Presumably this is supposed to be different from what I said (sharing profits), so are you suggesting the service provider should take 0%?
>Then owners could group together on their own terms to get market power.
Thats precisely the part consumers don't want to do (and where Tesla can add value): aggregation and Autobidder.
If there are thousands of dollars on the line, third parties will bid against Tesla...
EDIT: I think in my location all that has to happen for demand to shift is for the power company (BC Hyrdo in this case) to offer different rates. They can do this statically or dynamically and one way or another things will shift. As a person I can figure out to charge my car or heat my house/water or whatnot for a lower cost. I don't think they care.
We switched to a new power company purely based on rates. They offer free power for a 3 hour slot between 9pm and midnight.
We spent $2k on hardware to take advantage - a 7kw fast charger for the EV and a clockwork timer for the water tank.
In return we could load shift so much that 45% of our power is now free. That's with no other behavior changes (well one small change - family members became aware that having long hot showers in the day meant a lukewarm shower at night).
All super simple, and all driven from the bottom up by specific rates.
Instead it's more economical for me to drive my grid dependence to zero. I'm one of the "no thanks" folks in the article.
Tesla knows your utility rate, including the absence or presence of time-of-use billing. They also have access to the real-time market behind the meter. In this position, they can always Do The Right Thing to minimize total cost of EV charging (electric bill minus earned Autobidder revenue).
In your case the Right Thing sounds like choosing the tiered PG&E rate, and letting Tesla aggregation pay you for load shifting.
Looking at my data so far, it's cheaper for me to have a tiny gasoline generator to fill in under the quite-rare shortfalls (e.g., the two continuously rainy weeks in December where I don't quite charge up my batteries during the day, and I need to run heating overnight) than it is to pay the minimum grid connection charge.
I expect that as our local grid costs continue to skyrocket at about 4x CPI, and with distributed generation costs coming down, that many more folks will do the same.
Because all EV need to negotiate with the charger their plugged into to determine if they can charge, and how fast. It pretty easy to build a charger compatible with any EV that simply caps the cars charging rate until electricity is cheap.
Here in Europe at least, there are already several companies that make these chargers, including ones that just MitM the cable between your car and your normal charger, and allow you get better rates though aggregation with other owners.
For V1G (ie one-way demand response charging), I'd prefer cars also have a Set It And Forget It option:
Always charge immediately to [ 30% ], then charge to [ 80% ] by [ 7 AM ] [ weekdays ].
And then it just Does The Right Thing.
For configuring stationary batteries, the equivalent would be:
Always reserve [ 40% ] backup, then trade with the grid when payout exceeds [ 20¢/kWh ].
Current generation Tesla systems allow some of this configuration, but not all.
I don’t know man. This sounds awful. Like an even worse HOA. Unless I’m misunderstanding your concept here.
If better systems (eg Tesla's Autobidder) generate more revenue, then even after paying a percentage you still come out ahead.
Meanwhile an under-sophisticated algorithm will just end up being the "dumb money" in the marketplace.
If at any time during the night the prices of the unpurchased futures drop below that of the ones you have purchased, you can sell one and buy a different one (rescheduling the charge).
There isn't any better algorithm within those constraints. As long as the energy futures market is a fully liquid market, the price you'll get will be (on average) equal to the spot price you would have paid if you'd made the ideal scheduling decisions and bought on the spot market.
I still suspect more sophisticated players will find easy ways to "game" such an algorithm (eg pre-bidding). Whenever you have a large herd of predictable sheep, it's an opportunity for a wolf.
For the record, I don’t own a Tesla and I don’t want to. I have no plans of giving Elon Musk any of my business.
Then owners could group together on their own terms to get market power.