News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by ekianjo on Saturday July 02, 2022 @09:51AM (#31958964)
Erm, reusing is more effective than building a new computer from scratch. New chips are not environmentally friendly to make, use large amount of pure water, etc...

related article from a few years ago about the Z400:

https://boilingsteam.com/gaming-on-a-cheap-xeon-the-hp-z400-...

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by iasay on Saturday July 02, 2022 @10:24AM (#31959230)
Not when you’re paying the electricity bill it’s not.

My old workstation cost me a 14” MacBook Pro in power in 5 years.

Plus you can get new in box Lenovo mini PCs with 11th gen i5 in for less than the price of a second hand Xeon desktop that’s actually usable now. They pull average 30 watts.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by hexo on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:09AM (#31959660)
OK, let's calculate! Old PC amortized to 130W constantnly, 24/7, @ 20c per kWh = 0.624$ per day, that is 227.76 per year. New workstation today is like ~4000$. So that means you'd have to run it more than 17 years at that price of electricity to be on par with price of new computer, not counting electricity for new PC.

I've actually was able to turn off all heaters during winter and heat my house using computers only! I'd say, "higher" TDP of older CPU was really an advantage here. And, let's be real, new high performance CPUs arent low-TDP either (270W for new AMDs), or GPUs (350W range for high end gaming card).

So, I'd really say it's environmentally friendlier to use waste heat as house heating than using "space heaters" only. (I really do have to heat using electricity, as I don't have gas nor any other source.)

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by loeg on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:57AM (#31960101)
Your $4000 figure is way too high for something comparable with the ancient workstation. Try $800. And 130W might be low.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by znpy on Saturday July 02, 2022 @02:47PM (#31961345)
I thought the same. We’re not comparing old workstations to new workstations, we’re comparing old workstations to current day desktop computers.

An average build is more likely in the range of $1250 +/- 250$

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by maccard on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:46PM (#31961754)
130w is definitely low. My Xeon workstation is closer to 250w.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by hexo on Saturday July 02, 2022 @06:26PM (#31962996)
I've just measured it with wattmeter. Xeon E5-2697v2, 64GB ram, SSD + 2x HDD, GTX1080. Excluding monitor, that might add another 15W according to its "energy usage bar" which sits at about 25%.

110W "idle" with firefox running + few opengl programs.

160W at steam startup, then it jumps between 120W and 160W. It stabilizes at 110W in about 2 minutes.

130-230W when compiling emacs (takes about 30 seconds).

150W when loading Facebook in Firefox. Then stable at 110W again.

175W-180W running Prison Architect. Very safe to add another 220W when running GPU heavy game (thats not very relevant here, new GPUs consumes ~same or more power).

I'd say my "randomly guessed" 130W amortized is pretty OK. And remember, this guess was for reference only, scale it to your needs.

Of course it can get higher when having a lot of things up and running, with a lot of active tabs in firefox.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by ac29 on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:58PM (#31961840)
It runs at 250W 24/7?
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by metadat on Saturday July 02, 2022 @04:56PM (#31962315)
170w to 300w for an older (2010-2015 era) dual-processor Xeon idling is what I've measured at my house across numerous Supermicro builds.

2018 and newer server chips may have better low-power idle mode support.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by metadat on Saturday July 02, 2022 @08:28PM (#31963845)
I want to add that I do thoroughly enjoy and appreciate my trusty old 2U Supermicro dualie from 2014-era Xeon parts.

Even if it does idle at 170w, the build was less than $2k, it has 50 cores, 384GB ram, tons of storage.. 1 year uptime, so sick! Has not let me down yet! Even if the mobo croaks, it's easy to source a cost-effective replacement from fleabay.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by maccard on Saturday July 02, 2022 @06:20PM (#31962962)
Welli turn it off out of working hours but it idles at 250w yeah. Peak power draw is much higher.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by ekianjo on Sunday July 03, 2022 @12:34AM (#31965096)
250w at idle? Sounds unlikely
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by maccard on Sunday July 03, 2022 @05:26AM (#31966361)
I actually wasn't clear - I have a dual slot Xeon so it's really two xeons. But yes,it really is just shy of 250w idle
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by iasay on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:13AM (#31959706)
Where does your 20c/kWh come from?

In summer what to you do with that excess heat?

Far more nuanced than trite calculations chosen to back up your conclusion.

Also you’re rebasing the argument on a new $4000 spend when you can spend $400 on a mini PC with the same performance as an old Xeon as suggested.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by hexo on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:20AM (#31959768)
20(euro)cents used to be average price in my country. I actually have much lower price (about one third of that) because I don't have other energy source. It does not really matter where that price came from, as it can nicely serve as reference point and you can easily scale it according to your price of electricity.

Also, $400 mini PC have performance nowhere near workstation, since RAM only costs more, not even thinking about gaming GPU or price of decent SSDs and HDDs.

What did I do with excess heat? Opened window and turned off POWER8 energy hog.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by iasay on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:22AM (#31959779)
$400 mini PC gets you an i5-11500T with NVME SSD that will take 128Gb of RAM. Some of them even pop up with NVidia T400 in them. New with Lenovo warranty on eBay.

The i5-11500T has better single and multi thread performance.

Sure you won’t get an RTX in it but that’s a 1% case really when we’re talking software engineering.

That’s a hell of a lot better value proposition than a 5+ year old Xeon which is what we’re seeing suggested here.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by hexo on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:26AM (#31959823)
Just that 128GB DDR4 is more than 550usd in my country.

GPU with 2GB of VRAM is not much today, my 4k desktop consumes 1.6G vram and i'm not even running any game.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:10PM (#31961495)
>my 4k desktop consumes 1.6G vram and i'm not even running any game

What desktop is that? I ran Windows 11 desktop with youtube and bluray rips fine even while allocating only 512MB of VRAM, though the more you allocate it the more it will use, to cache and speed up various frequently used apps, but even with 512MB it still worked fine.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by iasay on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:30AM (#31959862)
Fits in your $4000 workstation budget :)
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by hexo on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:33AM (#31959891)
Also, have you seen high-end laptop prices? Dell XPS is easily 3k+$.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday July 02, 2022 @12:13PM (#31960232)
We have them at work, XPS are overpriced garbage machines that just look and cost premium. Do avoid.

Midrange machines <1000€ from Lenovo and HP make great workhorses at a fraction of the price.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by iasay on Saturday July 02, 2022 @12:16PM (#31960259)
As an owner of one I completely agree with this.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by iasay on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:42AM (#31959969)
Yeah I have a fully loaded XPS 5500 and a 14” MBP
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by TimPC on Saturday July 02, 2022 @12:03PM (#31960163)
If your computers produce so much heat that they heat your house during winter you should also factor in the extra AC costs in summer.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by schwartzworld on Saturday July 02, 2022 @01:45PM (#31960931)
Can't speak for OP, but if you leave your windows open in the summer, waste heat would be a non-issue
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by hexo on Saturday July 02, 2022 @12:22PM (#31960313)
It's not "that much heat", it's that good insulation. Also, I don't really need or want AC, I love hot weather.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by iforgotpassword on Saturday July 02, 2022 @10:37AM (#31959349)
Op specifically said environmental perspective, so it doesn't matter whether you pay 5ct or 90ct per kWh.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by iasay on Saturday July 02, 2022 @10:48AM (#31959437)
It does however depend on how much coal you shovel into it.

The point is you can’t go “the environment” and throw half the concerns out of the window. It’s way more nuanced than that.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by iforgotpassword on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:29AM (#31959857)
That however is a fair point. I would be genuinely interested in the actual numbers. Gut feeling tells me buying a new computer has to be much much worse than running a ten year old machine even on coal, since a lot of these components come from all across the world, get produced in countries some of which have lax to no regulation regarding pollution, use of toxic substances, and so on. The hard thing is probably trying to break this down to one individual computer being made.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by naniwaduni on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:05AM (#31959627)
It absolutely matters if those kWh are backed by environmental damage. Also if you can spend that money elsewhere to reduce environmental damage.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by scns on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:37AM (#31959926)
My plan was upgrading my i5 4460 and get the best bang for my buck. Was eyeing an i7 4790K which would have cost 140€. Got a workstation with a xeon equivalent to the 4770, with a quadro K2200, an intel dc ssd (RSP new ~400$, a 2TB HD and 32GB RAM for 180€ instead.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by stigz on Saturday July 02, 2022 @12:05PM (#31960175)
It's not about you, bud. Speaking at a global level it is more efficient.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by iasay on Saturday July 02, 2022 @12:12PM (#31960223)
Show me the calculation.
Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by Wowfunhappy on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:37AM (#31959918)
In a world where we had a reasonable tax on carbon, environmental friendliness and individual economic rationality would be one and the same.

But we don't live in that world. So they are not.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by AtlasBarfed on Saturday July 02, 2022 @07:43PM (#31963570)
One would think economics would have been onboard with environmentalism a lot longer ago, but economics as a culture/institution is very much aligned with the ultra-rich.

Economics, the leadership and prominent members of its social network, were all too willing to rubberstamp the whims of the "elites", future of the human race be damned.

Economics the "science" is a lot like the police "union", the only acceptable union to the right because it keeps them in place, while economics the "science" is acceptable because it justifies their position and wealth.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by abraae on Saturday July 02, 2022 @04:02PM (#31961863)
If ever there was a glove perfectly fitted for the invisible hand of the market, it's saving our planet by taxing carbon.

Yet here we remain, whining about why it can never work.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by dtgriscom on Saturday July 02, 2022 @10:28AM (#31959265)
Citation? There's a cost to generating/transmitting energy, there's a cost to building/shipping new computers. Any idea which is "worse" for the environment (for some definition of "worse")?

I'm not being snippy; I honestly don't know. Personally, if I need a solution that's good for a number of years, I'd go for a new, efficient computer rather than reuse an old toaster.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by johnfernow on Saturday July 02, 2022 @01:56PM (#31961008)
No figures for a Xeon machine in particular, but some other figures for a general idea (from The Carbon Footprint of Everything by Mike Berners-Lee, 2020 second edition, page 140):

Manufacturing a computer:

* 326 kg CO2e: 13-inch MacBook Pro, 128GB storage

* 475 kg CO2e: 15-inch Dell Precision 5530, 256GB storage

* 620 kg CO2e: 16-inch MacBook Pro, 1TB storage

Using it:

* 4g CO2e per hour on 13-inch MacBook Pro

* 6g CO2e per hour on 16-inch MacBook Pro

* 20g CO2e per hour on average-efficient laptop

* 98g CO2e per hour on desktop computer with screen

* 130g CO2e per hour on gaming PC with screen

The figures for using it are based on the US grid's typical mix of coal, renewables, nuclear, etc. In places with a greener grid, such as the UK, the figures are different (there's a different edition of the book for the US and UK version, and possibly other regions as well.)

So we don't have figures for the emissions for a Xeon machine, either in manufacturing or usage. And these figures are estimates, of course, not precise measurements. But they help us to get a good picture of the scale of the impact.

Let's assume that you use your computer 12 hours a day, 365 days a year. On a standard gaming PC with a screen, that'd be 569400g CO2e per year, or 569kg. The big question then is how much more inefficient is a Xeon machine than a standard gaming PC. If the Xeon machine emits 1.33x more than a standard gaming PC, that'd put its yearly usage emissions at 757kg CO2e, so if you used your machine for 5 years, than the difference in emissions would be 940kg CO2e between the Xeon and standard gaming PC, which would probably be enough to justify buying a new machine. But if it's only 1.1x more inefficient, than that difference would be 285 kg, not nearly enough to justify a new machine (and probably still the case even if you use the machine for 10 years.)

Ultimately, I'm not sure that we have the information necessary to definitively answer this, but all other things being equal, I'm skeptical that the CPU alone will make an enormous difference in power draw in day to day usage. A newer CPU will be more efficient when at 100% usage, but does it draw significantly less power when at idle? I don't know. But if anyone else has found any information that could help, I'd love to check it out. That said, there are plenty of second-hand machines that are more efficient than a Xeon machine. Once there are no second-hand efficient machines left, it'd be worthwhile to dig in deep on the emissions of old Xeon machines versus newer more efficient machines, but right now you can just buy used and refurbished efficient machines, so I'd probably just recommend that.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by gpapilion on Saturday July 02, 2022 @03:31PM (#31961650)
A typical server tdp will vary a lot depending on the components buts it’s a safe bet to look at 1u being right around 1000w for a recent Xeon.

It’s also the opposite older equipment for servers. There are lower tdps for older equipment and for a haswell or broadwell it may use 20-30% less energy than a typical server sku. The compute per watt has increased, but the power draw of modern server cpus are probably much higher than you would expect.

Re:Why your next home computer should be an old Xeon worksta... by wiseowise on Saturday July 02, 2022 @11:56AM (#31960089)
They’re going to be made regardless of whether you buy them or not.