News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by tzs on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:53PM (#32104120)
> Omicron in general for most people is no worse than the flu, unpleasant but bearable.

Flu in the US kills around 12k to 50k per year, with a particularly bad year every few decades getting up to maybe 80k. Omicron killed somewhere between 150k and 250k in the US in less than a year, and that was with free vaccines that were highly effective against death easily available to pretty much everyone who was not a young child.

That doesn't sound like no worse than the flu to me.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by wonderwonder on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:26AM (#32104605)
I am not saying you are wrong and in my original comment I was careful to specify that I was not attempting to downplay its significance. With that said in my personal experience Covid hit me like the flu. I had an elevated temperature for a couple days, was achy and tired. Affected my kids and spouse in the same way. If someone wants to vaccinate their kids, that's their choice and I'll be the last person to disparage that choice. Personally I don't see the need.
[dead]
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by wonderwonder on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:58AM (#32104755)
Never taken the flu vaccine and neither have my kids. All is well so far. Its ok to just get sick sometimes. My family and I are relatively young and in good health. When I am older I will consider vaccinating against the flu as my risk factors will be higher. I am all for vaccines for things such as polio, measles, etc. I just see no need to use a vaccine currently that is formulated to protect against a specific strain of a virus that constantly changes rendering the vaccine less effective or just as effective as getting the viral infection would render me. I'm fine getting the flu or covid once a year or every couple years, it has truly never been a big deal. The bodies immune system is pretty ok. I would argue that ensuring you are physically fit provides a similar amount of protection against covid's affect as the vaccine. Plus I have had covid now so I have antibodies as well.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by leksak on Friday July 15, 2022 @01:51AM (#32105005)
One reason to vaccinate is to make sure that you don't spread it. This reads as if you feel as if the only reason to get vaccinated is to ensure that you don't have to have it but that isn't worthwhile for you as that's at worst inconveniencing. For someone else it may be much much worse. It's for them those of us with good health vaccinate, not for ourselves.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by wonderwonder on Friday July 15, 2022 @07:27AM (#32107005)
Unfortunately the current round of vaccines show limited effectiveness at both preventing an infected person from passing Omicron on and from becoming infected by it after a brief period of time. Even the benefits of a booster are negligible a few weeks after application. Your reasons to get vaccinated while noble, unfortunately don't stand up to Omicron. One would have to get vaccinated every 2 - 3 months or so to retain a high percentage of protection. Something I am not willing to require of my family. It's similar to masks, perhaps they have limited effectiveness but the tradeoff of limiting my kids development and just the sheer inconvenience of wearing them is not worth it to me. If a store requires it I have no issues complying with out complaining as it's a quick in and out. Overall though I'm done with them and have not had to wear a mask except in a surgeons office for over a year.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by leksak on Friday July 22, 2022 @09:00AM (#32191439)
Fair, but my read of GPs post wasn't limited to a Corona vaccines but also flu vaccines.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by nradov on Friday July 15, 2022 @04:50AM (#32106150)
The COVID-19 vaccines have only a limited and temporary effect on reducing transmission. While I would encourage everyone eligible to protect themselves by getting vaccinated, preventing spread isn't a valid reason.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by leksak on Friday July 22, 2022 @09:02AM (#32191453)
You seem more well-read on COVID-19 vaccines than I am. I felt it worthwhile to answer GP because my interpretation of their comment was that not vaccinating to prevent spread didn't appear to be a reason they considered at all regardless of what vaccine.
[dead]
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by wonderwonder on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:15AM (#32107291)
I try to avoid getting injected with medication that I don't believe I need. This applies 100x to my kids. This is just a personal choice, I support anyone that wants to vaccinate their family againstcovid or the flu. Covid is unfortunately here to stay and mutates rapidly reducing vaccine effectiveness. Best defense where possible is to ensure you and your family are physically fit and healthy.

" I mean, being sick is worse than not being sick. Right?" Is it? Sometimes it's ok to get sick, its just part of being alive. I'm ok with my kids being under the weather for a few days while the long term effects of the vaccine are still being observed. It's impossible to know long term affects of a novel vaccine in such a short period. Both my kids got covid, 1 showed no symptoms the other had flu like symptoms of 4 days. Wife and I also had flu symptoms.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by peteradio on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:43AM (#32107518)
Efficacy is based on health outcomes, you are wrong that protection from prior infection lasts shorter than vaccine, or I am unaware of the source of your claim. Protection is based on more than bloodborne antibodies.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by landemva on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:57AM (#32104753)
I am in decent health. My Dr. and I discussed it, and there is no compelling reason for me to get yearly flu shots.

I also avoid high fructose corn syrup. My body, my choice.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by Johnny555 on Friday July 15, 2022 @02:41AM (#32105313)
>I am in decent health. My Dr. and I discussed it, and there is no compelling reason for me to get yearly flu shots.

That might be the right personal decision, but it ignores the public health aspect -- getting the flu shot will help reduce your chance of contracting and spreading the flu to others.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday July 15, 2022 @03:11AM (#32105527)
is there a compelling reason to avoid it?
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by peteradio on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:47AM (#32107557)
This is a losers life strategy: do anything anybody tells you to unless you can mount a vigorous rhetorical explanation for "why not". Generally speaking you should be talked into things and have a good sense for when to proceed with caution. New pharmaceuticals aren't the same thing as pickin up nickels on the sidewalk.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday July 15, 2022 @09:28AM (#32107960)
> This is a losers life strategy: do anything anybody tells you to unless you can mount a vigorous rhetorical explanation for "why not"

More like a loser's life strategy is avoiding everything anybody tells you to avoid until someone can mount a vigorous explanation for why you should do it.

If you have no reason to not get it, and "maybe getting slightly less sick" as a reason to get it, ordinary people simply do the cost-benefit equation there and come to the conclusion that most people do: that getting it is better than not getting it

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by peteradio on Friday July 15, 2022 @09:57AM (#32108258)
> "maybe getting slightly less sick" as a reason to get it

You are barking up the wrong tree if that is my upside. I get sick all the time, I got kids in daycare and school, its just a fact of life. I don't ever know what I got or if maybe I'm not getting enough sleep or a bit hungover. I don't need a pharmaceutical for anything that ails me, yet.

Ordinary people under 50 doing the cost benefit analysis might rightly come to the conclusion that there is no medical or social benefit to getting the vaccine. Can you learn to respect that or is this vaccine really a must have for anybody?

[dead]
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by peteradio on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:42PM (#32110038)
I assert most people <50 made their decision sans data analysis, if that's true then I'm above the mean in that regard.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday July 15, 2022 @01:21PM (#32110550)
given that even you, someone who has decided not to receive a vaccination, are thusfar unable to articulate any significant downsides, it is unlikely that the average person would believe there to be any
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by peteradio on Friday July 15, 2022 @01:59PM (#32111006)
Again, I make decisions based on some apparent upside. There's also no significant downside to twisting the door knob three times and knocking on the frame three times before entering any room.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday July 15, 2022 @05:41PM (#32113117)
perhaps the reason most people behave differently is that they perform a more proper cost benefit equation, which doesn't minimize the upside, and doesn't have bias towards the "cost" end of the spectrum before any costs or benefits are actually added in
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by wonderwonder on Friday July 15, 2022 @11:01AM (#32108880)
Is the answer to this question known? There has not been enough time to observe if there are long-term consequences to children taking the vaccine. I am not against vaccination but I think simply wanting to wait and see what happens is a very valid response.
[dead]
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by wonderwonder on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:02PM (#32109514)
Some are vocal in claiming they know on both sides. Personally I don't know so I will err on what in my mind is the side of caution and hold off on getting my kids vaccinated. Others may choose a different approach and see the cautious move as getting them vaccinated. There is just no way to know and each family has to make its own decisions. Everyone should respect each other's choices and know they are coming from a place of concern for their children.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday July 15, 2022 @01:18PM (#32110507)
some are vocal in claiming others do not know a thing, when it is in fact the vocal person who does not know, so thank you for not claiming others don't know and admitting you don't.

what cost:benefit analysis leads you to believe that your approach is cautious, rather than incautious, as those with a different cost:benefit analysis might consider it?

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by wonderwonder on Friday July 15, 2022 @02:00PM (#32111010)
Friend at this point in time you appear to be intentionally obtuse on what I said. All the answers to your questions are in my prior post. All the best.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by jussij on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:08PM (#32104195)
Another big difference is how much pressure COVID can exert on the hospital system. The COVID hospitalization rates are magnitudes larger than the worst ever flu season.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by mrhands556 on Friday July 15, 2022 @01:11AM (#32104820)
From covid or with Covid? Covid is treated differently than the flu in healthcare. They naturally have been testing all admissions for Covid. If someone comes in for a broken arm and test positive, then they’re counted against the Covid numbers.

Flu numbers typically are a small sample size and extrapolated based on respiratory-like illness admissions in hospitals nationwide.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by sofixa on Friday July 15, 2022 @02:15AM (#32105147)
> If someone comes in for a broken arm and test positive, then they’re counted against the Covid numbers.

You know you have to substantiate such a wild claim, right? Nobody is counting patients with broken arms that happen to have Covid as Covid patients.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by briandon on Friday July 15, 2022 @03:09AM (#32105506)
Dr. Birx back in 2020: "If Someone Dies With COVID-19 We Are Counting That As A COVID-19 Death" https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2020/04/08/dr_birx_u...

In March 2022 (this year), sleuthing by members of the public into inflated pediatric death counts resulted in the CDC deleting 72k alleged covid deaths, blaming a coding error for the overcount: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/mar/24/cdc-coding-err...

In one county in Colorado, a coroner pointed out that 2 of 5 covid deaths were actually due to gunshot wounds: "Grand County Coroner Raises Concern On Deaths Among COVID Cases" (Dec 2020): https://www.cbsnews.com/colorado/news/grand-county-covid-dea...

The way that a "covid case" or alleged "covid death" has been counted may have improved over the past 2 years, but 70+ thousand purported covid deaths were just admitted to have been illusory a few months ago and there most definitely have been significant financial incentives for hospitals to claim a particular patient had covid and further incentives for specific treatments (remdesivir, placing them on a vent, etc.).

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by nradov on Friday July 15, 2022 @04:54AM (#32106176)
I don't know why you're asking for substantiation, that is common knowledge to anyone paying attention. Almost half of hospital COVID-19 patients were admitted for something else and only incidentally tested positive on admission.

https://www.businessinsider.com/covid-patients-nyc-hospitals...

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by origin_path on Friday July 15, 2022 @05:27AM (#32106321)
This is a common problem with COVID-19 threads on HN now. Happened to me several times in the past weeks. It's interesting but also very concerning just how large the knowledge gap has become between people who still support the public health restrictions and everyone else. Almost any fact you present, regardless of how basic or well known you think it is, will run into someone who thinks it's wild and crazy and has never encountered it before. That's true even if it's been admitted in public by the people who literally run the public health response!

The cause seems to be aggressive filter bubbling. We see it above too - there are highly upvoted people saying nothing more than "it can't be true, I don't believe it, it must be a right wing conspiracy". Any information that undermines government narratives just gets mentally erased, causing a distressed reaction of "that claim is CRAZY" to almost any attempt to discuss known data or facts.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by jussij on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:24AM (#32107347)
Firstly the date on the link you provided is from Jan 11, 2022, 9:52 AM so it's a little dated when considering a fast moving pandemic.

Further googling reveals this similar headline: "Over 40% of NYC’s COVID-infected hospital patients admitted for other reasons"

This then begs the question, if in fact 60% of people are going to hospital because of COVID that indicates a very big problem.

Hospitals by their design are always meant to be full and their size will be determined based on an expected amount of demand.

If the hospital contains these unexpected COVID cases that then means many people who need to go to hospital will not be going to hospital only because the beds are taken up by these COVID patients.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by wonderwonder on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:53AM (#32107604)
Respectfully, I think you are misinterpreting that headline. It's saying that of all the patients that tested positive for covid at the hospital, 40% of them were actually there for another reason. So a guy could be there for a broken arm and test positive for covid while there. He just needs to be treated for the broken arm, not covid.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by jussij on Saturday July 16, 2022 @12:53AM (#32115320)
If you have just one patient in hospital with COVID and no other ailment that will represent a degradation of the 'normal' operation of the hospital.

If you have 10% of the hospital population in hospital with COVID (and just for COVID) you will have degraded the performance of the hospital by 10%.

This is because hospitals are designed to operate at maximum capacity (i.e all the beds are in use and there is a waiting list to get a bed). Every bed in use by a COVID patient will just add someone to the waiting list.

So my question would be what percentage of patients are in hospital because of COVID and only because of COVID?

That number is a very good measure of the pressure that hospital system will be under and my guess is it will be much greater than 10%.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by nradov on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:29AM (#32126587)
Hospitals are not designed to operate at maximum capacity.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by jussij on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @04:05AM (#32162831)
On any given day, our hospitals — by design — operate at 90 to 100% capacity. That's why we have sought waivers to allow critical access hospitals to operate above their licensed capacity Peel wrote.

https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2020/apr/01/jeff-jacks...

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by laverya on Friday July 15, 2022 @11:31AM (#32109168)
> Firstly the date on the link you provided is from Jan 11, 2022, 9:52 AM so it's a little dated when considering a fast moving pandemic.

January 2022 would include ~3/4ths of the pandemic's time and deaths so far.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by cf141q5325 on Friday July 15, 2022 @03:17AM (#32105570)
This widely varies by countries, as well as often states. It entails what criteria you use for your statistic and how you collect the data. Because unfortunately data collection is one of those things that is assumed to be trivial, but actually quite difficult and costly. Especially in the beginning, you just took the rate of positively tested patients. Because you could do so at a single point in your hospital, the testing center. Figuring out information concerning individual patients means having to collect this information for every individual as well.

Let me also point out that this wasnt some grand failure. We were in a situation in which what ever information we could get was really helpful. But you have to be aware, that there is not magic box somewhere that spits out perfect information. All data collection has its limitations, its why we still know very little about long covid. Because getting that data is incredibly difficult, especially at scale.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by jussij on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:04AM (#32107223)
Someone with a broken arm will most certainly take up a seat in the hospital waiting room, but would be unlikely to be taking up a bed in hospital.

Someone with COVID could well be in hospital for weeks if not months and if things get serious they could end up taking a bed in the ICU.

It would be highly unlikely to see someone in ICU with just a broken arm.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by mrhands556 on Monday July 18, 2022 @08:45PM (#32146046)
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by azinman2 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:26PM (#32104288)
Don’t forget long covid is estimated at roughly 20%, which is quite significant.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by cf141q5325 on Friday July 15, 2022 @05:18AM (#32106284)
Which vaccines have very little influence on.

https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-01453-0 relating to the study https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01840-0

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by azinman2 on Friday July 15, 2022 @10:52PM (#32114853)
That’s not what the thread is about:

> Omicron in general for most people is no worse than the flu, unpleasant but bearable.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by cf141q5325 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:27PM (#32133479)
I know, i was agreeing with you. The long covid numbers are what makes COVID worse. I was pointing out that there is no way around those.
Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by TeeMassive on Friday July 15, 2022 @02:20AM (#32105191)
Before covid, doctors were trying desperately to sensibilize people about the danger of the flu to no avail. It was common for flu death to not be marked as such on the death certificate.

But covid is different because it is under the spotlight and faces more scrutinity. And the disctinction as covid being the main cause, a comobidity or a unrelated pathology was never clearly made since the beginning of the pandemic.

Re:U.S. public health agencies aren't ‘following the science... by rustybelt on Friday July 15, 2022 @05:23PM (#32112962)
Only 13000 people in the US die of AIDS each year. Is the flu worse than AIDS? How about rabies? Less than five deaths per year in the US. What would you rather have. I'll even concede that Omicron has a higher infection fatality rate than the typical flu strain, but both are well under 1% and those death totals have much more to do with transmissibility than severity.