News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by alldayeveryday on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:15AM (#32069443)
I was at the gym yesterday (or maybe the day before) and saw on one of the TVs that Fox News was running this same story. Throw "Netherlands work from home" into your favorite search engine and you'll see that this story has been syndicated far and wide.

I cant help but to find the timing of this coincidental given that other story coming out of the Netherlands (civil unrest and protest from the farmers).

Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by nicholasbraker on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @02:56AM (#32079728)
There is no "civil unrest". farmers are indeed protesting and they are supported by some rightwing parties and media. Media makes it much bigger than it actually is in terms of unrest. Yes, farmers have it rough, and it's largely due to the unwillingness of the Dutch government to tackle the problem of having too much livestock on a small piece of land combined with banks who kept on pushing farmers to borrow more money to buy bigger stables. (Guess what: the farmers are not spraying manure onto the front doors of the banks.. Well played guys!) This has been going on since the 1980's and every iteration of the Dutch government since then has been unwilling to make some tough decisions.

The role of the banks (actually the Rabobank who supplies credit to 90% of all farmers) have been very dubious. There are farmers who want to change into a less environmental unfriendly way of business but banks won't finance them due to the fact it's not "optimizing" the business in terms of output per square feet of stable (read: livestock). As we say here, the banks have also butter on their head, but they are being kept out of the main discussion. This seems to change with some media reporting on their role, but it's still highly dubious.

To summarize, it's a Gordian knot were farmers, government and banks have each other strangled in a weird menage-a-trois. Rightwing media and parties jump into this for their own gains.

Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by alldayeveryday on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:10AM (#32126445)
So you embark on a game of semantics wherein protesting is not a form of civil unrest, and then the coup de gras is to evoke "rightwing" as if that is somehow evidence of the falsehood of the claim.
Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by BlargMcLarg on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:23AM (#32069533)
More pressing are RE prices and fuel prices. Companies refuse to accommodate by giving higher pay and are too stubborn to adopt fulltime remote. In theory, this is one way to push them out of their comfort zone without hitting their bottomline that could tackle at least 4 separate problems.
Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by humanistbot on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:50AM (#32071687)
From the article:

> Under the new law, employers must consider all such requests and give adequate reasons for refusing them.

That isn't how I'd describe a "right."

Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by DigiDigiorno on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:55PM (#32074225)
In the US, there are limits to all of our constitutional rights. Laws that limit these rights must pass constitutional muster. Different rights have different tests the laws must pass. Generally speaking, in a challenge of constitutionality, the state has to show its interest meets a certain threshold, an "adequate reason" you could say. (FYI This is a limited and simplified element of constitutionality.)

I don't know much about the legal system of the Netherlands, so take this with a grain of salt, but I don't think it is fair to come to the conclusion that this doesn't create a right because of the limit on it. However, if the law allows employers to define "adequate reasons" themselves, then I agree the whole thing is illusory, but I do not know that to be the case here.

Fun fact: Roe v. Wade, when it was the precedent, explicitly mentioned the government's interests in protecting women's health and protecting prenatal life as a reason for limitation (the "adequate reason"). The law in the case was a carte blanc ban on abortion, which almost by definition, didn't balance any legitimate interests and was thus found unconstitutional.

Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by ratg13 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @01:45PM (#32073401)
Not everyone can work from home.

Doctors, service workers, construction workers, pilots.. an endless list of jobs literally can not be done from home.

The right is more about that it is an option where available, because obviously it wouldn't make sense any other way.

Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by SapporoChris on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:30PM (#32073933)
Addressed in the article: The law forces employers to consider employee requests to work from home as long as their professions allow it, according to media reports.
Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by 6510 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:18PM (#32072137)
We have a lot of those, they cant just make something up. If the reason for refusing is dubious it stacks with similar requirements. Dutch law also instructs to be a well behaved employee and a well behaved employer without any written specification.
Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by seydor on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @08:59AM (#32069212)
It's still baffling why businesses wouldn't want employees to work from home
Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by ekianjo on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:13AM (#32069400)
Gotta make sure the workers do their work! And also, very important to have useless chit-chat around the coffee machine the whole time, and useless meetings with managers who have too much time on their hands.
Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by donatj on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:19AM (#32069487)
I honestly find the lack of cross-department chitchat an actual problem.

When we were in the office I would often strike up a conversation with people from another part of the company, people I had no reason to talk to. I would get an honest idea of their struggles and needs not filtered through corporate meeting grandstanding. It built connections and empathy.

I have barely spoken to anyone outside my department since work from home began, and I think that’s a problem. Sure large cross department slack channels exist, but the public performative nature of it just isn’t the same.

Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by adrian_b on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:32AM (#32071411)
I agree that such unplanned conversations with random colleagues can be very useful.

Nevertheless, such conversations normally take just a very small fraction of the time spent in the office.

While doing real creative work, I have never seen anyone who doesn't do it better when insulated from their colleagues.

I have always worked in places where I wasted at least a couple of hours every day with commuting, and those are certainly not worth 10 or 20 minutes of useful daily conversations with the colleagues.

In my opinion, the best would be a hybrid style of work, with 4 days at home and 1 in the office, or at most with 3 days at home and 2 in the office, to have an opportunity for unplanned discussions.

Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by walterbell on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:18PM (#32072131)
Planning unplanned discussions is an unsolved problem.
Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by erichocean on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @05:36PM (#32075992)
I dunno, Pixar's headquarters are designed so there's only one central bathroom in a large indoor plaza.

Apparently Steve Jobs required it, the plan being to enable "unplanned discussions" to occur.

Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by walterbell on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:42PM (#32088491)
Kudos to Jobs' vision. Cafeterias sometimes play a similar role. And places where smokers congregate.
Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by redleader55 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:26AM (#32069571)
I find the random coffee machine/water cooler chat very useful. I can run an idea quickly by someone, I can see that others are burned out or tired and take more time to just chat about stuff. Being in the office also allows me to turn to my colleagues and ask for help if I need it.

At home there is no way to do that. My wife was also working from home so I'm not alone, but it's not the same when you are a couple, working in different companies.

If meetings with managers are bothering you, it means either you have bad managers(they need to justify their time), you have bad culture in your company(big boss needs to see "slavers" working in cubicles) or you don't communicate well asynchronously with the team (managers are forced to get updates live).

Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by alexdh on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:58AM (#32070948)
I really like that you mentioned working asynchronously. Truly an understated part of remote work (and even in-person work too).

The most successful remote work jobs I've worked have had a really healthy balance of async work.

Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by f0e4c2f7 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:11AM (#32071121)
Wow that's an incredibly strong worker protection. How is the tech scene in the Netherlands these days? Good startup culture?
Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by rowanG077 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:25PM (#32073888)
It's pretty oke I'd say. You can get many tax benefits and loads of people are willing to work for promising startups.
Re:Netherlands poised to make work-from-home a legal right, ... by sylware on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @08:52AM (#32069133)
They have ASML and now probably work-from-home as a legal right.

Yeah, I am starting to be jealous of them.