News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by londons_explore on Sunday July 10, 2022 @10:00AM (#32044856)
Smart demand management hasn't been rolled out because there are many different people involved who would all like to pocket the profits.

Eg. a tesla plugged in at 6pm could shift it's charging time to earn quite a profit on the realtime-priced wholesale electricity markets.

* Tesla et al (the company) would like to make that money - in the lifetime of a car, it could be tens of thousands of dollars. They propose to do it with 'virtual power plants' which can make/use power and trade on the power market.

* The homeowner would like to make that money too. Through the use of manually setting timers to use power at cheaper times and having a peak/off-peak plan.

* The electricity distributor would like to make that money - by mandating that devices like cars and water heaters be remotely controllable by them, so that they can buy less of the most expensive power generation.

* Electricity generators would like to make that money too - by not doing any demand management, prices vary more widely, and they get big profits when they can spin up gas turbines to cover that peak demand.

Technically, none of the above ideas are hard to implement - but each party blocks policies and rules that move in the direction of someone else making the money.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by r3trohack3r on Sunday July 10, 2022 @11:06AM (#32045433)
SRP in Phoenix Arizona has a form of this, I’m currently switching to it.

They have peak/off-peak rates with an additional monthly fee based off your maximum kilowatt usage in any 30minute on-peak interval. They also integrate with an ecobee thermostat (and give a $100 credit for buying them - just got two for $50 a piece) and will automatically adjust your thermostat up by at most 4 degrees during on-peak conservation events where demand is spiking in the valley. They can even pre-cool your house by 2 degrees prior to the event on off-peak rates to try and comfortably get you through the conservation event.

I’ve configured my pool pump to turn off during peak hours and will avoid doing dishes and laundry during peak. I imported last years hourly usage into spreadsheet and ran the numbers. If my math is right, I should save on average between $100 and $200 per month on electric (I’ve had winter bills as low as $150 and summer bills as high as $750!).

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by bumby on Sunday July 10, 2022 @05:25PM (#32049207)
What is your $/kwh rate? I've also been a resident of the desert southwest, but that bill seems insane, about 5x what my bills were. At the time, I think we were paying around $0.13/kwh peak and $0.09/kwh off-peak. You may just have a much nicer/bigger spread, though
Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by r3trohack3r on Sunday July 10, 2022 @05:40PM (#32049359)
I’m currently on the Basic Plan: https://www.srpnet.com/prices/home/basic.aspx

Between $0.0829 and $0.1299 depending on peak/off-peak and seasonal. 3k sq ft house built in 2004.

Switching to their Time Of Use Demand plan, which it doesn’t seem like they have a public page for. It’s substantially cheaper per kwh than TOU - as low as $0.03 - but they have a fee for your peak demand in the month as high as $17 per excess kw.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by toiletfuneral on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:28PM (#32046124)
I can't imagine wasting that much water by having a pool in Phoenix, insane
Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by r3trohack3r on Sunday July 10, 2022 @04:36PM (#32048732)
I don’t (currently) think water is wasted in any meaningful way by my swimming pool. When it evaporates it turns to water vapor. Then it comes back down as liquid water when it rains. There is an argument that we put extra work into this water to transport it and make it potable - but PHX’s water is positive sum. Water demand in the valley is accounted for during construction and sourcing it is part of the project cost. I’m also prepared to pay the cost of continued sourcing of water over time as the valley grows - including projects like desalination.
Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by AtlasBarfed on Sunday July 10, 2022 @07:11PM (#32050172)
When the Colorado river starts to reach the ocean again, then maybe this attitude can be tolerated.

Right now, your comments are shockingly ignorant.

Voodoo accounting is all over the west. You can tell by the water levels, which is the "final accounting".

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by r3trohack3r on Sunday July 10, 2022 @08:49PM (#32050914)
Arizona takes a very practical approach to water management which is part of why I chose to live here. We take a true positive sum approach that I believe in, humans can do this. We find water where it exists and transport it into a desert. We’ve built a human settlement in a space where very little life has chosen to live - distancing ourselves from the biosphere seems like a solid play.

Our approach to water is part of why we are able to give up so much from our pull on Lake Mead during this drought. Nevada is giving up 21k acre-feet, Mexico 80k af, and AZ is giving up a whopping 512k af. Nothing as far as I know for cutbacks from CA's draw.

If it doesn’t work out, I dont understand a worst case scenario less than “move closer to water”

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by nerdponx on Monday July 11, 2022 @08:29AM (#32055256)
I'm not an AZ resident but this seems the exact opposite of sustainable. It sounds like mining: yes, technically the metal or whatever is still somewhere out there in the world, but no longer usable or accessible to humans after it has been used the first time.
Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by r3trohack3r on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @03:56PM (#32074865)
Using water is sustainable - life has been doing it since the beginning - it's where you pull that water from that really matters. Water has a natural cycle where the earth recycles it. Sustainability is making sure your draw from earth's reservoirs are in balance with the rate the earth is replenishing them.

If you pump water out of your groundwater table faster than the water cycle replenishes it - that isn't sustainable. If you draw from lakes faster than the water shed and streams replenish them - that isn't sustainable.

The Salt River Project in Arizona carefully monitors the water shed, reservoir levels, and ground water levels to sustainably provide water to the valley. Arizona seeks out new sources of water that will provide sustainable water moving forward. When we build - we take water demand into consideration and source water upfront. Yes we have pools and water parks, but we plan for those and work to make them sustainable. We don't just let almond farmers tap our ground water and drain our water tables like some neighboring states. It helps that the only solution for us is a sustainable solution; the only way to survive here in the desert is to have a sustainable water supply.

To GP's point, many of these measurements are showing that humans are unsustainably pulling from these reservoirs. The levels are dropping, lakes are running dry, and rivers aren't making it to the ocean. But, when I look at the numbers, I can't say it's Arizona causing that. Arizona seems to be doing it's diligence in sustainably using water. I can't say the same for our neighboring states.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by AtlasBarfed on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @01:28PM (#32085917)
"Arizona seeks out new sources of water that will provide sustainable water moving forward."

We need breathing room!

Arizona is a desert, and there are ... googles ... 7 million people living there that should not be. There are 300 golf courses! There should be ZERO open air heavily-manicured grass golf courses in a landlocked desert.

When people joke that if you want to settle mars, let's settle Antarctica, it's closer and easier to do... well, the REAL settling-mars project is Arizona.

I've also heard that Las Vegas, another middle of the desert atrocity, is also 100% water efficient.

I've also been told about things like "clean coal", "fracking doesn't turn farmers water on fire", "pesticides are safe", "global warming isn't real", and a host of other big fat lies that you'll only discover are wrong in the future when it is too late.

So either you are being mendacious, or you are happily eating the big lie served up to you on a platter.

Humanity is so screwed.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by r3trohack3r on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:43PM (#32100633)
> that you'll only discover are wrong in the future when it is too late

Too late for what? If what you’re saying is true - we won’t be able to reliably move water to the desert over the next 1000 years. Then Arizona won’t have enough water and those people will have to move closer to a water source. But is Arizona reducing the amount of available water on Earth? I feel like you’re referring to a long-term ecological crisis that this is causing, but I’m failing to see it.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by Scoundreller on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:50PM (#32047650)
Depends how well they cover it (temporarily with a cover or permanently with a gable/roof or completely indoor pool). Transpiration from lawn grass will evaporate a similar amount of water as an outdoor uncovered pool. At least they don't have to worry about heating it in AZ. Ideally their air conditioner would dump heat into the pool for any heating (no idea if pool heaters are a thing in AZ).
Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by r3trohack3r on Sunday July 10, 2022 @04:41PM (#32048776)
No cover due to its odd shape. During summer months I use evaporative cooling to keep the pool cool enough to swim. To do this, we intentionally run the water feature to increase the evaporation rate - evaporating water takes the higher energy water molecules and ejects them from the pool reducing the temp.

We also use a pool heater about 3 months out of the year. Never considered the A/C condenser as a heater. Initial thought is that the time of year you need to heat the pool is the time of year you aren’t running your A/C.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by jakewins on Sunday July 10, 2022 @03:33PM (#32048107)
Hasn't been rolled out in the US, although that's shifting as well. My employer (Tibber) have hundreds of thousands of paying customers in EU, and the bulk of the pitch is that we smart-schedule your EV and home heating to hit low prices, and sell ancillary services (eg. stop your charger for ~15s to help grid do frequency control).

While people may argue over who should get what slice of the pie, I think the situation in Europe has already answered that: you, the owner of the EV and charger or heat pump, get the pie.

I think Tibbers business model is good here: We charge a flat (~$5) monthly fee to smart-schedule your assets and buy electricity for you, and then you get ~100% of the profit from your demand-responsive asset. We also make some money if you spend less $$ on energy, since we settle daily with producers, but monthly with you, so lower cost of financing if you spend less.

The major blocker to more demand response, at least in EU, is the pace at which countries (looking at you Germany) roll out meters capable of hourly remote reading.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by goodpoint on Sunday July 10, 2022 @10:45AM (#32045239)
People are usually aware of Big Oil but often forget that power generation and distribution companies also have they own interests (and are able to buy politicians).

Unsurprisingly, they dislike distributed/democratized power generation and storage.

> shift it's charging time

*its

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by robocat on Sunday July 10, 2022 @06:37PM (#32049874)
A market that works properly depends on electricity market design[1], and the design of regulations for the network, the generators, and the consumers. Each country has solved this in their own way, some networks have successful regulations and some don’t. I live in New Zealand and the market[2] works okay (although it helps that NZ is reasonably functional compared to many other countries).

The network/grid infrastructure is mostly a natural monopoly: infrastructure which requires communal long-term goals via regulations and the infrastructure cannot be run as a normal pure-profit business.

Generators and consumers need an electricity market designed to meet capacity and other[3] goals (link mentions: Ancillary Services, Frequency Keeping, Over-frequency reserve, Instantaneous reserve, Black Start, Voltage support, Automatic Under Frequency Load Shedding (AUFLS), Dispatch-Capable Load Station Setup, Frequency Keeper Selection, Infeasibilities, Load Forecasting, Offer and Bid Setup, Scheduling and Dispatch, etcetera).

I like your point. It is hard to design regulations to avoid the monopoly capture your examples show, and how to have a functional regulator that isn’t captured, and a market that encourages participants to develop functioning systems. Tesla needs some incentive to build and maintain a system to optimise charging schedules and load shedding.

[1] https://www.nera.com/practice-areas/energy/energy-market-des...

[2] https://www.mbie.govt.nz/building-and-energy/energy-and-natu...

[3] https://www.transpower.co.nz/system-operator/electricity-mar...

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by schiffern on Sunday July 10, 2022 @10:16AM (#32044983)
Insightful post.

I've long suspected that the most viable path (only viable path?) is for Tesla to capture the profits and share a percentage with the equipment owner.

Since the payoff to the homeowner happens "in front of the meter," it gets around the bureaucratic nightmare of fixing the perverse incentives in electricity pricing (eg the flat rate problem /u/rr808 mentions). All you need is one large aggregator to participate in the real-time wholesale market, issue commands to the "fleet," and divvy up the profits.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by maxerickson on Sunday July 10, 2022 @10:42AM (#32045213)
Tesla could make an open API at just let whoever capture the profits.

Then owners could group together on their own terms to get market power.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by schiffern on Sunday July 10, 2022 @11:43AM (#32045736)
>Tesla could make an open API at just let whoever capture the profits.

Presumably this is supposed to be different from what I said (sharing profits), so are you suggesting the service provider should take 0%?

>Then owners could group together on their own terms to get market power.

Thats precisely the part consumers don't want to do (and where Tesla can add value): aggregation and Autobidder.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by maxerickson on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:04PM (#32045919)
API on the car, not on the service. A way for the owner of the car to control what the car is doing remotely.

If there are thousands of dollars on the line, third parties will bid against Tesla...

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by YZF on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:13PM (#32046594)
I think the API already exists since you can use the phone app (e.g.) to control charging. I haven't looked at this for some time but while the API isn't/wasn't open it's been reverse engineered and I think there's an ecosystem using those APIs (not for this purpose but for other purposes).

EDIT: I think in my location all that has to happen for demand to shift is for the power company (BC Hyrdo in this case) to offer different rates. They can do this statically or dynamically and one way or another things will shift. As a person I can figure out to charge my car or heat my house/water or whatnot for a lower cost. I don't think they care.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by abraae on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:55PM (#32047717)
Your edit is on the money.

We switched to a new power company purely based on rates. They offer free power for a 3 hour slot between 9pm and midnight.

We spent $2k on hardware to take advantage - a 7kw fast charger for the EV and a clockwork timer for the water tank.

In return we could load shift so much that 45% of our power is now free. That's with no other behavior changes (well one small change - family members became aware that having long hot showers in the day meant a lukewarm shower at night).

All super simple, and all driven from the bottom up by specific rates.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by zbrozek on Sunday July 10, 2022 @03:51PM (#32048295)
That sounds pretty great. I can't imagine my utility, PG&E, doing the same. Their TOU rates start at about the same as their tiered rates and go up from there. Even under maximal load shifting that plan costs me more than the simpler (yet still complicated) plan.

Instead it's more economical for me to drive my grid dependence to zero. I'm one of the "no thanks" folks in the article.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by schiffern on Sunday July 10, 2022 @06:55PM (#32050034)
This is exactly the perverse pricing problem that Tesla (or someone else) can easily solve with aggregation+Autobidder.

Tesla knows your utility rate, including the absence or presence of time-of-use billing. They also have access to the real-time market behind the meter. In this position, they can always Do The Right Thing to minimize total cost of EV charging (electric bill minus earned Autobidder revenue).

In your case the Right Thing sounds like choosing the tiered PG&E rate, and letting Tesla aggregation pay you for load shifting.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by zbrozek on Monday July 11, 2022 @10:44AM (#32056826)
I have no interest in letting Tesla, or anybody else, capture that value. Nor do I have any interest in propping up a failing grid at my own expense. I've been DIYing-at comically low cost-my way towards an off-grid electrified home. And I've driven up my energy consumption and quality of life dramatically while also reducing my costs and environmental footprint.

Looking at my data so far, it's cheaper for me to have a tiny gasoline generator to fill in under the quite-rare shortfalls (e.g., the two continuously rainy weeks in December where I don't quite charge up my batteries during the day, and I need to run heating overnight) than it is to pay the minimum grid connection charge.

I expect that as our local grid costs continue to skyrocket at about 4x CPI, and with distributed generation costs coming down, that many more folks will do the same.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by abraae on Sunday July 10, 2022 @06:38PM (#32049882)
It's fascinating how the economics play out. Thanks to this deal, it no longer makes sense for us to go solar or to have a house battery. So the power company has us as a loyal customer (at least, while they keep offering this deal).
Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by avianlyric on Sunday July 10, 2022 @07:27PM (#32050303)
Every EV already has this API, it’s just exposed to the “charger” not the internet.

Because all EV need to negotiate with the charger their plugged into to determine if they can charge, and how fast. It pretty easy to build a charger compatible with any EV that simply caps the cars charging rate until electricity is cheap.

Here in Europe at least, there are already several companies that make these chargers, including ones that just MitM the cable between your car and your normal charger, and allow you get better rates though aggregation with other owners.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by schiffern on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:32PM (#32046163)
Thanks. Yes, a more open car API would be welcome.

For V1G (ie one-way demand response charging), I'd prefer cars also have a Set It And Forget It option:

Always charge immediately to [ 30% ], then charge to [ 80% ] by [ 7 AM ] [ weekdays ].

And then it just Does The Right Thing.

For configuring stationary batteries, the equivalent would be:

Always reserve [ 40% ] backup, then trade with the grid when payout exceeds [ 20¢/kWh ].

Current generation Tesla systems allow some of this configuration, but not all.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by BolexNOLA on Sunday July 10, 2022 @10:54AM (#32045320)
I hate navigating utilities as it is, now I need to join/form a co-op just to use my car?

I don’t know man. This sounds awful. Like an even worse HOA. Unless I’m misunderstanding your concept here.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by maxerickson on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:03PM (#32045910)
No, do what you want, stick with giving Tesla thousands of dollars a year instead of opting into the coop that runs the simple algorithm and gives you the money.
Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by schiffern on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:09PM (#32045948)
What makes you think a "simple algorithm" from a cash-strapped coop can compete with more sophisticated systems?

If better systems (eg Tesla's Autobidder) generate more revenue, then even after paying a percentage you still come out ahead.

Meanwhile an under-sophisticated algorithm will just end up being the "dumb money" in the marketplace.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by londons_explore on Sunday July 10, 2022 @04:28PM (#32048667)
The algorithm isn't awfully complex. If it's 6pm, and you need your car charged by 6am, and you need to be charging for 6 hours, then you just purchase the cheapest 6 energy futures for the 6 hours you know you'll need, and don't purchase the other 6.

If at any time during the night the prices of the unpurchased futures drop below that of the ones you have purchased, you can sell one and buy a different one (rescheduling the charge).

There isn't any better algorithm within those constraints. As long as the energy futures market is a fully liquid market, the price you'll get will be (on average) equal to the spot price you would have paid if you'd made the ideal scheduling decisions and bought on the spot market.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by schiffern on Sunday July 10, 2022 @07:21PM (#32050248)
Fair point. For car charging the algorithm can be relatively simple (if suboptimal due to imperfect assumptions like "fully liquid"), but for stationary batteries + solar it gets much more complex.

I still suspect more sophisticated players will find easy ways to "game" such an algorithm (eg pre-bidding). Whenever you have a large herd of predictable sheep, it's an opportunity for a wolf.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by BolexNOLA on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:22PM (#32046072)
I’m specifically saying this “energy HOA” sounds miserable/time-consuming just to run my car, and if people immediately have a negative reaction like that then the “solution” is potentially very flawed, if for no other reason than it hurts adoption. There’s no need to get so hostile over a simple critique. I also don’t think it’s reasonable to assume a “simple algorithm” will solve this.

For the record, I don’t own a Tesla and I don’t want to. I have no plans of giving Elon Musk any of my business.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by andrepd on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:23PM (#32046082)
> is for Tesla to capture the profits and trickle down some crumbs to the equipment owner.

Capitalist labour relations, but now with your car manufacturer :)

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by avianlyric on Sunday July 10, 2022 @07:20PM (#32050233)
I don’t think this is quite true, although their maybe local politics that are making it true in certain areas.

Each of the demand response techniques you mentioned address a different concern, and are all complimentary to each other.

Planning and managing grid capacity happens on many different timescales. From decade long planning of large scale infrastructure, through to the millisecond-by-millisecond management that occurs during a grid crisis.

Each of the techniques you mention create a demand response effect at different timescales.

Simple multi-rate tariffs that offer different rates and different times of day, create macro scale changes in a grids daily demand curve. Reducing the peaks, and filling in the troughs, allowing distributors to reduce their total future CapEx spend.

Virtual power plants like Tesla allow distributors to “buy electricity” for cheaper than buying it from peaked plants for periods where they known that total demand is going high, and cheaper energy producers are already saturated. You’re operating on timescale looking a few hours or a few days into the future here. It’s important to note that Tesla themselves are creating addition value here, beyond simple tariff changes. Teslas virtual power plant will be committing themselves to a guaranteed load reduction at a specific period of time in the near future, failure to produce that reduction means Tesla has to buy extra electricity to make up the shortfall at extremely inflated rates. So Tesla create value through the efficient and accurate aggregation and management of many cars, dealing with issue like cars being unplugged, or already charged and varying levels of owner participation.

Electricity distributors requesting remote control is less effective than Tesla’s approach, because the distributor now has to carry all the risk associated with loads ignoring their commands. It’s basically impossible for them to mandate control, not unless their gonna employ the plug police to make sure nobody wires up a heater without telling them. Ultimately distributors can create and enforce load mandates by simple refusing to upgrade electrical connections to provide more supply, and downrating existing ones. This is already how industrial electricity supply works.

The number of types of demand response a specific load supports isn’t zero sum, it’s multiplicative. Each additional form of demand response supported creates additional value, and markets already exist to price that value.

In parts of the world with well functioning energy markets, the issues of how best to do demand response are handled by the energy markets. Each type of demand response (generally measured on two axis, speed of response and reliability of response) creates value for different market players. They can then create schemes to buy different types of demand response that fits their needs, or it can be bought though existing markets. The final piece of the puzzle is figuring out how properly aggregate individual loads into a large enough fleet that it can have a meaningful impact on the grid.

Unfortunately you changing the charging times on a Tesla has very little impact on the grid. But changing the charging time of 10,000 Tesla’s, now that might buy you a seat in the energy markets.