News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by lb1lf on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:45PM (#32046297)
This sounds good; a citizen can now refer to The Law(tm) and keep filming any police encounter with the general population from a distance of 8ft.

I enjoy yelling about abuse of power as much as the next guy, but from the looks of it, this law empowers the citizenry.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by woodruffw on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:16PM (#32046623)
In the US, you have a constitutional right to record the police. This law attempts to limit the bounds of that right, making it strictly more limited than before.

In other words: it was already the law. This is an attempt to limit civic participation and oversight, and to disempower citizens.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by lb1lf on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:49PM (#32046991)
But surely the police are well within their rights to have you do it from a safe distance?

8ft seems a reasonable compromise; close enough to capture what is going on, far enough away to not interfere in an ongoing struggle, for instance.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by woodruffw on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:54PM (#32047036)
It’s not a reasonable compromise in many scenarios, ones that the police must be recorded by the public in: crowded streets and public transport, unconstitutional crackdowns on protestors, being cornered by cops in semiprivate areas, and so forth.

The police have no such right not to be recorded. They are afforded legal recourses against interference, but simply recording them does not constitute interference in any reasonable sense.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by kristofferc on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:55PM (#32047059)
It is already illegal to interfere.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by mytailorisrich on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:37PM (#32046856)
From the article itself it is not clear whether the law applies to absolutely all filming or only filming by third parties.

Edit: yes, I meant bystanders.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by woodruffw on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:46PM (#32046951)
Assuming by “third party” you mean bystanders: yes, the law only applies to them.

That’s one of many reasons why the law is absurd: the police already have (more than) adequate legal cover to deal with interference in their activities. They don’t need a law that specifically carves recording out for punishment, unless the real goal is to stifle civic participation.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by throwbigdata on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:14PM (#32047288)
I don’t see language that excludes personal interactions with LE ; help me understand?
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by woodruffw on Sunday July 10, 2022 @03:07PM (#32047842)
Item B of the amended law[1]:

> notwithstanding subsection A of this section, a person who is the subject of police contact may record the encounter if the person is not interfering with lawful police actions, including searching, handcuffing or administering a field sobriety test. The occupants of a vehicle that is the subject of a police stop may record the encounter if the occupants are not interfering with lawful police actions.

In other words this law targets bystanders, i.e. concerned fellow citizens. It probably does this to avoid the trivial standing that recording as a bystander offers, meaning that the limitation there is more of "we think we can get away with this" and less "we think this is the right stopping point."

[1]: https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.htm

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by throwbigdata on Monday July 11, 2022 @06:50PM (#32063160)
Thanks
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by simonbarker87 on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:31PM (#32046791)
I assume you’ve missunderstood the ramifications of this. Traffic stops are all within 8 feet, this means that no traffic stop can be filmed in Arizona, many people get assaulted or killed by police in traffic stops. If the police are within 8 feet of you then they are able to assault you and claim you attacked them and any recording you have won’t legally count even if it shows the policeman is lying. This law helps on group of people, police. Specifically, dirty police. A good police officer would say “I see you’re filming and I’m happy for you to keep filming even if we have to come within 8 feet”
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by frognumber on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:36PM (#32046845)
The law doesn't say that. If you're involved with the police, you can film from whatever distance. Unrelated parties need to be at least 8 feet away.

This sounds super-reasonable to me. 8 feet is close enough to capture what's going on, but far enough to not interfere or escalate in a situation.

In a tense situation, it's not always easy to tell who might or might not be a danger to the police officer. This seems to set a reasonable bound which avoids accidents or incidents. Arrests are tense situations.

Imagine you're a police officer arresting a dangerous criminal, and their friend comes within 3 feet. They're filming you. You don't know if they're an accomplice or not. What do you do?

Now, it's easy. 8 feet away is okay.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by woodruffw on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:43PM (#32046913)
Your analogy doesn’t adhere to the bounds proscribed by this new law: if the officer has a legitimate reason to believe the other person is an accomplice in the crime, then they’re involved in the “law enforcement operation” and the recording law doesn’t apply to them.

This is bad law: it takes a set of restrictions that already exist, and adds additional language to them in order to chill civic participation. The police already have a cornucopia of powers available to them; they don’t need a completely arbitrary carve-out for just the act of recording their actions.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by frognumber on Sunday July 10, 2022 @04:02PM (#32048407)
I think, in the situation I gave, there isn't legitimate reason to believe either way. All you know is you're holding down a suspect who has a knife, and their brother is walking up awfully close up to you. You don't know if they're:

1. About to smack you in the head to save their brother

2. Trying to make a nice video recording

Adrenaline is flowing, and you have 1.5 seconds to decide. Which way do you guess?

The law seems reasonable in concept. Lots of flaws in the language, as is being pointed out in this discussion (although sometimes incorrectly). What bugs me most is: "C. this section does not establish a right or authorize any person to make a video recording of law enforcement activity."

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by bearcobra on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:45PM (#32046936)
If you are sitting in a car next to someone being arrested it's very easy to be within 8 feet. If a person is within 3 ft without filming is everything fine? Who knows, but the act of filming doesn't seem like a reasonable differentiator between the two.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by lovehashbrowns on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:44PM (#32046928)
It's not easy because now you can be arrested for filming the police encounter and who's gonna say you were more than 8ft away from the interaction? You, of course.

But then it's your word against the police officer's word, and (1) police are willing to lie, and (2) the words of a police officer almost always carry more weight in a court proceeding.

This doesn't actually change anything because if you're intending to interfere with a police interaction, you're going to interfere with a police interaction. That's already illegal. Nothing changes.

If you're only intending to record the interaction, you now have this stupid law to worry about. More of our rights being restricted, with people applauding it under the guise of police safety.

Also, keep in mind that police in the US already have vast protections like qualified immunity, safety and weapons training, they're armed, and they have a legal right to violence. I don't understand what sorts of protections they're desperately in need of.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by frognumber on Sunday July 10, 2022 @03:55PM (#32048341)
One would hope if you're being arrested for being closer than 8 feet, when you're not, you'll have video evidence to the contrary (kinda by definition). It might not be precise enough to tell 7'11" from 8'1", but otherwise, you have actual forensic evidence to tell who was wrong and who was right.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by lovehashbrowns on Sunday July 10, 2022 @04:10PM (#32048485)
That sounds great but now you're in court and having to prove that you were further than 8 feet. So you were harassed by police, arrested, charged with this crime, and sent to court. This is just another tool for police to harass citizens that is completely unnecessary for the safety of the public.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by frognumber on Sunday July 10, 2022 @04:18PM (#32048575)
Most likely, things don't go that far. Prosecutors don't want to take losing cases. There are no high-stakes consequences, as there ought to be, but it also doesn't look good for anyone involved.

Your bigger picture, though, is smack-on. By the time you hit the legal system -- criminal or civil -- you've already lost. A typical case will bankrupt most people in the US. Thing is, one can always come up with an excuse to sue / prosecute someone. There's a deeper problem there which this law doesn't change.

I'd rather address root causes.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by lovehashbrowns on Sunday July 10, 2022 @04:28PM (#32048660)
Even if it doesn't go to court, just being threatened with this crime might be enough to get someone to stop recording a police interaction. So again the law is to the detriment of the public. There is no upside to this law aside from it being a useful tool for police intimidation.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by el_benhameen on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:44PM (#32046927)
In a tense situation, it’s also not always easy to judge distance. Do you think a cop who doesn’t want to be filmed is going to whip out a tape measure or just start smacking around the videographer and say they were 7’ 11” away?
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by anthony_romeo on Sunday July 10, 2022 @04:02PM (#32048410)
So hypothetically, if one is being illegally beaten by a person who happens to be an on-duty police officer, all the victim has to do to achieve justice is turn on their camera to record the incident to gather evidence. Bystanders can feel good that they’re ignoring the incident and carrying on with their days, as they know that it’s the victim’s responsibility to record their own beating.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by frognumber on Sunday July 10, 2022 @04:16PM (#32048550)
... or record from 10 feet away.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by anthony_romeo on Sunday July 10, 2022 @04:27PM (#32048649)
10 feet away from what, exactly? A ‘law enforcement activity’? Is that area defined in a meaningful way?

What if a bystander records 10 feet away, but a second person stands in between and records 5 feet away? Has the area of law enforcement activity expanded to include the first bystander because of the second bystander is breaking a law?

I guess bystanders who didn’t bring their tape measure can just run the risk of recording and let the courts shake it out, right?

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by micromacrofoot on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:45PM (#32046937)
now what happens when a cop walks towards someone to get them to stop filming?

same thing that happens when you push a cop away for yelling at you 2 inches from your face: now you’re on the ground

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by ndsipa_pomu on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:45PM (#32046950)
I believe that there's a specific exception to this law if the police are addressing the person filming i.e. you can film your own interaction with police within 8 feet but not someone else's. I can imagine that it would cause issues with traffic stops if the passenger starts to film the interaction.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by notch656a on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:50PM (#32046997)
Yes but what if I'm a passenger who wants to film a stop of the driver and am ordered to stay in the car along with the driver? My 1A rights are then restricted?
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by jccooper on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:07PM (#32047209)
Passengers in involved cars are also allowed to film explicitly by the law.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by Sevii on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:15PM (#32047295)
The law specifically calls out the case of passengers in the car being allowed to film a traffic stop.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by ndsipa_pomu on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:57PM (#32047081)
I guess you could argue that if the officer orders you to stay in the vehicle, then they are interacting directly with you, but I don't know how that would play out in court.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by staticassertion on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:30PM (#32046784)
That's not going to work.

a) The police don't give a shit about the law, nor are they required to know it

b) They'll just walk towards you, say you're breaking the law for filming, break your phone, beat the shit out of you and/or shoot you

c) It was always legal to do so. Now it isn't.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by Clubber on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:39PM (#32046879)
Yes this is my read. When dealing with police and regulating them in some of these really bad departments (Lovelace, CO, I'm looking at you, but LA, NY, any major city), you have to assume they will think of anything to get around the regulations, do whatever they want, and cover their ass. Right now it's so blatant, they know they're being recorded and still violate civil rights, and still only get a paid vacation as punishment most of the time, if that. We need to start holding the mayors accountable for police misdeeds as much as the police themselves.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by ajaimk on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:05PM (#32046509)
The loophole for the cops is that they can walk towards you and claim you are within 8 feet.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by logicalmonster on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:22PM (#32046687)
I get this possibility.

The potential problem for the police that I’ve seen is that when there’s an arrest from some resisting person and a sympathetic crowd gathers around to record and voice some words of protest, it’s a chaotic situation. You have people going crazy hooting and hollering and it’s a bad situation to be in even if the cops are 100% doing the right thing by the book. I don’t know what’s the right distance, but I get that cops want to maintain some distance from crowds so they’re not swarmed.

In the end, I don’t know what can be done other than mandating personal recording equipment that can’t physically be switched off.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by johnhenry on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:31PM (#32046793)
> even if the cops are 100% doing the right thing by the book

Public scrutiny is only as issue for those who don't want to be publicly scrutinized. If they are doing the right thing, they should have not problem. They don't want to be scrutinized because they are 100% NOT doing the right thing by the book.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by technothrasher on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:48PM (#32046978)
> If they are doing the right thing, they should have not problem.

This sounds awfully close to the bullshit line I've gotten from cops on several different occasions that I've been stopped and questioned, "If you haven't done anything wrong, you wouldn't be nervous."

I don't know if this law is a good one or not, but people (cop or otherwise) will always be uncomfortable when there's a serious imbalance of power.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by barnabee on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:16PM (#32047310)
It seems obvious to me that there should always be a serious imbalance of power away from the police.

That is, they should only feel “comfortable” in any situation and willing to carry out any action if they feel like they have the support of the local citizens (see also the Peelian principles [1]).

In that vein this seems like another regressive step.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peelian_principles

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by johnhenry on Friday July 15, 2022 @01:03AM (#32104777)
Ironic, right? Police officers are public servants and this concerns public scrutiny by taxpayers who pay their salaries. I hope you can see the difference between this and what you hear from the cops making you nervous.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by logicalmonster on Sunday July 10, 2022 @07:59PM (#32050589)
> They don't want to be scrutinized because they are 100% NOT doing the right thing by the book.

Do you think a crowd of angry people are experts in proper police procedure? Is the mob ever objective about what they see? Is a crowd going to understand that when somebody is hopped up on meth/cocaine that maybe they’re going to be hella strong and hard to take down and it’s going to take some actual force to stop them?

You’ll have angry people screaming bloody murder regardless of whether or not the police are doing the wrong thing in some cases.

I agree, scrutiny on the police is good, but a mob of people screaming from a few feet away during an arrest isn’t the thing to bring about a safe outcome for anybody and I can easily see that happening and being something that needlessly escalates a situation.

If you see somebody getting arrested and are concerned about their safety, I’d totally say filming the encounter from a safe distance is justified and a good idea, I just don’t think a crowd of people going a few feet away is good.

Downvote me if you want, I don’t care. I’m just recommending what I think would likely be best for a safe police encounter

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by johnhenry on Sunday July 10, 2022 @08:17PM (#32050696)
A specific distance isn't going to prevent a crowd of people from forming; but it does it give police officers the ability to punish/threaten/intimidate witnesses for something that was previously legal.

I hope people don't downvote you for expressing an incorrect opinion, but I do hope that you understand that the purpose of this law is 100% about preventing scrutiny. The angry mob scenario that you describe is fiction used by police officers to prevent you from looking into their job performance.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by logicalmonster on Monday July 11, 2022 @02:29PM (#32059856)
The responses to my posts in this thread such as "Fuck what they want" only reinforce to me that the proverbial mob isn't capable of being objective about many police actions.

Having a crowd of people trying to scream a few feet away from the cops trying to apprehend a resisting person is a recipe for disaster.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by 8n4vidtmkvmk on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:39PM (#32046881)
this is dangerously close to saying you don't need privacy if you have nothing to hide.

the public doesn't know the full situation, they don't have police training, the video might be cut or not capture everything the police saw/heard.

police should be held accountable for sure, but we need to let them do their jobs without villainizing everything they do.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by Clubber on Sunday July 10, 2022 @05:01PM (#32048993)
>this is dangerously close to saying you don't need privacy if you have nothing to hide.

Yes, philosophically it's different because when the police say it (nothing to hide), they are trying to violate our civil rights through trickery or whatnot. In this context, it's the citizens making sure the government actors (police) are doing what they are legally required / allowed to do. The government run by the people shouldn't be hiding anything from the people, unless it's absolutely necessary. How can a country run democratically if the voters are in the dark and can't find out what's going on?

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by hdjrudni on Monday July 11, 2022 @11:34PM (#32065273)
They should know what's going on, but they need the full story, not just what they perceive to be happening because they don't know the suspect is on drugs, or just robbed a store, or is a violent felon. I don't know how we do that. Body cams on the police sounds good, but even that doesn't capture the full picture I think. Maybe also rotate cops partners occasionally so they don't form bad habits.

Maybe a bad example, but I don't expect non-programmers to be able to review my code. I don't know how we can expect non-police to properly review police behavior unless it's outrageously wrong.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by vkou on Sunday July 10, 2022 @04:15PM (#32048534)
> this is dangerously close to saying you don't need privacy if you have nothing to hide.

We empower police to harass, detain, and use deadly force against the public.

This power has to be counterbalanced by accountability. If the way they use that power cannot stand up against public scrutiny, then they shouldn't have it.

> but we need to let them do their jobs without villainizing everything they do.

We wouldn't do that if they didn't so consistently fail at doing their jobs, or at being held accountable for those failures.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by logicalmonster on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:02PM (#32047143)
> Public scrutiny is only as issue for those who don't want to be publicly scrutinized.

Scrutiny on police isn't the issue. I'd mandate for cops and cop cars to be equipped with a dozen+ cameras if I could and it should be legal to always record cops in public.

The issue is a loud crowd forming around an already tough situation and making it worse for everybody. Think about what happens if you have 30 people shouting loudly around a guy resisting arrest and jostling for position trying to get a video for their social media and it's a recipe for disaster. Cops can't communicate with each other and the guy being arrested can't hear commands. It makes an already bad situation more stressful and easier to go wrong.

I get wanting to monitor cops (I'm 100% supporting that) but you can't have a crowd forming 5 feet from a tussle shouting and expect things to be improved.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by staticassertion on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:32PM (#32046803)
> I get that cops want to maintain some distance from crowds so they’re not swarmed.

Fuck what they want.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday July 10, 2022 @03:11PM (#32047893)
ah, so police need access to my pornhub searches, alexa recordings, and phone location becayse if I have nothing to hide I have nothing to fear.

but when the shoe is on the other foot suddenly it's a problem?

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by rgrieselhuber on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:27PM (#32046753)
They also put up crime scene tape.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by bufferoverflow on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:30PM (#32046786)
It doesn't sound good. It's a law restricting something very important - ability to record people who were granted special powers, including killing. I don't understand the reasoning. Anything in public and anything visible from public areas should be allowed to be recorded.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by chrsig on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:50PM (#32046366)
no, the default is that it's legal to film within 8 ft of police.

All laws are inherently restrictive.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by mattmaroon on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:58PM (#32046440)
They really aren’t unless you have an incomplete model of how the legal system works. This is a good example of this.

There is no default. Court cases have upheld that it is legal for cops to establish a safety perimeter, even when that distance is undefined. Thus a cop could argue that the necessary safe distance is an arbitrary number like 25 feet or 50 feet.

This law defines it as 8, potentially giving you greater freedom.

The legal system as a whole is inherently restrictive, but individual laws within it may be otherwise.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by mlyle on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:10PM (#32046560)
> This law defines it as 8, potentially giving you greater freedom.

No, this law establishes a new crime and penalty for being closer than 8 feet, without precluding enforcement under other laws:

" C. THIS SECTION DOES NOT ESTABLISH A RIGHT OR AUTHORIZE ANY PERSON TO MAKE A VIDEO RECORDING OF LAW ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITY. "

https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/bills/HB2319S.pdf

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by matheusmoreira on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:18PM (#32046641)
It's funny. Authorities can surveil the entire globe with complete impunity but the second citizens start surveilling them all sorts of laws are passed making it illegal.

Sousveillance should be a right of every single citizen. This right should be established and authorized.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by justinpowers on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:27PM (#32046751)
“Sousveillance”, as a term, was new to me.

In case it’s new to anyone else:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sousveillance

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18493797

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by mattmaroon on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:48PM (#32046981)
Right but much of law is interpretation, by design or by chance, and there’s a very strong likelihood that courts will now interpret 8’ to be the safe distance as a result of this. It’s very probable that before this law, cops could have moved you, say, 25’ away when you were trying to record and gotten away with it in court, whereas now they probably wouldn’t.

But for an even less theoretical example, state laws have explicitly legalized marijuana, for instance. If you’ve been in a state before and after (I have, as have most Americans) you saw your freedoms increase (and restrictions decrease) as a result.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by mlyle on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:06PM (#32047185)
If cops argued before that they needed to keep the public 20' away from incident A-- "totally not" to prevent filming, but for public safety-- that argument doesn't vanish or really weaken now.

I understand what you're saying, but this doesn't establish some kind of right to be within 8' of an officer and probably doesn't change the evaluation of most situations substantially.

Officers have a whole lot of reasons to want to keep the public farther back- Tueller drills, if I were scuffling with some dude I'd not want a potentially-hostile observer 10' away, standard training about perimeters in static situations, etc. Those don't evaporate, and they generally can be argued for even if the real motivation is preventing filming.

> But for an even less theoretical example, state laws have explicitly legalized marijuana, for instance.

Yah, I'm not interested in arguing the philosophical question of whether all laws are in some sense prescriptive-- nor of whether removing past restrictions counts as adding a law. I just don't think the AZ public is better off or more able to film with this new law.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by WastingMyTime89 on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:37PM (#32046861)
> All laws are inherently restrictive.

While the maxim "Everything which is not forbidden is allowed" generally holds true for individuals (but not organisations), it is not true that all laws are restrictive. See for example the first amendement of the US constitution which is restrictive towards the legislature and sanctifies rights for individuals or from a more international point of view the first article of the Declaration of Human Rights which states that all men are born free and equal in dignity and rights.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by Supermancho on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:59PM (#32046451)
> All laws are inherently restrictive.

Repeals, franchises, permits, etc may include restrictions, but you might be able to imagine circumstances when laws are not uniformly restrictive.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by chrisseaton on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:05PM (#32046512)
> All laws are inherently restrictive.

This isn't the case at all - law can be a precedent that something is permitted, for example.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by bnj on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:20PM (#32046657)
Can a new law explicitly permitting behavior that wasn’t previously prohibited really be said to be alleviating restrictions?

Laws are inherently restrictive in the sense that things which aren’t prohibited by law, are permissible. So a law which codifies that something is permissible is useful for clarity, but it doesn’t really release citizens of restrictions.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by mattmaroon on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:54PM (#32047045)
Yes because things can be restricted due to legal precedent determined by a judge, rather than due to a law, but a law can redefine it to be less restrictive. Imagine as a hypothetical (I know next to nothing about AZ law) that AZ had a law that said cops could enforce a minimum distance from which you could record for safety reasons. Hypothetically, a court case could rule that a cop that wouldn’t let people record from under 25’ was following said law. There’s no law that specifies 25’ in this hypothetical, but now there’s a court precedent that effectively sets it at that.

So the law defining it as 8’ just gave everyone 17’ feet of freedom.

Also state laws can legalize something that was federally illegal, sort of. See marijuana legalization. (This is really technical and rests on the commerce clause and is debatable, but what’s not debatable is people can now open up a shop and sell weed without ending up in a federal prison whereas before they could not, so freedom has increased.)

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by thfuran on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:13PM (#32047269)
>So the law defining it as 8’ just gave everyone 17’ feet of freedom.

A law, but not this law, which explicitly does not grant any right.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by chrisseaton on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:14PM (#32047284)
But the interpretation of the law likely will - as soon as a judge rules you were 9 feet away and so ok, that establishes a precedent, based on this law.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by thfuran on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:17PM (#32047318)
Why would a judge ignore the clause that explicitly states that it doesn't grant any right or authorize any person to record?

At nine feet away, this law has no bearing and the earlier precedent should still apply.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by Raed667 on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:49PM (#32046354)
until the police starts charging at you and now you're under 8ft.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by elmerfud on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:52PM (#32046385)
If the police begin to charge at you because you are recording you now become party to the police interaction and you can record under the 8-ft distance. I know on emotional issues like police interactions logic is hard to follow but logic is still a thing.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by macksd on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:16PM (#32046625)
Logic didn't seem to have been a thing in the Daniel Shaver shooting, which happened in this state. I thought the bodycam footage was a pretty clear illustration of a terrified and confused unarmed victim doing his best to follow unclear instructions being shot by a cop who, in the end, clearly had some facts wrong. And the cop was then acquitted, got re-hired and given a pension because he had a disabling case of PTSD from the incident. Imagine what a state like that could get away with if video wasn't even public, or how easily a cop could get away with intimidating people who are even 8+ feet away.

I wouldn't be quick to trust this law if I lived in Arizona and tended to be harassed by police.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by chadcatlett on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:22PM (#32046681)
All they need to do is claim you are interfering with their law enforcement activity and they can say you can't record your own interaction.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by BoorishBears on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:20PM (#32046668)
I would consider it barely logical to think the cop approaching you specifically so they can claim you're in the way of their operations and gain an excuse to stop your filming (https://youtu.be/VWHOz5sLk-c https://youtu.be/L7lHeRBgs9U https://youtu.be/HEL8CdV9HUQ) would suddenly stop because:

"Whelp now they're a part of this police interaction [as I intended] so I should respect their rights [which me approaching them was an attempt to interfere with]"

The current MO is:

- Cop approaches someone recording

- Proceed to apply psuedo-legal pressure because you're now "too close" to a cop (who approached you to begin).

And you actually think that a law that replaces a murky step two with "You can't film within 8ft of us" is an upgrade?

You actually think the cop informing you you can't film them will take the law they approached you to enforce as a reason to leave you alone?

-

There's something beautiful yet dangerously naive about the kind of people who have this much good faith in how police leverage the law.

Sorry but even the "good cops" are not about to use the law to expand your rights.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by etchalon on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:00PM (#32046452)
The idea that the police will follow the letter of the law during an interaction seems naive given what we've seen of police behavior.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by staticassertion on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:46PM (#32046952)
Except when you were recording you weren't party to the police interaction. So you were breaking the law. Can you follow that logic?
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by calabin on Sunday July 10, 2022 @03:04PM (#32047809)
This does exactly the opposite of that. Reading the text of the bill, every part of it, especially Section (B), is couched in the principle of "not interfering."

For Example: "A PERSON WHO IS THE SUBJECT OF POLICE CONTACT MAY RECORD THE ENCOUNTER IF THE PERSON IS NOT INTERFERING WITH LAWFUL POLICE ACTIONS"

So if a police officer determines that your recording of a traffic stop is "interfering" with their investigation, that it's causing you to cooperate too slowly, that your holding up the phone is limiting their ability to see into the vehicle, etc., they're well within the law to instruct and even force you to stop recording.

While a court may find that their determination of "interference" was insufficient, and that they were wrong to take your phone or arrest you for refusing to stop recording, it will be a determination made after you were arrested or fined or your phone was confiscated.

It produces a chilling effect on the ability of citizens to record the police, and gives police more law to throw at citizens to try and intimidate them into not recording their activity.

https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.pdf

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by plandis on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:35PM (#32046837)
This was already a right, this law just gives police an ability to harass people filming them if they so desire.