News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by bdhe on Friday November 04, 2011 @12:00PM (#3196532)
I'm completely speculating, but I wonder if the bottleneck of math being hard is tied directly to how notoriously bad the standard of math in K-12 education is? I've always wondered how in the US the public school system is very weak (or at least people constantly complain about it being so) and yet they have some of the best technical colleges in the world (MIT, Stanford, Caltech, etc.) I've always wondered how students cope up with this big jump from high school to college.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by repiret on Friday November 04, 2011 @12:47PM (#3196746)
I think that there is a very high variance in math education (and people) in public K-12 schools. My high school math consisted of advanced algebra, proof-based geometry, trig and a smattering of calculus. This seems to be typical for college-bound student across the country. I went to a second-tier technical university (CalPoly, San Luis Obispo) and I was well prepared for the typical first year physics and math classes. From what I can tell, the first-tier schools you cite have substantially similar first year math and science curriculum.

That said, I know people who went to the same school middle and high schools I went to, but who were never able to get past the introductory algebra class I took in 8'th grade. Sure, some people probably got better or worse teachers, but I believe some peoples brains are just better at math than others.

Then why does the US look so bad at math? I don't know. I suspect that both of these statements are true:

1. Many countries have better alternate education paths for people who aren't that interested in college. People on these alternate paths are excluded from foreign statistics, while people who ought to be on them dilute US statistics.

2. Doing poorly in school is more acceptable to Amercan parents than it is to parents in many other developed countries. (Ironically, this may be because a lack of alternate education paths led parents to becmoe disillusioned with the value of school)

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by coffeedrinker on Friday November 04, 2011 @02:20PM (#3197138)
We home educate our kids and I can tell you the differences in math ability between each child.

One of my daughters can hit anything thrown at her. My other daughter is more advanced than most kids her age at math, but I know that she has already learned more math than she will ever use in her life (she is in eight grade but is doing very advanced algebra). Her interests will never lead her to a career that requires more than she already knows.

The problem is pushing everyone to one standard, when they do not need it. It makes them feel stupid, and is a waste of time that could be used developing other skills.

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by hemancuso on Friday November 04, 2011 @12:18PM (#3196607)
By selecting ~500 engineering students out of a pool of 3+ million.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by cynest on Friday November 04, 2011 @12:49PM (#3196758)
Current undergrad taking math courses at one of the colleges mentioned. I would say that what you suggested is definitely part of the problem. The other part is that even the good* programs in high school are very different in structure from university math courses. There are very few study skills developed because most of the focus is on remembering the testing algorithm and does not necessarily include the rigor required to fully understand mathematics.

*good in this context means AP level. This is not because AP is the correct measurement, it is because AP and the like is the measurement used to judge high schools

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by jtbigwoo on Friday November 04, 2011 @02:37PM (#3197194)
In high school, the track I was on ended with high school seniors taking calculus at the local engineering college. No AP classes were offered where I lived, but I'm convinced that one college level class did more for me than a half-dozen AP classes would have. Especially because it forced my high-school math teacher to think more about preparing students for college-level work.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by cynest on Friday November 04, 2011 @03:28PM (#3197394)
> Especially because it forced my high-school math teacher to think more about preparing students for college-level work.

I think the intended preparation is actually really important. With AP the flow is Learn ch2 algorithm > learn ch3 algorithm>...> do well on test > not have to take calc in college. If you actually prepare a course for rigorous understanding, I suspect you might end up sacrificing your AP score somewhat for much greater gains later on. However, the system only cares about that short term result.

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by March_Hare on Friday November 04, 2011 @04:04PM (#3197505)
> Especially because it forced my high-school math teacher to think more about preparing students for college-level work.

I believe high school students who take college courses can be a great asset for their high school for this very reason.

As a junior in high school I took college algebra at a community college in the evenings. As a result of the conversations with my math teacher, she made many changes to the subjects she covered in her pre-calc and algebra 2 classes.

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by brohee on Friday November 04, 2011 @12:16PM (#3196600)
It's easy, the American universities are good because they attract plenty of foreign students coming from places where the universities may not be as good but where high schools are arguably much better.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by DevX101 on Friday November 04, 2011 @12:27PM (#3196647)
This isn't very true for undergrad.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by sp332 on Friday November 04, 2011 @01:29PM (#3196927)
Most of the students who make it to Caltech in a math program didn't depend on the K-12 "system" to teach them math. It's practically a requirement to do a lot of self-teaching outside of school.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by carpdiem on Friday November 04, 2011 @03:02PM (#3197300)
I don't know about MIT and Stanford, but I went to Caltech, and while there are first-year courses with names like 'Calculus', they are categorically nothing like the first-year courses at UCs or CSUs.

To put things into perspective, there is zero AP credit offered at Caltech. The only way to skip classes is to pass Caltech's own placement exams. I took the first placement exam (after finishing the entire AP math curriculum, as well as the entire math curriculum at the local community college—through linear algebra, diff eqns, and multivariable calc), got a 96% on Caltech's placement exam, and was recommended to take an extra, remedial mathematics course in addition to the regular freshman load to help bring me up to speed.

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by InclinedPlane on Friday November 04, 2011 @03:34PM (#3197420)
In what way are those first year Calculus courses different at Caltech? I'm quite curious.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by splat on Friday November 04, 2011 @05:26PM (#3197753)
As another (recent) Caltech grad, I'll take a stab this. The Caltech intro calc class is very heavily proof-based. We started with easy problems that had nothing to do with calculus like proving that 1/sqrt(3) is irrational, went into epsilon-delta proofs for limits, and continued on to showing that the Dirichlet function is discontinuous everywhere. I don't think we evaluated a single integral in that class.

A strange feature of the class was that the weeks where we studied derivatives were a lot harder than the weeks when we studied integrals. Although derivatives are a lot easier to evaluate than integrals, it's a lot harder to prove that they exist. Most of our problems were proving the existence of derivatives and integrals, not evaluating them, so it was a weird inversion in what is normally considered difficult in calculus.

If you want a sample of the problems, here's one of the problem sets from this year's class:

http://www.math.caltech.edu/%7E2011-12/1term/ma001a1/homewor...

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by InclinedPlane on Friday November 04, 2011 @07:57PM (#3198274)
Oh, that's just elementary analysis. That's still "calculus" of course, but in most colleges you might not be expected to take that unless you were a math major. I can respect that.

(Note: I studied math as well as chemistry and CS at a state college so my background is a little unusual.)

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by gtani on Friday November 04, 2011 @01:21PM (#3196887)
There's still a reasonable number of public schools in middle class areas in the US that offer good educations. The interesting population is the eng/science/math majors at good colleges who didn't go to such great public or private high schools, how did they get leapfrogged? I remember some of my friends going to community college classes while in high school, math camps, programming comps, stuff like that.

Those program offerings are really important, they're like a parallel education track to public K-12. Now there's Khan Academy, the MIT and Stanford courses online, all kinds of resources, but you have to get motivated/gifted together with like minded ones.

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by milesskorpen on Friday November 04, 2011 @01:49PM (#3197016)
The article specifically says this isn't the main issue--many of the students dropping out are the people with the highest SAT math scores, and a bevy of AP calculus/science classes under their belt. In theory, these should be our strongest students.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by forensic on Friday November 04, 2011 @04:04PM (#3197504)
It's really simple. Smart people are not going to work 1000 times harder for less payoff.

Smart students with everything going for them get to make this decision:

(A) Dedicate their entire life at college to doing useless problem sets. No free time. No social life. No girlfriends. Spend all your time with stinky nerds drilling on useless sets. Then get out of school and make $80k doing the engineering slog. Max out your salary at $140k, 20 years down the road.

(B) Take easy classes while being a professional partier. At parties, have loads of sex and take lots of drugs while meeting many many people. Build up 1000+ Facebook friends and forge lifelong bonds with important well-connected people. Get your degree and use your connections to get hired for $80k. Have your employer then pay for your MBA. Max out your salary at $400k 20 years down the road, not including bonuses and side deal opportunities.

Phillip Greenspun was right. Unless you're a masochist or a social reject, engineering is for foreign students. A top American student from a good family has no incentive to do engineering: not lifestyle, not financial.

When it comes to software this is even more true because you don't even need an engineering degree to write software. Paul Graham has a philosophy degree and most of his wealth came from people skills: convincing Blackwell and Morris to hack for him, and later convincing young engineers to hack for him.

Steve Jobs vs Steve Wozniak is another perfect example. Woz did the work, Jobs got the glory. Woz stayed home nights hacking while Jobs was out fucking the prom queen and taking credit. Our society does not reward engineers so anyone with the ability and foresight to be a doctor, dentist, MBA, or clinical psychologist is not going to torture themselves.

Hacker News entrepreneurs are just a bunch of masochists who never learned that partying, taking drugs and having sex is more fun and pays better than writing Ruby apps.

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by Locke1689 on Friday November 04, 2011 @04:39PM (#3197618)
FYI, medicine has a very bad expected value for time input. MBA and engineering are decent -- not great, but OK. The probability of making decent money is pretty good, while the probability of making a lot of money is small.

If you're smart (and I mean really smart), finance is generally a good bet. Once again, adjusted for time input it's not great but it does have a higher expected value.

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by forensic on Friday November 04, 2011 @05:03PM (#3197683)
You're still missing the real value, which is not the "degree" but rather the connections.

Just make friends with rich people and get them to hire you at their friend's giant corporation where their job is to undermine democracy and fool people. It's easy and pays well.

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by silverlake on Friday November 04, 2011 @05:48PM (#3197841)
Paul Graham's doctorate in computer science probably helped a bit.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by hagy on Friday November 04, 2011 @07:12PM (#3198134)
That’s a bit of an over-generalization. While there are individuals that can use the party-sex-drugs track as a networking opportunity into future lucrative careers, such individual are an exception, not the rule. Most students on the party-sex–drugs track are just enjoying their youth (and racking up student loans). I’ll agree that if you’re a young Machiavelli attending an elite school, then rubbing shoulders with your wealthy classmates can work out quite well.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn ... by omlette on Friday November 04, 2011 @07:20PM (#3198153)
> Paul Graham has a philosophy degree and most of his wealth came from people skills: convincing Blackwell and Morris to hack for him, and later convincing young engineers to hack for him.

id think having a deep enough knowledge on lisp to fill two books probably had something to do with it as well.