News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT engineers fly first-ever plane with no moving parts (... by pclmulqdq on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:27PM (#31934887)
I'm not sure that the guy who patented this is considered a "serious" scientist. After all, he did patent a technology from the 60's.

Otherwise, this just seems to be MIT being MIT: creating a trivial improvement on an old technology (in this case, moving the boost converter onto the airplane to avoid a tether wire), and publicizing the hell out of it because it's cool.

Re:MIT engineers fly first-ever plane with no moving parts (... by tytso on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:00PM (#31937801)
Keep in mind that the MIT Press office != the professors at MIT. It's actually quite common for any University's press office to be clueless about the research being done at the university, and it is their job to make as big of a splash as possible.

This is much like the oft-cited issue that the reporters aren't responsible for the headlines --- that is picked by the editors to make as big of a splash as possible.

As far as "patenting a technology from the 60's", even an incremental improvement on an old idea is still patentable. The real test is whether the patent cited the prior art, and you can bet that MIT Press Office didn't read the patent application before breathlessly sending out the press release.

Re:MIT engineers fly first-ever plane with no moving parts (... by pclmulqdq on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:28PM (#31938143)
That is a good point. MIT professors are usually very aware of the context of their work and the actual contributions they are making. Nevertheless, the MIT press office is a particularly egregious organization in terms of its tendency to exaggerate - my dad's lab cured cancer about 10 times in the early 2000's if you believe the press releases.

In this case, I'm not sure the MIT professor was aware of the "crackpot" invention that effectively pre-empted him. Many professors don't read patents (and there are lots of reasons why they shouldn't), and I'm not sure there was a paper.

One thing about patents is that if an invention is obvious in light of other inventions, it might not be patentable. In this case, I'm pretty sure that this combination of a technology from the 60's, a boost converter, and a LiPo battery may be "obvious" given the prevalence of other drones: it is a combination of two past inventions that fit together naturally (a drone + a propulsion technology). Of course, it will take millions of dollars worth of arguing for someone to say either way.

Re:MIT engineers fly first-ever plane with no moving parts (... by mannerheim on Thursday June 30, 2022 @10:31PM (#31941533)
See also the 'science news cycle': https://phdcomics.com/comics.php?f=1174
Re:MIT engineers fly first-ever plane with no moving parts (... by lupire on Thursday June 30, 2022 @06:52PM (#31939717)
Where is the "breathless" part?
Re:MIT engineers fly first-ever plane with no moving parts (... by xattt on Thursday June 30, 2022 @09:28PM (#31941021)
The part where the ozone that’s emitted from the high voltage field overwhelms you!
Re:MIT engineers fly first-ever plane with no moving parts (... by rbanffy on Thursday June 30, 2022 @08:07PM (#31940417)
> a trivial improvement on an old technology (in this case, moving the boost converter onto the airplane to avoid a tether wire)

I wouldn’t call building an airplane that doesn’t need to be connected to the ground by wires a minor improvement. This makes a fun gimmick into something potentially useful.

Re:MIT engineers fly first-ever plane with no moving parts (... by Dylan16807 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:19PM (#31938026)
Making it work on its own without a tether wire sounds like a substantial improvement to me.