But it's not safe to do anything with unbounded time on a realtime thread, and malloc takes unbounded time. You should also mlock() any large pieces of memory you're using, or at least touch them first, to avoid swapins.
(this is not so much an issue with linux but with your threading library)
I'm completely in agreement that you shouldn't be mallocing, that was kind of my point - if you just got a key change from the cable stream and you can't get it decoded within your small number of millisecond window before the on-the-wire crypto changes you're screwed (I chased one of these once that only happened once a month when you paid your cable bill .....)
If your threading library isn't capable of handling priority inheritance then it's probably Linux's fault for making it not easy enough to do that. This is a serious issue on AMP (aka big.little) processors, if everything has waits on the slow cores with no inheritance then everything will be slow.
>If you want a good malloc impl just use tcmalloc or jemalloc and be done with it
This wasn't applicable until relatively recently.
... it still does ? I had a case a year or so ago (on then-latest Linux / GCC / etc.) where a very sporadic allocation of 40-something bytes (very exactly, inserting a couple of int64 in an unordered_map at the wrong time) in a real-time thread was enough to go from "ok" to "unuseable"
modern engines generally have a memory handler, which means that mallocs are usually coached in some type of asset management. you are also discouraged from extending working memory of the scene suddenly. When I was doing gamedev, even then, there was no reason to big malloc because everything was already done for you with good guardrails
I did, in fact, call him out on that. I did not know exactly how those plugins worked then(though I have a much better idea now) but I already knew that it couldn't be so easy. The actual VST devs I shared it with concurred.
But it looks like he's simply learned more ways of blaming his tools since then.
It's interesting that LLVM is suffering so horrifically using default malloc. I really wish the author did a deeper investigation into why exactly.
Benchmarking Malloc with Doom 3 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31631352 - June 2022 (30 comments)
Where do people get their opinions from? It seems like opinions now spread like memes - someone you respect/has done something in the world says it, you repeat it without verifying any of their points. It seems like gamedev has the highest "C++ bad and we should all program in C" commmunity out there.
If you want a good malloc impl just use tcmalloc or jemalloc and be done with it