You have to pay them, and most of them are not very good at writing. Even with a big budget, you get a limited number of good articles per day.
If you can make writing fake news 100x cheaper, and then just throw everything at social networks and let people sort out the most viral stuff, that can change the game.
Also, computers can be faster. If something new happens today and hundred articles are written about it, a computer can quickly process them and generate hundred more articles on the same topic, than a group of humans would. (Many humans can do the writing in parallel, but each of them needs to read individually the things they want to react to.)
I don't think people, organizations, and government, pushing false narratives, is some new game. I think it's a game that people are dangerously unaware that they're already playing. Destroying the trust of content on the internet, resulting in having people be more diligent about what they believe, is, I think, almost certainly a net positive.
But, as a counter argument to myself, people are lazy and will, instead, just go to a news source that they "trust", and listen without ever questioning.
Either way, I don't see the fake news, itself, as being anything but a fleeting problem for society. The problem will continue to be people, organizations, and governments taking advantage of laziness.
For an example, imagine Dall-E 2 was released for political use. For a few weeks, we would have a flood of fakes of every politician doing every imaginable act. Society would very quickly believe none, rather than believing all.
That didn't seem to be how it worked with the election-theft narrative. People kept believing garbage from discredited sources.
GPT-3 can't create a second IEEE so it's not an issue to be worried about.
Authoritarians benefit from a society-wide lack of trust in there being any sort of consensus/objective truth. When people don't know what to believe, they either turn to conspiracy theories that claim to offer a peek behind the curtain, or more likely just tune out and hope that their favorite strongman can simplify the chaos.
There's been speculation on Twitter that the conflicting narratives from Russia itself during the invasion aren't really a political problem, since confusion makes it more difficult for the public to rally behind a counter-narrative.
There already exists far more content than anybody can read. We have developed mechanisms for filtering out content which isn't worth our time, and language models don't have any special ability to force you to read their creations.
And even if content can be placed somewhere you will read it: no matter what I put into this box you will not suddenly be susceptible to believing the unbelievable no matter whether I wrote it or whether a language model wrote it.
The value of exercising critical thinking, checking trusted curated sources, information hygiene, recognizing and avoiding manipulation tactics in news and ads will have to go up. The internet is already almost entirely unreliable without requiring any fancy AI. The listed skills will be necessary regardless any increase of politically manipulative content, advertisements or product misrepresentations.
The issue many people have with fake news is that it's a tool that can sway public opinion without any basis on facts. I'm not sure, by your response, if you find that to be problematic or not.
I think we've recently found that people haven't decided which voices to trust and can be led to believe things placed in front of them. Paired with the ability to spread that information - there is significant impact on society.
That's the reason some people have issues with fake news, from my experience.
Also, getting a computer to do something will always scale several orders of magnitude more than having billions of people do it.
> That's the reason some people have issues with fake news, from my experience.
From my experience, most people who believe Fake News is a significant problem are people who dislike WHOM some have chosen to trust.
Few see fake news coming from their preferred media sources, or supporting their preferred narrative, as highly concerning, and instead usually treat it as benign (human errors happen etc etc).
However, when it's coming from their political adversaries, or from sources they dislike, it suddenly is presented as some huge issue.
In reality, it is all the same, and people are decently good at filtering it out when it contradicts what they want to believe, and very bad at filtering it out when it agrees with them.
For an example of fake news from outlets like the NYT, the most egregious recent one has been the dismissal of the Hunter Biden laptop, calling it a Russian hoax, calling it "fake news", listing intelligence agencies (of all people) as proof of this, getting Twitter and Facebook to outright ban the New York Post article on it - when in fact everything in their article was 100% true.
How many people (especially Dem voters) have taken this story as "dangerous spread of Fake News by the NYT, Washington Post etc"?
My point was that we all have blindspots when the news sources we have chosen to trust are feeding us false information. Also, the problem isn't that people don't choose a news source to trust, it is that they choose a bad news source to trust, and this can happen for very different reasons.
Language models can now pass as human in many situations but there are already billions of humans capable of writing fake news, this isn't a new capability.
We have already created mechanisms for deciding which voices to trust and no matter how good language models get they will not be able to prevent you from visiting economist.com