some that are borderline:
r/Fitness
r/Bodyweightfitness
r/Target
r/Homebuilding
r/Credit
The so-called “professional managerial class” is (1) not a class, and (2) a grouping that cuts across the proletariat and petit bourgeiosie (and is largely contained within the intelligentsia component of those classes.)
(Its basically an American-Left resurrection of the Leninist critique of the behavior of the intelligentsia, divorced from the theory in which that critique was grounded which recognized that the intelligentsia were not a genuine classes because their relation to the economy was predominantly as wage labor hired by capital–and thus proletarian–but occasionally petit bourgeois; its kind of weird that its invocation seemed to fade after the 1970s but has become popular again in the last few years.)
The exercise of control over capital/means of production (what defines PMC) isnt exactly the same thing as ownership but it's closer to that than only being able to offer labor.
It's not uncommon for it to be better. PMCs (e.g. C level execs) of major corporations a often make out better than shareholders.
As usually defined (where by the 2010s it accounted for more than a third of American jobs), it's not. It's mostly proletarians, a bit of it is in the petit bourgeois, and a numerically irrelevant or even smaller numerically irrelevant slice is in the haut bourgeoisie (it's not clear to me if the upper end of the usual understanding includes the haut bourgeois who incidentally have the kind of job usually ascribed to the “class” but for whom it is not particular job reflects rather than is in any way necessary to the power they exercise over capital, but it makes little difference either way.)
The whole purpose of the designation, within Leftist discourse, is to identify and growing (even at the time first identified) segment of the wage-labor force as class enemies of the proletariat by inventing a new class label to apply to them, so as to justify why they aren't targets for solidarity efforts.
> PMCs (e.g. C level execs) of major corporations a often make out better than shareholders.
C-level execs of major corps aren't typical members of the PMC “class” by a long shot.
Virtue Hoarders: The Case against the Professional Managerial Class - University of Minnesota Press
The point here is that getting blacklisted is probably a much scarier prospect for the manager. PMC jobs typically have more stringent reference checks and employment history requirements. Meanwhile a low-wage grocery store clerk is going to have no trouble finding another shitty job. Typical minimum wage jobs just want someone who will show up and doesn't have a criminal record.
If it’s not satire, I’ve only got one argument to offer: what are the odds that the advantages and disadvantages of both sides are equally balanced? Vanishingly small. So why would you “both sides” things when one is definitely going to be better. Figure out which side that is, and then advocate for it. That’s how progress happens.
Usually in an wish to maintain order and prevent chaotic conflict. Not going to explicitly say it's a good or bad thing, but that usually seems to be the intent.
And the answer fixated on the "language" of the message, not the merit or contents of the message. Such an answer is worse than useless given the stakes of the question.
Despite the colloquial use of the word "contract," there is generally always going to be an employment contract (agreement) in place.
Similarly, people colloquially talk about having a "contract" for things like cellphones meaning a fixed term, but there is always an actual "contract" (agreement) with the terms of the service regardless of whether the plan has a fixed term or not and regardless of whether it's prepaid or not.
I don't think this is a controversial definition of the word contract (for example Wikipedia's entry for "contract" states, "A contract is a legally enforceable agreement...").
I did not say that contract and agreement are synonyms that can be replaced with each other in all circumstances, so I'm not really sure that your comment is relevant to what I wrote.
I was also trying to clarify that the employment contract might be titled "Employment Agreement" or something like that but is still a "contract."
If the worker isn't receiving consideration: Slavery, which is illegal in the civilised world (Americans still enslave convicted criminals...)
If the employer isn't receiving consideration: Some sort of payroll error? Are you mistakenly still paying people you fired? Call HR now.
My workplace doesn't have them except for employees that are part of bargaining units (ie, the ones represented by unions). Sadly, I am not one of these; my employment is contract-free.
It would not guarantee a term of employment, in the standard form (but could, if it were so modified).
“But they didn't sign anything like a contract,” one might object.
They accepted an offer to do work of some specification for pay of some specification. Even if there was nothing in writing and no other explicit terms, that's sufficient to have a contract.
You really can't see the issue with authorising a group you have little to no control over, speak on your behalf ? I can totally understand that people share some views with what unions are currently defending.
But the requirement on signing a paper that says "whatever the union currently says and will say in the future 100% represents my point of view" is a fair criticism of the union model.
A union authorization card is simply a means of demonstrating the 30% employee support required for the NLRB to order an election. That’s it. Unions will generally not hold elections until 60% of employees have signed cards, because a majority vote is required.
From the anti-union National Right to Work Foundation:
“You have a legal right to revoke any union authorization card that you have signed. It is illegal for a union to restrict your right to revoke a union authorization card that you signed.”
Is that what it says? It says that you have to agree to be legally responsible for the union's opinions on netflix shows, or of your cousin's marriage?
No, it says that you're agreeing for them to represent you with the company, not some made-up all-encompassing scaremongering paraphrasing of that.
Mind you, I'm not necessarily on Amazon's side here. Their scare-mongering is pretty slimy, to say no more. But IMTDb's objection is valid, even adjusted for your criticism.
Ooh scary ... is the employment contract signed by Amazon's employees not legally binding? How is it Amazon's business what their grown-ass employees can or cannot sign?
> By signing a card or filling out an online authorization form, you are providing the ALU your personal information.
Like Amazon monitoring my spending habits?
> By signing a card or filling out an online authorization form, you are authorizing the ALU to speak on your behalf.
And thats terrible how?
> The ALU is not part of Amazon and does not represent Amazon
Thats the whole point.