I don’t think a library would sign up to Kanopy if it wasn’t somehow more attractive to them over DVDs.
Back when Terry Semel (ex Warner Brothers CEO) was still CEO, Yahoo! would show Oscar screeners in the cafeteria of the best films nominees around that time. Answers to your questions would be 1) No, 2) yes, 3) I dunno, employee cafeteria sized... The organizers said that we were "just in Jerry and David's living room", strongly implying that no public performance rights were obtained, but I dunno. I also don't know if the official screener discs come with appropriate rights.
My data is at least 5 years out of date. But their list price used to be $250 per movie.
Eventually, a lawyer at Google SF got a global, unlimited license for the whole company, so I didn't have to negotiate anymore. I didn't even want to ASK the Motion Picture Licensing Corp. what that cost.
So we went through Swank for years and years. Those are the two distributors who have all the Hollywood movies. There are lots of smaller distributors, too.
People who say "they should just buy the DVD" are imagining that the library can just pay $20 or whatever, and then offer it to as many users as want to watch?
I don't think it works that way for libraries. Maybe someone who knows for sure can tell us? I'm guessing that they get the right to loan out the DVD physically but not electronically.
I ran the Cinema Club at Google for 10 years, and we made our lawyers happy by always paying "public performance rights" (PPRs) for all our flicks. When you buy a DVD, you get a license for "home viewing." That does not allow you to invite members of the public in to watch. You cannot show it in your bar or restaurant or at a place of business. Maybe you, Fred Hacker, can get away with it, but a large multinational company cannot.
When I negotiated PPRs with a film distributor, they always asked these questions:
1) Is the film showing advertised outside your company?
2) Is attendance limited to employees and their guests?
3) How big is the room? (or maybe it was "what's the average attendance?")
I didn't look into what public libraries pay for their movies, but I'm pretty sure it's more than you would pay to just buy the DVD.