News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:17AM (#32092293)
Oh really? How did the 13th amendment codify slavery? For some reason I thought that the civil war ended slavery but you must know better. Please explain.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by coddingtonbear on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:24AM (#32092342)
If you give the 13th amendment a read, it contains this clause:

> except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted

It does otherwise end slavery, but provides the above loophole for continuing similar practices.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:41AM (#32092427)
Do you object to the “duly convicted” part? What do you think should happen to convicted criminals instead?
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by boomboomsubban on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:48AM (#32092472)
Your question was "How did the 13th amendment codify slavery?" They answered it, the first mention of slavery in the constitution legalized it for convicts in the 13th Amendment.

Why are you now changing your argument to "they deserve slavery?" Didn't you just say the Civil War ended slavery?

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:55AM (#32092520)
No I’m not changing my question, but I think this gets to the misunderstanding that there must be in rejecting the idea that the 13th amendment ended slavery.

We didn’t fight the civil war to end the concept of incarceration for duly convicted lawbreakers. It’s pretty easy to understand and accept that right?

And the people who fought the civil war believed that they were doing it to end slavery.

So perhaps your definition of slavery is inconsistent with theirs, and also out of step with the letter of the law.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by shadowofneptune on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:10AM (#32092609)
https://theconversation.com/prison-records-from-1800s-georgi... Across the US but most flagrantly in the deep south, you see huge spikes in the black prison population starting after the civil war. Many were contracted out to mines, farms, etc. Conditions were poor, many died in that labor. There's little else it can be called once you move out of the abstract.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by boomboomsubban on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:06AM (#32092582)
Incarceration isn't slavery, we could still have prison without treating people like property.

And again, the 13th Amendment is the first time slavery was mentioned and it explicitly allowed some form of it. Maybe the Civil War vets were fine with that, but the amendment still codified slavery.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by beebmam on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:17AM (#32092645)
I think there's a big difference between Chattel slavery, and the kind of slavery that the 13th amendment allows for. There's also "wage slavery", which even Abe Lincoln and the republican party agreed was comparable to chattel slavery unless the wage slavery eventually led to self-employment.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by TedDoesntTalk on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:39AM (#32092758)
> the people who fought the civil war believed that they were doing it to end slavery

For many Northerners, it had nothing to do with slavery and everything to do with states rights vs. federalism. And keeping the Union together. Revisionist history makes it 100% about slavery.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:03AM (#32092894)
While it’s true to say that some northerners had other interests in fighting the civil war, there’s no clearer evidence of the cause and purpose of the civil war than the reasons cited by secessionist states for leaving the union. Yes it was about “states rights”, but specifically (as they themselves said) it was about the right of states to continue slavery.

You can say that people in the north weren’t angels, they certainly weren’t, and that there were other issues that motivated people to enter the war and fight for their side, there certainly were.

But the central issue of the civil war was slavery. If it was any other issue, the seceding states would have said it, and surely a compromise would have been reached (as in fact even today states have “rights” if not just the “right” to hold slaves).

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by TedDoesntTalk on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:46AM (#32093195)
> seceding states would have said it

They did. I get the feeling we’ve read different history books. So many reasons. What about the industrial north and the agricultural south? Played no part in the war, I’ve suspect you’d say. It was all slavery.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by abvdasker on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:40AM (#32093554)
> What about the industrial north and the agricultural south?

Guess what kind of labor the economy of the "agricultural south" was dependent on at the time. The Civil War was primarily about slavery, especially the expansion of slavery westward. To argue the opposite is ahistorical nonsense so false it amounts to an outright lie.

Even the Confederacy was open about the fact that slavery was the reason for succession. Just read The Cornerstone Speech given by the vice president of the Confederacy weeks before the Civil War began:

> [The Confederacy's] foundations are laid, its cornerstone rests upon the great truth, that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery—subordination to the superior race—is his natural condition. This, our new government, is the first, in the history of the world, based upon this great physical, philosophical, and moral truth.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:51AM (#32097636)
> I get the feeling we’ve read different history books.

I get the feeling we've read different history.

Forget books or opinions provided by other people many years after the fact, forget my opinion, just look at what the seceding states themselves said to justify their secession.

For example, here's South Carolina: https://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/csa_scarsec.asp

The VERY FIRST sentence identifies the reason to secede being that the northern states are refusing to send back their fugitive slaves!

And if it's not clear enough for you, they repeat it in more detail just a little further down in the document:

---

"In the present case, that fact is established with certainty. We assert that fourteen of the States have deliberately refused, for years past, to fulfill their constitutional obligations, and we refer to their own Statutes for the proof.

The Constitution of the United States, in its fourth Article, provides as follows: "No person held to service or labor in one State, under the laws thereof, escaping into another, shall, in consequence of any law or regulation therein, be discharged from such service or labor, but shall be delivered up, on claim of the party to whom such service or labor may be due."

This stipulation was so material to the compact, that without it that compact would not have been made. The greater number of the contracting parties held slaves, and they had previously evinced their estimate of the value of such a stipulation by making it a condition in the Ordinance for the government of the territory ceded by Virginia, which now composes the States north of the Ohio River."

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by abvdasker on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:44AM (#32093588)
> it had nothing to do with slavery and everything to do with states rights

"states rights" to do what?

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by travisjungroth on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:54AM (#32096116)
> No I’m not changing my question

Come one, you totally changed your question!

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by markdown on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:56AM (#32092523)
The same thing that happens in any other civilised nation; they serve time in jail.

They shouldn't become slaves. US prison slaves produce $11B worth of products and services and are paid 11c to 52c per hour.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/jun/15/us-prison-wo...

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by mushbino on Monday July 18, 2022 @04:07PM (#32142976)
Some states such as Arkansas, Georgia, and Texas pay them nothing at all and additionally, Alabama, Florida, Mississippi, Oklahoma, and South Carolina allowed unpaid labor for at least some jobs.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by abvdasker on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:45AM (#32092458)
I think they object to the continuing to allow slavery part.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:49AM (#32092481)
But “slavery” for incarcerated criminals? What exactly do you want to do with them?

Like, after you’ve convinced everyone that you’re morally superior to everyone else, do murderers get to walk free?

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by abvdasker on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:04AM (#32092568)
There's no reason for scare quotes given the specific carveout for slavery which exists in the Constitution. If you have an issue with that verbiage, take it up with the 38th United States Congress and Abraham Lincoln.

> do murderers get to walk free?

You're arguing against an extreme position that nobody actually holds. Most reasonable people would probably point to criminal justice as implemented in many European countries as exemplifying a more humane model which produces better long term results.

The carveout for the enslavement of incarcerated people also created a perverse incentive which played out predictably in the wake of Reconstruction's failure. If you're interested in the long and painful history of this fact here's a useful resource:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4kI2h3iotA

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:18AM (#32092649)
Europeans and European countries have done all kinds of ridiculous things. Just because someone in Europe does something like you describe (if they even do, I doubt it), it doesn’t mean we should do it.

People in the South after the civil war grasped for any excuse to disenfranchise black people. Big surprise. That’s not an argument to treat prisoners any differently than we do today.

Are people incarcerated unfairly or are they convicted under unjust or unconstitutional laws? That’s a reason to agitate for change.

Are duly convicted criminals forced to do things they don’t want to do? Oh well, sounds like a good idea to me, I will invest in continuing that practice as long as the laws are fair!

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by bryanrasmussen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:02AM (#32092559)
The 13th amendment does not end incarceration it ends slavery and involuntary servitude. Thus it allows you to enslave criminals and force them to work for you without in any way taking away from the obvious ability to incarcerate them.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by betwixthewires on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:35AM (#32092729)
Not who you're responding to, but I will take a crack at your question. I think that incarceration and forced labor are barbaric and ineffective, and an enlightened society should not engage in those sorts of behaviors.

I believe in corporal punishment and fines. Petty crimes get fines, say some number larger than the average payout per crime divided by the chances of getting caught, so that on average criminals lose money. And for violent crimes, lashing, flogging, something quick, painful, that doesn't destroy families and take years from someone, and that doesn't maim or disable (so things like cutting off hands are out). And for repeat violent offenders and extreme cases like murder and torture and things, death, the reasoning being this is not punishment, it is corrective action, and if the corrective action doesn't work, the offender must be removed from society as they are a danger.

I can see exile making some sense in some cases but I haven't explored that really.

All this is predicated on the society being one where victimless crimes don't exist. Nothing should be illegal that involves no unwilling participants. Drugs, sodomy and things like that should not be crimes, social pressure and social sanction are enough to deter things a society doesn't want but that doesn't violate rights of others, and punishments for them should not be codified into law.

I know my opinion on this is not a commonly held view, and would be considered extreme by many, but I do think it is more humane and productive than incarceration.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by imtringued on Thursday July 14, 2022 @07:22AM (#32094479)
The slave loophole creates a motivation to wrongfully convict people or more aggressively convict people for petty crimes.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by mushbino on Monday July 18, 2022 @04:08PM (#32142997)
That's exactly why the Jim Crow laws came around making almost anything illegal (if you were black). They rounded people up and put them right back on chain gangs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Crow_laws
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by travisjungroth on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:23AM (#32092336)
Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:40AM (#32092420)
So the problem is that incarcerated criminals lose their freedom? That’s what you object to?
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by batch12 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:51AM (#32092495)
Captivity, forced labor, and unsafe conditions as a result of subjective sentencing and a fallible criminal justice system.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:57AM (#32092527)
Huh, so what are you arguing for exactly? No justice system? What happens to murderers?
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by betwixthewires on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:24AM (#32092677)
I don't think anyone is arguing for anything man, they're just pointing out that forcing people to work, conviction or not, is, in fact, slavery. If you think that slavery in those cases is justified, that's a different discussion. But it is slavery, plain and simple.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:50AM (#32092810)
You are right, except to the extent that “people SAY the 13th amendment ended slavery but it really codified it man” recasts what happened in the civil war and what purpose people had in fighting and dying to get it passed.

Some people today want the glory of abolitionist revolution without having to pay with their own blood.

Yeah, maybe you can make an argument that the justice system can work differently in one way or another with diff tradeoffs, but if you set up the argument so that you’re in a morally superior position to the people who fought and died in the civil war to end slavery, you should expect and you definitely deserve very strong opposition.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by markdown on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:57AM (#32092529)
Nah, criminals all over the world lose their freedom. They aren't turned into slaves https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/jun/15/us-prison-wo...
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:45AM (#32092792)
In some places, criminals are killed much more quickly as punishment. Should we do that instead, because some countries do it?

Or maybe we should figure out what we want to do by argument and consensus, instead of blindly following the old colonialists and ex-fascists in Europe?

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by markdown on Thursday July 14, 2022 @06:03AM (#32094018)
> In some places, criminals are killed much more quickly as punishment. Should we do that instead, because some countries do it?

You do. USA is a world leader in killing criminals. Only China, Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt kill more per year.

> Or maybe we should figure out what we want to do by argument and consensus, instead of blindly following the old colonialists and ex-fascists in Europe?

You don't do that. You blindly follow some 20yr old colonials who scribbled out a constitution 200 years ago.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:58AM (#32097731)
> Only China, Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt kill more per year.

So you're saying we could do better I guess.

> You don't do that. You blindly follow some 20yr old colonials > who scribbled out a constitution 200 years ago.

I guess, but maybe better to follow 20 year old colonials who wrote a constitution 200 years ago than to blindly follow inbred royal families with even poorer claims to power? I mean, as long as we're just throwing insults at this point, you have to see that Europe is at least as ridiculous (and at least when it comes to politics, arguably much worse).

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by markdown on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:16PM (#32104238)
And which royal families have claim to power? Do you really think kings and queens still rule in Europe, like in Disney fairytales?
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:14AM (#32104545)
Let me guess, that smug superiority, serious and knowing citations from "The Guardian", you're from the UK right? And you're lecturing us in the states about our naive skepticism of countries with royal families, while also paying your taxes to protect the royal pedophile Prince Andrew right? Please tell me more about how royalty no longer rules in Europe.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by travisjungroth on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:02AM (#32096220)
No, I answered your question before you edited it. You asked something to the effect of "How does the 13th amendment codify slavery?". This is Section 1 of the 13th amendment, that has an explicit exemption under which slavery is not unconstitutional.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by evanb on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:26AM (#32092351)
https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/amendment-13/

> Section 1 > Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.

So XIII explicitly allows for criminals to be worked without reward. Of course equating that with chattel slavery (which was prohibited by XIII)...

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:42AM (#32092433)
Right, but what’s the problem exactly?
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by zardo on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:09AM (#32092605)
Freed slaves would wind up convicted of "vagrancy". That is, being black and unable to prove employment to the judge, who would be getting kickbacks for each conviction from the local lumber company that hired out prison labor.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:40AM (#32092759)
Sounds like an unjust law and/or an unfair enforcement of the law, rather than an argument that incarcerated people shouldn’t be forced to work.

Freed slaves also were unfairly scrutinized for eligibility to vote. Does that mean we should never work to guarantee the integrity of our voting systems?

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by mushbino on Monday July 18, 2022 @04:11PM (#32143026)
There are unfortunately many companies who lobby the government to keep prison population high because they depend on cheap/free prison labor. Over 4,100 companies profit off of prison labor in the US. That's a lot of incentive.

https://corpaccountabilitylab.org/calblog/2020/8/5/private-c...

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by yieldcrv on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:57AM (#32092528)
That there is no rehabilitation, only punitive. This undermines the domestic security of the US (as the convicts are still in a marginalized status after the sentence is over and also not rehabilitated, promoting destructive behaviors)

And its purpose is specially for a slave population.

Some developed nations have reevaluated this, to have convicts be rehabilitated and more collaborative members of society. And the inhumane conditions in the US prisons - for slaves - being valid arguments to prevent extradition.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by pabs3 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:07AM (#32092587)
Rehabilitative justice is better than retributive justice, but I'm partial to transformative justice; fix the system that lead to the crimes.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Restorative_justice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rehabilitative_justice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transformative_justice

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by matwood on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:27AM (#32092695)
It creates an incentive to grow and maintain the slave class. Instead we should be thinking rehabilitation and how to have less people in prison.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:42AM (#32092772)
Why should we be thinking that?

Some people might argue that we should pursue even more extreme punishments, to dissuade people from committing crimes.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by yieldcrv on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:40AM (#32093558)
The outcome of punitive retribution is that it undermines the domestic security of the US when convicts sentences are over. They are less integrated into society than before the arrest, and are not rehabilitated from the crime they did, are not rehabilitated from the punishments and society in prison, and are marginalized from the rest of society pushing people towards more petty and violent crimes against the population just for basic food and shelter.

So your idea exacerbates the thing you want to dissuade.

The concept is called recidivism if you are interested in corroborating or learning additional perspectives of this. And why it occurs such as the misaligned incentives that promote recidivism that we as a society can fix.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @12:14PM (#32097949)
Huh, seems like that theory isn't getting much support these days, with sympathetic DAs on the chopping block.

Maybe it's actually wrong?

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by dragonwriter on Thursday July 14, 2022 @12:15PM (#32097977)
Or maybe the motivation for punitive retribution is punitive, not corrective, so that the truth of the empirical theory has no bearing on the support for policy?

Disagreements on values often masquerade as disagreements on facts, especially because people often use fact claims oriented to their audience’s perceived values to sell actions based on different values to them.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:23PM (#32098943)
Or maybe punitive retribution is also corrective.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by yieldcrv on Thursday July 14, 2022 @12:35PM (#32098264)
sympathetic DAs are the wrong approach, hampering enforcement is the wrong approach. those are bandaids that are incompatible with society that doesn't have other structural changes. since those structural changes don't exist, all you have is amplified domestic security problems as more violence occurs without penalty, incompatible with the concept of civilization.

you're looking at this through the lens of more enforcement+penalties versus less enforcement+penalties, a false dilemma that's not what the rest of us are talking about.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:24PM (#32098964)
You negated a lot of ideas but left off the part that summarizes what you're talking about.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by yieldcrv on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:11PM (#32099541)
Is there any thread you found productive here?
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:07PM (#32100225)
Yes, each thread produced several words.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by imtringued on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:43AM (#32096002)
That is quite interesting. Maybe we should start enforcing the law against school shooters.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @12:23PM (#32098086)
Sure, seems like it's worth trying.
Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by evanb on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:59AM (#32092541)
I'm not interested in fighting on the internet. You asked

> How did the 13th amendment codify slavery?

It codified it the above sense.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:26AM (#32092691)
If you’re not interested in fighting on the Internet, you wouldn’t have posted what you posted.

You can say “it codified [slavery] in the above sense”, but obviously this isn’t the sense that people meant when they went to war to end slavery. And neither you nor I had to make the sacrifice that those people made to end what they considered to be slavery in the US.

Maybe it’s worth considering what the purpose of the 13th amendment was? It’d be a pretty huge mistake to conclude that the purpose of passing the 13th amendment was to enshrine slavery in law, which so many people fought and died to abolish, right?

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by evanb on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:31AM (#32093071)
I was acting with the principle of charity, assuming that you did not actually understand the sense the above poster meant. Hoping that you would apply the same principle to my comment, I pointed out in my original response that that sense drew an equivalence between unpaid imprisoned work and chattel slavery that is...

That's the last I'll respond to you about this topic.

Re:US Doesn't Care About Financial Crimes by kthielen on Thursday July 14, 2022 @12:18PM (#32098008)
> That's the last I'll respond to you about this topic.

I love it when this one gets pulled out. UH OH, NO MORE RESPONSES!

Well I'm also happy to leave it here, that the 13th amendment absolutely outlawed slavery and that people arguing for policy changes in law enforcement are making a weak case that their poorly justified agenda is somehow on par (or even more morally virtuous) with the 19th century abolitionists.

NOW I'M TAKING MY BALL AND GOING HOME.