News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by mcv on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @05:07AM (#31998494)
I noticed I kept switching between several principles. Possibly triggered by the details of the problem. Some of the principles:

1. If you're able to act, you are already responsible for the outcome. Inaction is a choice too. There's no intrinsic moral difference between pulling the lever or not.

2. Acting from a position of ignorance is irresponsible. Better not to act than to take the risk of making the situation worse. (This contradicts #1.)

3. The person who tied these people to the track is the one who really carries the responsibility to this tragedy, not me.

All three of these are valid, and yet contradictory to some extent.

Apparently I solved philosophy at the cost of 59 lives. Not sure it was worth that sacrifice.

Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by eurasiantiger on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @05:25AM (#31998596)
Imagine being at a railyard at the time of a crash and being seen throwing a switch in front of a moving train.

There’s no real-world case where that person is not considered responsible.

Not to mention that trains really cannot go over switches at speed. A runaway trolley would probably derail at the switch if it was set on the side track.

Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by Ensorceled on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @08:16AM (#31999734)
> Not to mention that trains really cannot go over switches at speed.

As someone who used to work on the railway (Maintenance of Way Workers Unite!!); in real life ... I'd throw the switch hoping to derail the train!

Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by mcv on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:13AM (#32001256)
Exactly. In real life, I'd try to derail the train, and then call the police so they can figure out who tied these people to the track. The problem is a very artificial situation, and therefore hard to apply to real world ethics.
Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by Aeolun on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @05:28AM (#31998618)
I think it’s reasonable to assume the trolley goes fast enough to do the deed, but not fast enough it couldn’t round the bend.
Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by littlestymaar on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @06:02AM (#31998829)
That's clearly a reasonable assumption, since a trolley will kill people underneath at any speed, no matter how low (the slower, the more horrible the death will be though…)
Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by eurasiantiger on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @03:16PM (#32005491)
I posit there is a small positive non-lethal speed. Where are the MythBusters… :)
Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by _nalply on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @05:40AM (#31998700)
If you assume you make an ass out of you and me.
Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by rootusrootus on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @09:55AM (#32000943)
> Inaction is a choice too

Only in the narrow situation where you know all possible outcomes and have a sufficient time to consider them. In the real world, given a limited amount of time and ignorance of many details, inaction is not even remotely the same as action.

Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by karategeek6 on Sunday July 10, 2022 @05:11PM (#32049072)
Not sure why you state #2 contradicts #1. If you are in a position of ignorance, choosing inaction (unless and until said ignorance can be rectified, anyway) is the correct action.